2025-2026 Leafs Season

~$2.5 million/yr for 8 years
You gain 5M in cap space, 2.5M cap hit doesn't sound like a lot but not insignificant either if you factor in 8 yrs, you're always up against the cap.
I guess you have to weigh what kind of player(s) you can get for that against what you realistically believe the team's chances
are to have any serious success in the next few years, I'm not sure 5M will get enough to really push you up substantially with this team.
If you don't anticipate a real boost, maybe holding on to him for a couple more years at 2nd or 3rd pairing and then cut him loose, shave maybe 4 yrs off the obligation.
In an ideal world, I would like to see him gone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trevor Wong
Leafs play TB and Florida back to back after the Olympic break.
Tkatchuk doing his thing again picking on Kucherov and Hagel comes in and fights him.
Bennett didn't do anything cause he's going to be Hagel's teammate in a few days.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Trevor Wong
McMann has a cheap contract which is very appealing to any team.
Leafs had to pay a premium on every trade they made when they loaded up for the playoffs because they needed salary retention.

The cost of retention is typically around a 4th round pick.
It adds some value that he is cheap, but its not going to massively ramp his value.
What it might do is add more suitors, which could drive up the value a bit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trevor Wong
I've been wrong before on deadline returns, but I really doubt McMann is getting a first round pick.

Part of it is that most of the elite teams in the league have already traded their first rounders this year. The current top 5 in the league have already traded their picks (picks #28-#32), so you are then asking teams that could fall anywhere between 16-27 to move that pick. Teams #22-#27 right now are Pitt, Islanders, Boston, Buffalo, Montreal, Detroit. I don't see them giving a first for McMann, or risking a 2027 pick as those teams are not sure if they are elite moving forward.

The second part is McMann is probably a tier below of what a first rounder normally is. He's not bad though - if you move the package starts with a 2nd... maybe a 2nd/ 3rd or 4th / B or C level prospect. That package is close to the same value as a #28-#32 pick in the draft. But teams are afraid to risk trading a first round pick if it could fall before #20... or worse case trade a future first and see what happened to the Leafs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trevor Wong
Mcmann is exactly the player the Leafs need. Physical and can score. Why trade him for an unproven late round draft pick. Makes no sense to give away a player like that. Give him a contract
 
The point with McMann being cheap was that a team would be getting a player way above his pay grade. His next contract will probably be closer to 5 mill than his current 1.35 mill. It's as if a team would be getting a player with salary retention already built in and certainly a lower salary would more easily accommodate fitting in under the cap of a team trading for him.

Bertuzzi and Hyman were also exactly the type of players Leafs needed. Both signed for 5.5 mill after leaving the Leafs as UFAs.
 
You gain 5M in cap space, 2.5M cap hit doesn't sound like a lot but not insignificant either if you factor in 8 yrs, you're always up against the cap.
I guess you have to weigh what kind of player(s) you can get for that against what you realistically believe the team's chances
are to have any serious success in the next few years, I'm not sure 5M will get enough to really push you up substantially with this team.
If you don't anticipate a real boost, maybe holding on to him for a couple more years at 2nd or 3rd pairing and then cut him loose, shave maybe 4 yrs off the obligation.
In an ideal world, I would like to see him gone.

You gain $5m in cap space, but since Rielly is a valid #4-#6 Defenceman you have to replace with a valid #4-#6D.
And the Leafs have no young valid D, or young prospects coming up.
So they have to use free agency. And $3.5-6M is the cost of such a player.
 
I personally don't think McMann is worth $5 million/yr. Don't forget, last year McMann was a total dud in the playoffs.

I think the Leafs would be making a big mistake, signing McMann to a 4yr, $5 million per /yr contract, as some of the "talking Heads", suggest the Leafs do.

You don't pay a player for what he was. You pay a player for what he is now and what you think he will be. I'm not saying Leafs should sign him for 5 mill long term but finding a player like him for cheaper is not as easy as you may think.
Unless you think players like Domi, Maccelli, Joshua, Roy, and Laughton are his comparables.

Bertuzzi scored 21 goals in 80 games in his only season with the Leafs. This season he has 25 goals in 54 games.
Hyman as a Leaf his last 2 seasons were very good. 21 goals in 51 games followed by 15 goals in 43 games.
Both times Leafs wanted to keep them but thought it was too expensive or simply they had no cap room.
They chose the cheaper route hence they kept Domi. In Hyman's case Bunting was probably their de facto replacement.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Trevor Wong
I don't mind Mcmann but not a fan @ $5million a year either. The Leafs haven't really chosen a direction yet. But i guess we find out soon. I don't believe Matthews or Nylander will be traded though
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trevor Wong
You gain $5m in cap space, but since Rielly is a valid #4-#6 Defenceman you have to replace with a valid #4-#6D.
And the Leafs have no young valid D, or young prospects coming up.
So they have to use free agency. And $3.5-6M is the cost of such a player.
What advantage would you gain by doing that if it doesn't give you an upside and you're also on the hook for 8 years at 2.5M?
All you're doing is exchanging one limited D for another at a real cost, an additional 8 years after he's gone.
Just a consideration.
 
I often hear Leafs are a skilled team. More skill than any other team. Well, only 3 Leafs are in the Olympics.
Even if they still had Marner that would only be 4.
Florida has 10 players in the Olympics and Seth Jones and Barkov are inured and not included.
Minny has 9. Colorado, TB, and Boston have 8. Dallas, Vegas, and NJ have 7.
For a team supposedly loaded with skill that is a sad state of affairs and some even want Matthews and Nylander turfed.
Oilers also have only 3 players in the Olympics. They, however, have McD and Draisaitl. The only team with 2 players in the top 5 in points.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Trevor Wong
I often hear Leafs are a skilled team. More skill than any other team. Well, only 3 Leafs are in the Olympics.
Even if they still had Marner that would only be 4.
Florida has 10 players in the Olympics and Seth Jones and Barkov are inured and not included.
Minny has 9. Colorado, TB, and Boston have 8. Dallas, Vegas, and NJ have 7.
For a team supposedly loaded with skill that is a sad state of affairs and some even want Matthews and Nylander turfed.
Where do you hear that? :confused:
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Trevor Wong
What advantage would you gain by doing that if it doesn't give you an upside and you're also on the hook for 8 years at 2.5M?
All you're doing is exchanging one limited D for another at a real cost, an additional 8 years after he's gone.
Just a consideration.

None - that is generally my point. With the Leafs lack of really cheap options (i.e. young controllable costs) to replace him, the buyout is hard to justify.

The only point to doing it would be:
1) if you have young cheap options to fill Rielly's spot (NOPE), and then can use money at other positons
2) Rielly has become so useless that he is not even a valid NHL D or worth less than say $2M (NOPE)
 
Last edited:
Where do you hear that? :confused:

Where have you been, In a cave? Obviously not this year. All the years when Leafs had the fab four.
Only team in the history of the NHL with 4 players at the same time making over 10 million.
It'll probably be at least another 20 years before that will ever happen again even with inflation.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Trevor Wong
The one thing with buyouts (and the stretch) is they are not stretched evenly over 8 years for various reasons... the 2/3 part and the 8 years is correct for Reilly.
Here is a link with his buyout details
NHL Contract Management

Rielly's cap hit for the next 4 years would be $3.6 million after buyout vs his current cap hit of 7.5M.
So the cap savings from buying him out would only be $3.9 million for the next 4 years (7.5m vs 3.6M).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trevor Wong
None - that is generally my point. With the Leafs lack of really cheap options (i.e. young controllable costs) to replace him, the buyout is hard to justify.

The only point to doing it would be:
1) if you have young cheap options to fill Rielly's spot (NOPE), and then can use money at other positons
2) Rielly has become so useless that he is not even a valid NHL D or worth less than say $2M (NOPE)



There were some stats that showed when Rielly is out of the lineup up, the leafs have won roughly over 80% of the games over
the past three + seasons.


“ Morgan Rielly is out of the lineup. As of February 2026, the team has maintained a record of 24–5–1 without him since the 2022–23 season. “

They were able to replace him with minor league players for that stretch of 30 games. It‘d be ridiculous to expect win/loss records on the same level if he’s permanently out but I have no doubt his deletion will make this a better team. He makes a good player every 3 or 4 games but screws up at least 2-3 times more. He has deteriorated to the point that he shouldn’t be on a team that wants to present itself as a contender.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trevor Wong
There were some stats that showed when Rielly is out of the lineup up, the leafs have won roughly over 80% of the games over
the past three + seasons.


“ Morgan Rielly is out of the lineup. As of February 2026, the team has maintained a record of 24–5–1 without him since the 2022–23 season. “

They were able to replace him with minor league players for that stretch of 30 games. It‘d be ridiculous to expect win/loss records on the same level if he’s permanently out but I have no doubt his deletion will make this a better team. He makes a good player every 3 or 4 games but screws up at least 2-3 times more. He has deteriorated to the point that he shouldn’t be on a team that wants to present itself as a contender.

The Leafs aren't going to be a contender for a while. It's an oldish team with a lack of youth on low cost deals, prospects and picks, The only option is re-tool via free agency with more older players that are 28-35 which never really works or rebuild. So cutting him and putting 3.9 into FA doesn't do much. Not that keeping Rielly solves much either, but Leaf decisions have to be about rebuild or asset retention.

Anyway if you insist on getting rid of Rielly, it makes more sense to trade him and retain at 50% ... works out to the same cap hit (within $200,000) and you will not get punished with $2.1 million of cap hits 4 years after his contract is over.

Some team will bite on Reilly at 50% retained if the return is nothing.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Trevor Wong
The Leafs aren't going to be a contender for a while. It's an oldish team with a lack of youth on low cost deals, prospects and picks, The only option is re-tool via free agency with more older players that are 28-35 which never really works or rebuild. So cutting him and putting 3.9 into FA doesn't do much. Not that keeping Rielly solves much either, but Leaf decisions have to be about rebuild or asset retention.

Anyway if you insist on getting rid of Rielly, it makes more sense to trade him and retain at 50% ... works out to the same cap hit (within $200,000) and you will not get punished with $2.1 million of cap hits 4 years after his contract is over.

Some team will bite on Reilly at 50% retained if the return is nothing.
As long as he has a NMC he's not going anywhere.