I'd like to share my thinking, because I also wrestle with what's fair and also what's sustainable for me.
Some women charge extra for certain things, and some don't charge extra but do the nice extras without stopping the session to upcharge. I really appreciate the ones who give a nice experience without stopping to say "that's extra". I also wouldn't want those women to feel like they're missing out compared to ones who stop to say "that's extra". So I tip that amount if I get the service without being upcharged. Sps usually upcharge from 20 to 50 for some things.
Also, some sps will keep going after your first shot; others just stop and run out the clock by talking. So I like to tip those who keep doing the fun stuff. I try to make sure I'm consistent so that it doesn't make the sp wonder if they did something better or worse if I'm inconsistent.
Sometimes gifts are nice if you know her well enough that a certain gift makes sense; else a gift card or cash tip is probably easier. I used to bring an sp sliced fruit and snacks because she said she never ate lunch during her shift. Looking back, I wonder if she ever ate them, and I think giving the cash would have been easier for her to decide what to do with it.
I recall that for regular massage therapists (no happy ending), their recommendation is that if the pressure to add a tip makes it difficult for their clients, they'd rather the client makes an appointment without tipping rather than not make the appointment at all.
So I guess whatever is sustainable for you is what's right for you.