Civil War: MAGA in Turmoil

Would wanting anyone living in the U.S. illegally be deported be considered fascist?
Is wanting enforcement of the law fascist?
If done without due process, yes, it is fascist.
If done for ethno-cultural or religious reasons, yes, it is fascist.
The Trump administration is guilty of both of the above, not because I am interpreting their actions as such, but because they are infact saying/doing those things.
You can make an argument that Trump is racist. But the questions above get at the matter of actual immigration policy.
You might not support deportation and enforcing the law as strongly as someone else.
However, that is you entering into shades of gray and declaring you have the only correct answers. Everyone else who does not share your exact perspective on these questions must be racist.
You keep misusing the word "perspective" in an attempt to downplay fascist actions by the Trump government.
But that is not going to work for anyone outside your echo chamber.
These are not perspectives, but the objective reality of things in the US right now.
A policy of deporting people without due process is objectively fascist.
There are no shades of grey here.
 
It wasn't fascist for Biden to go after trump? his political enemy?
They didn't violate any due process to detainees
which court orders were n ot followed?
which war crimes did they commit? CNN MSNBC or any twitter rando saying it's war crimes doesn't mean it is fam...lol
No, Trump was convicted of felonies, so he is infact guilty.
OTOH, Comey's case got thrown out. Hence, Trump's actions were fascist.
which court orders were n ot followed?
Many. Some below:
- Ignored judge’s order to return deportation flights.
- Delayed releasing frozen federal grants despite court order.
- Slow-walked court-ordered legal aid for migrant kids; one deported.
- Bypassed injunction blocking mass CFPB layoffs.
- Violated gag orders in his criminal cases.
which war crimes did they commit?
Killing survivors of a military strike is a war crime.
Not per CNN or MSNBC.
But per US and international law.
 
There is no evidence presented that they were infact narco terrorists.
they were investigated. and of course you won't see the evidence you want as it's going to be classified...woulld you request all the military operations under Obama and Biden and expect to have it on your desk by tomorrow?
 
  • Like
Reactions: WyattEarp
There is no evidence presented that they were infact narco terrorists.

There is no such thing as narco 'terrorists'.
they were investigated. and of course you won't see the evidence you want as it's going to be classified...woulld you request all the military operations under Obama and Biden and expect to have it on your desk by tomorrow?

There is no investigations, Hegsmeth just said 'kill them all'.
But you also think trump is the anti war president.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
Immigration is a shit show. It's been a shit show that's been building and it hit a crescendo the last few years.

Now I don't know why you would repeat arguments that aren't based on facts on the ground. I have told you and others it's so easy to check information before you post it. This might reveal your real purpose is less than forthright.

So no, not everyone wants illegal immigrants who commit crimes deported out of the U.S. Don't ask me why. It would appear to be Red cities and states pandering to extreme views on immigration.

Per Google AI:
As of early December 2025, there are approximately
7,113 illegal immigrants with active U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detainers currently in the custody of New York state or local jurisdictions, meaning they are in local jails or state prisons for other criminal charges.

Key Details
  • Number in Custody: Over 7,000 illegal immigrants with active ICE detainers are currently being held in New York jails and prisons on various criminal charges.
  • Crimes Alleged: According to data from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and ICE, these individuals are associated with a wide range of serious offenses, including 148 homicides, 717 assaults, 152 weapons offenses, and 260 sexual predatory offenses.
  • Sanctuary Policies: New York's sanctuary policies generally prohibit local law enforcement and jails from holding individuals solely on the basis of a civil immigration detainer without a judicial warrant. This has led to tension between federal and state/local authorities.
  • Released Individuals: Since January 20, 2025, New York jurisdictions have released nearly 7,000 other criminal illegal immigrants back into the community who had active ICE detainers, rather than transferring them to federal custody upon their release from local charges. The crimes associated with this group included 29 homicides and numerous other violent felonies.
  • Federal Action: ICE has called on New York authorities, including Attorney General Letitia James, to honor their detainer requests to ensure that these individuals are transferred to federal custody for potential deportation proceedings rather than being released onto the streets.

This does not disprove my comment. However, it does illustrate an issue between states and the federal government. Keep in mind, the GOP loves to trump up the importance of states rights when it comes to things they care about, like abortion. But, when it comes to whether a state should help ICE, they are certainly pro-federalism.

So, looking at the New York stuff, that is basically an issue that New York does not have mandatory holds for undocumented people. Which means unless the ICE folks have a judicial warrant, the state has no need to hold them. Is this good or bad, I'm not sure. But, the reality is that if a New York judge felt that they were deserving to be freed on bail, so be it. That does not mean the state of New York wants violent offenders (documented or not) roaming the streets. But, it is a recognition that the bail system could be broken (i.e., the judges are more willing to grant peace bonds or bail to avoid the crazy over crowding at places like Riker's Island, where some poor bastard spent nearly two years waiting for his case to be heard for allegedly shop lifting a back pack).

It should also be pointed out that the ICE requests are civil immigration detainers, not signed by a judge. Has New York state made mistakes? Probably.

But, my point here, with facts for your pleasure, is that the vast majority of people caught by ICE now are not violent criminals:

.

Now, ICE, because they've been given the greenlight to racially profile people, has detained at least 170 American citizens.


That is pretty fucked up. How close were they to deporting someone?
 
@silentkisser

I am following up on the post above but it is a response to all the members fascinated with the idea that immigration is a major swing issue in the 2026 midterm elections.

For a moment, let's forget your argument that everyone wants illegals who have committed crimes to be deported. That leaves the Democrats having to make the case that all law-abiding illegals should be allowed to stay in the U.S. I don't think that's what most Americans and Canadians want as policy. It's easy to say that this policy is not sustainable in the long-run. It's basically saying if you can get here you can stay. Of course, no liberal politician ever will explicitly say that.

For curiousity, I Googled Canada deportation 2025. You can see it below.

Canada is deporting more people in 2025, particularly those whose refugee claims have been rejected, with significant enforcement actions targeting certain nationalities like Indian nationals due to issues like fraudulent study permits and illegal work.
Enforcement measures include a new cost recovery framework for removals, a proposal for stricter border and immigration laws through Bill C-12, and increased cooperation with other countries like the United States to send back asylum seekers

I think there is an important distinction to be made here. It isn't like Dems are pro-undocumented, or promote open borders, despite what the right-wing politicians and media say. It is the recognition that the US economy is greased by the cheap labour provided by undocumented workers. I'm not saying its a good thing, but the reality is that many industries in the US rely on this to operate. As I mentioned, the hospitality industry relies a lot on cheap labour to clean hotel rooms or work in kitchens. Many small businesses use them for things like landscaping or construction/roofing. Farms across the country rely on them to pick crops. And we've seen anecdotal evidence that many of these businesses have been hurt by the mass deportation.

As for saying that if someone stays in the US for years and not be deported....I'm not certain that's a bad thing. Let me give an example: The person crosses illegally, but over the past 20 years has worked hard and never broken the law. They might get married and have a family. They pay taxes and what not, but literally never see any benefit (because they might pay into social security, they can never use it). Far from being a leech on the system, they actually support it, helping to sustain it. They could be a small business owner. If you opened up a path to citizenship for them, would that be the worst thing? I don't think so.

Also, I should also say that I am by no means an expert or have any bright ideas on how to fix the system in Canada of the US. In regards to the Canadian stuff, we all know the system was abused (both by industry and individuals). I have no issue with folks being deported for fraudulently coming here. But I also have no issues with the government taking in legit refugees and immigrants. Obviously Canada and the US have different issues. We don't see thousands of south Americans coming across our border (for the most part).
 
I think there is an important distinction to be made here. It isn't like Dems are pro-undocumented, or promote open borders, despite what the right-wing politicians and media say. It is the recognition that the US economy is greased by the cheap labour provided by undocumented workers. I'm not saying its a good thing, but the reality is that many industries in the US rely on this to operate. As I mentioned, the hospitality industry relies a lot on cheap labour to clean hotel rooms or work in kitchens. Many small businesses use them for things like landscaping or construction/roofing. Farms across the country rely on them to pick crops. And we've seen anecdotal evidence that many of these businesses have been hurt by the mass deportation.

As for saying that if someone stays in the US for years and not be deported....I'm not certain that's a bad thing. Let me give an example: The person crosses illegally, but over the past 20 years has worked hard and never broken the law. They might get married and have a family. They pay taxes and what not, but literally never see any benefit (because they might pay into social security, they can never use it). Far from being a leech on the system, they actually support it, helping to sustain it. They could be a small business owner. If you opened up a path to citizenship for them, would that be the worst thing? I don't think so.

Also, I should also say that I am by no means an expert or have any bright ideas on how to fix the system in Canada of the US. In regards to the Canadian stuff, we all know the system was abused (both by industry and individuals). I have no issue with folks being deported for fraudulently coming here. But I also have no issues with the government taking in legit refugees and immigrants. Obviously Canada and the US have different issues. We don't see thousands of south Americans coming across our border (for the most part).

It does seem like a battle between MAGA using white replacement fear to rage farm their base into voting vs a corporate culture that relies on cheaper, non union labour to stay profitable.

Same as here with Timmies continually requesting TFW's because they are just a bit cheaper than Canadians but willing to put up with more crap while we also watch DoFo and Carney fight back against anti immigrant fears associated with rising unemployment and higher housing costs.

Politicians struggle to play both sides at once.

 
  • Like
Reactions: silentkisser
No they weren't.
They also double tapped 2 survivors of the strike which is a violation of both international and US law.
True.
That exact example of what is not acceptable is in US DoD Law of War Manual. David French, a conservative columnist and former military JAG quoted it in the NY Times: Here's his quote:

To make this case, I have to begin in the most boring way possible — by quoting a legal manual. Bear with me.
Specifically, it’s the most recent edition of the Department of Defense Law of War Manual. Tucked away on page 1,088 are two sentences that illustrate the gravity of the crisis in the Pentagon: “The requirement to refuse to comply with orders to commit law of war violations applies to orders to perform conduct that is clearly illegal or orders that the subordinate knows, in fact, are illegal. For example, orders to fire upon the shipwrecked would be clearly illegal.”
Here’s another key line: “It is forbidden to declare that no quarter will be given.” A no quarter order is an order directing soldiers to kill every combatant, including prisoners, the sick and the wounded. The manual continues, “Moreover, it is also prohibited to conduct hostilities on the basis that there shall be no survivors, or to threaten the adversary with the denial of quarter."

For the record.
 
again, Generals have briefed Sec Hegseth that the boat was surveilled...
Read what kherg007 wrote.
“The requirement to refuse to comply with orders to commit law of war violations applies to orders to perform conduct that is clearly illegal or orders that the subordinate knows, in fact, are illegal. For example, orders to fire upon the shipwrecked would be clearly illegal.”
Here’s another key line: “It is forbidden to declare that no quarter will be given.” A no quarter order is an order directing soldiers to kill every combatant, including prisoners, the sick and the wounded. The manual continues, “Moreover, it is also prohibited to conduct hostilities on the basis that there shall be no survivors, or to threaten the adversary with the denial of quarter."
Hegseth explicitly said "Kill them all".
It is a war crime.
 
Read what kherg007 wrote.

Hegseth explicitly said "Kill them all".
It is a war crime.
And I'm quoting a conservative JAG who's quoting the bloody manual itself!
Shocking how that very example of killing the shipwrecked is in the damn manual.
 
And I'm quoting a conservative JAG who's quoting the bloody manual itself!
Shocking how that very example of killing the shipwrecked is in the damn manual.
This is what happens when you put lipstick on a pig like Hegseth - an insecure, wannabe tough guy, and give him some power.
He was probably foaming at the mouth to order that air strike and show everybody what a badass he really was.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
This is what happens when you put lipstick on a pig like Hegseth - an insecure, wannabe tough guy, and give him some power.
He was probably foaming at the mouth to order that air strike and show everybody what a badass he really was.
Faux tough guys are like that. I've worked with some of the toughest blokes around and they absolutely don't talk like hegseth or like those bro boy Podcasters etc. Real tough guys just carry it. They have no need to throw it around.