Civil War: MAGA in Turmoil

If it did, then that would also be unlawful and unconstitutional.
And just because it happened during the Obama administration doesn't make it okay for it to happen during the Trump administration especially when they have a policy position of mass deportations without due process
I never said it was okay, I merely said that the wrongful deportations happen by mistake under every administration, whether its Republicans or Democrats
 
I never said it was okay, I merely said that the wrongful deportations happen by mistake under every administration, whether its Republicans or Democrats
Except this particular administration has a policy of mass deportations without due process which wasn't the case with Obama.
 
I never said it was okay, I merely said that the wrongful deportations happen by mistake under every administration, whether its Republicans or Democrats

''

he Obama administration utilized existing legal frameworks for deportations, primarily formal removal proceedings (which involve a hearing before an immigration judge and associated due process rights) and expedited removal (a faster process with limited judicial review). The administration also shifted focus to prioritize the removal of individuals who posed a threat to national security or public safety, such as those with serious criminal convictions or recent border crossers.

Formal Removal Proceedings
For many undocumented immigrants, particularly those apprehended in the U.S. interior and with established community ties, the primary mechanism was formal removal proceedings.
  • Immigration Court Hearings: Individuals had the right to a hearing before an immigration judge, where they could present their case, challenge the government's evidence, and apply for forms of relief from deportation (such as asylum, cancellation of removal, or other legal status).
    • Right to Counsel (at no government expense): Immigrants in these proceedings had the right to secure legal representation, though the government did not provide them with a lawyer.
    • Appeals Process: Decisions made by an immigration judge could be appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) and potentially to federal courts.
    • Prosecutorial Discretion: The administration encouraged the use of prosecutorial discretion to prioritize cases involving serious criminals and allow others, such as eligible parents of U.S. citizens (under the proposed DAPA program) and DACA recipients, to seek temporary relief from deportation.

Expedited Removal
The Obama administration continued the use of expedited removal authority, which allows immigration officers to quickly remove certain individuals without an immigration court hearing.
  • Eligibility: This process was primarily used for noncitizens apprehended at or near the border who lacked proper entry documents or used fraudulent ones, and who had not been continuously present in the U.S. for at least two years.
  • Limited Review: In these cases, due process was limited. However, individuals who expressed a fear of persecution or torture were entitled to a credible fear interview with an asylum officer to access the asylum system.

Due Process Concerns
Despite the existence of formal processes, the administration faced criticism from civil liberties and immigrant rights advocates regarding due process issues:
  • "Rocket Dockets": The administration created expedited hearings, or "rocket dockets," for families and unaccompanied children from Central America, which critics argued gave individuals less time to find adequate counsel and prepare their asylum claims, potentially violating due process.
  • Stipulated Removal: The use of stipulated removal, where detainees agreed to deportation without a full hearing, was also scrutinized. Reports suggested government officials sometimes provided misleading information, leading immigrants to waive their rights without fully understanding the consequences or their eligibility for relief.
In essence, the Obama administration followed existing legal procedures for deportations, which offered varying levels of due process depending on the specific circumstances and location of apprehension. The focus was on creating a more targeted system that prioritized serious threats while attempting to provide a path to temporary legal status for others through executive actions like DACA and DAPA.


This is what AI overview has to say...Sounds like a balanced way to go about things to me.
 
You forget you are talking to Phil.
Yes, he is going to insist on a list of specific names and then insist each one doesn't really count.
It's his nature
He made an outrageous claim that US citizens were being deported, and yet couldn't even come up with any names.

I've only managed to find 4 so far, and those appear to be mistakes.
Trump is not deporting US citizens intentionally
 
Which is why the ones arguing Islamic terror is the biggest threat in the west always like to include 9/11 in their stats.
It gives them the boost to the numbers they need.

That's certainly the easiest way to do it.
Especially if you want to use fatality per attack as a metric.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
I never said mistakes were never made.
That happens all the time.

What I said was US citizens are not being intentionally deported under Trump's order.

You on the other hand were insinuating that Trump was intentionally deporting US citizens, but now you're chickening out from your stupid argument because you have absolutely no evidence of this

What has been insinuated is that the Trump regime is intentionally not bothering to not make mistakes.
Their entire approach has been one where sweeping up citizens isn't a concern.
And, to be fair, they know that people like you will defend it, so they thought the fallout of doing it this way wouldn't be too bad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
What has been insinuated is that the Trump regime is intentionally not bothering to not make mistakes.
Their entire approach has been one where sweeping up citizens isn't a concern
If that were true, then a lot more than just 4 people would have been illegally deported, and many of those cases would have made the 6 o'clock news.

All an illegally deported person has to do is step to a lawyer and file a lawsuit.
Many, many lawyers would take on cases like that pro bono since the payout would be in the million$
 
This is what AI overview has to say...Sounds like a balanced way to go about things to me.

It's been a major criticism of the Trump regime by many pro-immigration forces.
Obama was vastly more effective at deportations than Trump has been, and even more so at focusing on dangerous criminals, something Trump has refused to do.
Lots of people think one of the reasons the Trump's administration was less effective at deportations overall is the mass approach without due process has resulted in more pushback than if they tried to do it in a more balanced way.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
Please name every American Citizen deported by Obama
I cannot name every single one, but I can name a few who were illegally deported under Obama's regime.
And thats all I asked of @Shaquille Oatmeal, just name a few people who were illegally deported under Trump's regime, and he couldnt even name one.

How can you make a claim like that, but then not back it up with any evidence??

Here are some names of people who were illegally deported during Obama's regime



  • Jose Adan Fugon-Cano and Gustavo Barahona-Sanchez: In 2015, these two Honduran men were wrongfully arrested in New Llano, Louisiana, by local police who demanded their papers. The men were not charged with any crimes but were turned over to Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and detained for deportation. The Department of Homeland Security's Office for Civil Rights later found that the arrest was likely based on racial profiling.
  • Benjamin Nuñez-Marquez: In 2014, a Border Patrol agent stopped and detained Nuñez-Marquez, a long-time resident of Orcas Island, Washington, who was taking his elderly neighbor to the hospital. His case drew public attention and opposition from local residents.
  • "Vern": An immigrant from Guatemala, referred to as "Vern," was deported in 2017 after his wife and children witnessed ICE agents take him into custody. He had received a deportation order earlier but had established a life and a family in the U.S. and avoided all trouble with the law.
 
Here's what I wrote:


This is factually correct.
If a person holds a green card or work visa, they can be deported if they have engaged in illegal activities.
I'm not sure what you're trying to argue here

The thread.

1764450048306.png

We then corrected you that denaturalize has nothing to do with green cards and visas and is a threat against US citizens.
 
If that were true, then a lot more than just 4 people would have been illegally deported, and many of those cases would have made the 6 o'clock news.

All an illegally deported person has to do is step to a lawyer and file a lawsuit.
Many, many lawyers would take on cases like that pro bono since the payout would be in the million$

Do they have lawyers in prison in El Salvador?
Just asking.

And, I hate to tell you, but if they have a lawyer to contest their deportation that would mean they are getting due process, and you're against them getting that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
I cannot name every single one, but I can name a few who were illegally deported under Obama's regime.

Please go ahead and do so.

Here are some names of people who were illegally deported during Obama's regime



  • Jose Adan Fugon-Cano and Gustavo Barahona-Sanchez: In 2015, these two Honduran men were wrongfully arrested in New Llano, Louisiana, by local police who demanded their papers. The men were not charged with any crimes but were turned over to Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and detained for deportation. The Department of Homeland Security's Office for Civil Rights later found that the arrest was likely based on racial profiling.
  • Benjamin Nuñez-Marquez: In 2014, a Border Patrol agent stopped and detained Nuñez-Marquez, a long-time resident of Orcas Island, Washington, who was taking his elderly neighbor to the hospital. His case drew public attention and opposition from local residents.
  • "Vern": An immigrant from Guatemala, referred to as "Vern," was deported in 2017 after his wife and children witnessed ICE agents take him into custody. He had received a deportation order earlier but had established a life and a family in the U.S. and avoided all trouble with the law.

You've provided a lot of links but no deportations of American Citizens yet.
I thought you were pointing out how Obama also deported American Citizens.
 
Even the dumbest person knows that I was referring to the deport part of Shaq's post, and not the denaturalize part.

Holy shit Valc, you've really outdone yourself 😂

No.
No one believes that.
You got caught and had to backtrack.

I mean, you went right into how it is fine to denaturalize American citizens as well, even claiming it is a good thing.

Since you aren't arguing in good faith, we aren't taking your statements as good faith arguments.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
Do they have lawyers in prison in El Salvador?
Just asking
Some do. Thanks to Trump 👍


And, I hate to tell you, but if they have a lawyer to contest their deportation that would mean they are getting due process, and you're against them getting that
I have never said I was against due process.
Read my posts, I have always said that illegally deporting people is wrong
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Valcazar