The Israel Lobby

“Israel’s Fighting YOUR War” - Netanyahu ADMITS Genocide, Slams AIPAC Critics & Trump Owning Gaza

 
The case you are making here is that you are a touch upset with the ruling but more upset that I would note that the judge has ruled that being against Israeli government policy like genocide, is antisemitic.

Where had the judge said this?
 
The lobby

Gzmw7upWcAA-FM1
 
So you have trouble reading.
Got it.
(You could try and post the decision and not someone telling you what to think.)

We both know that you are being pedantic here to try to score a point.
The gist of the ruling is that the judge stated he backed the IHRA definition and that therefore its antisemitic to attack symbols of the Israeli government.

I know your goal is to try to argue that AIPAC and Israel's influence on american policy really isn't that bad, that genocide is ok cuz its on Palestinians and that really things aren't that bad. Finding this one point is the best you've got now, as in 'did they specifically say....'.

You should be at the point where you understand that any defence of zionism is defence of genocide and a regime as evil now as nazis.
 
We both know that you are being pedantic here to try to score a point.
The gist of the ruling is that the judge stated he backed the IHRA definition and that therefore its antisemitic to attack symbols of the Israeli government.

No it isn't.
It's saying it is reasonable to have a stay away order.

I know your goal is to try to argue that AIPAC and Israel's influence on american policy really isn't that bad, that genocide is ok cuz its on Palestinians and that really things aren't that bad. Finding this one point is the best you've got now, as in 'did they specifically say....'.

None of these are my goals.

You should be at the point where you understand that any defence of zionism is defence of genocide and a regime as evil now as nazis.

So asking for people to be read what a judge actually said is a defence of genocide now?
Nice.
 
No it isn't.
It's saying it is reasonable to have a stay away order.

The judge specifically stated that targeting symbols of the Israeli state is antisemitic, per IHRA.
Along with the ruling to stay away from the victim, which was based on him saying the attack was antisemitic by targeting the Israeli flag.

None of these are my goals.

More likely your goal is to test out debate tactics before they tried publicly.
But these arguments still appear to be defending Israel.

So asking for people to be read what a judge actually said is a defence of genocide now?
Nice.

Straw man, nice. That would be a lousy grading tactic.
What makes this defence of genocide is to continue to broadly target posts critical of Israel and AIPAC, without ever applying the same standard of criticism to Israeli actions.
The 'attack the messenger' approach that makes your target clearer than you think it does.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Valcazar
The judge specifically stated that targeting symbols of the Israeli state is antisemitic, per IHRA.

Please point to where he said it was "per IHRA".

Along with the ruling to stay away from the victim, which was based on him saying the attack was antisemitic by targeting the Israeli flag.

He said that someone targeting someone for an assault because they have an Israeli flag can be reasonably considered antisemitic for purposes of justifying a stay-away order.
That this decision might also change when the actual trial happens.

I understand that it is for some reason very important to you to claim that this means the US legal system has said that anyone attacking an Israeli flag in any context is doing something antisemitic.
Since I prefer to go by what the judge actually wrote in the context he wrote it, I won't be joining you on that.

More likely your goal is to test out debate tactics before they tried publicly.
But these arguments still appear to be defending Israel.

LOL
So "defending Israel" is going to just keep expanding, I presume?


Straw man, nice. That would be a lousy grading tactic.
What makes this defence of genocide is to continue to broadly target posts critical of Israel and AIPAC, without ever applying the same standard of criticism to Israeli actions.
The 'attack the messenger' approach that makes your target clearer than you think it does.

I get it.
Pointing out you said something that doesn't appear to be true is supporting genocide.
Because, if I understand, you are fighting the good fight and therefore anything that prevents you from accomplishing your goal is objectively pro-genocide.
Is that it?

The old Iraq war standard?
 
Please point to where he said it was "per IHRA".

Already posted earlier in this thread, do your homework. Unless you're trying to argue a specific 'per IHRA' quote, which would be another straw man.

He said that someone targeting someone for an assault because they have an Israeli flag can be reasonably considered antisemitic for purposes of justifying a stay-away order.
That this decision might also change when the actual trial happens.

I understand that it is for some reason very important to you to claim that this means the US legal system has said that anyone attacking an Israeli flag in any context is doing something antisemitic.
Since I prefer to go by what the judge actually wrote in the context he wrote it, I won't be joining you on that.

Fine.


LOL
So "defending Israel" is going to just keep expanding, I presume?

Expanding like 'greater Israel', or more like the genocide in general?


I get it.
Pointing out you said something that doesn't appear to be true is supporting genocide.
Because, if I understand, you are fighting the good fight and therefore anything that prevents you from accomplishing your goal is objectively pro-genocide.
Is that it?

The old Iraq war standard?

Not at all.

I'm sure you think you appear unbiased and logical but in reality your posts are similar to wyatt's in who you attack and why. Wyatt likes to claim he's calling out people being uncivil but its clear that this only applies to people he disagrees with. Your preference is to use straw man arguments to try to make posts seem ridiculous It shows up here in the way you attack my interpretation but not that of the press. The way you don't criticize the ruling, the IHRA definition or the genocide.

When this was posted you continued to say I was wrong, not that the times was.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
Already posted earlier in this thread, do your homework. Unless you're trying to argue a specific 'per IHRA' quote, which would be another straw man.

Yes, you posted the complaint, not the judge's ruling, and pretended the judge wrote it.
I remember.

Expanding like 'greater Israel', or more like the genocide in general?

Expanding until you're bored with it, I presume.

Not at all.

I'm sure you think you appear unbiased and logical but in reality your posts are similar to wyatt's in who you attack and why.

LOL!
This should be good.

Wyatt likes to claim he's calling out people being uncivil but its clear that this only applies to people he disagrees with.

Why on earth would you think I think I'm unbiased in terms of who I engage with?
When have I ever claimed that?

Your preference is to use straw man arguments to try to make posts seem ridiculous It shows up here in the way you attack my interpretation but not that of the press.

I have mocked you for believing the press.
That you somehow think this means I don't think the press is mockable is... a choice.

The way you don't criticize the ruling, the IHRA definition or the genocide.

I did criticize the ruling.
I just also didn't believe the press's (and more importantly, social media's) interpretation unquestioningly.
This is. as you have told me, tantamount to me supporting genocide.

I didn't criticize the IHRA definition because since it wasn't in the judge's decision, I didn't bother.
If you would like to know, I don't think it should be the international standard it often gets used as, because it has problems that are too exploitable by people of bad faith.
That you still somehow think I'm pro-genocide is somewhat ridiculous, but then you think disagreeing with you about this case means I am pro-genocide, so it is possible you aren't very good at this.

When this was posted you continued to say I was wrong, not that the times was.


Because I'm talking to you, not the Times. And mostly about your need to just uncritically accept what Twitter tells you.
I mentioned that activists on both sides seemed very committed to reporting the story sensationally.
The Times article itself isn't great, but the real problem with it is the headline (and more importantly the subhead).

Of course, the Times of Israel also seems to have noticed what happened with its article.

 
Yes, you posted the complaint, not the judge's ruling, and pretended the judge wrote it.
I remember.

As you noted, it was the judge ruling that the perp had to stay away from the victim because attacking someone with an Israeli flag is antisemitic.
Even when that flag represents genocide.

You do remember that you stated it was in that ruling, didn't you?


Expanding until you're bored with it, I presume.

I see, so the problem isn't a 2 year long genocide or Israeli expansion into Lebanon, Syria and Palestine. The problem is my attention to those crimes.

LOL!
This should be good.

enjoy

Why on earth would you think I think I'm unbiased in terms of who I engage with?
When have I ever claimed that?

Oh its very clear you are biased. But you refuse to admit that bias even on an anonymous board by refusing to clearly state your views.

I have mocked you for believing the press.
That you somehow think this means I don't think the press is mockable is... a choice.

Sure, once again the problem isn't how the ruling was publicly reported, the problem you have is with me.

I did criticize the ruling.
I just also didn't believe the press's (and more importantly, social media's) interpretation unquestioningly.
This is. as you have told me, tantamount to me supporting genocide.

You got it wrong again, intentionally.

I didn't criticize the IHRA definition because since it wasn't in the judge's decision, I didn't bother.
If you would like to know, I don't think it should be the international standard it often gets used as, because it has problems that are too exploitable by people of bad faith.
That you still somehow think I'm pro-genocide is somewhat ridiculous, but then you think disagreeing with you about this case means I am pro-genocide, so it is possible you aren't very good at this.

We went through this and the quote was provided. Are you suffering memory issues or just gaslighting?

Because I'm talking to you, not the Times. And mostly about your need to just uncritically accept what Twitter tells you.
I mentioned that activists on both sides seemed very committed to reporting the story sensationally.
The Times article itself isn't great, but the real problem with it is the headline (and more importantly the subhead).

Why would you assume I accept all xitter posts uncritically? Your issue is that most of what I post is stuff that doesn't show on the MSM but presents a point of view you don't agree with and don't want to see. You don't want to have to know that Israel kills 83% civilians, that the toll is likely around 400,000 and that the genocide is not limited to Gaza or even Palestine. You don't want to see global or even american or Canadian resistance to the genocide. The Times you will accept because they are the Times.
But you don't want to know how bad the genocide is.

Of course, the Times of Israel also seems to have noticed what happened with its article.


I see, so you think the first article was incorrect but now this article is correct.
Judge McFadden stated destroying an Israeli flag was a racist attack, the Times is trying to walk that back after the backlash they noted.
AIPAC is having a tough time and stories about controlling america don't play well anymore.


I expect you would also be happy that anti-zionism is the same as antisemitism, legally.
A view that would argue that all Jewish people are genocidal, should you ever state your views clearly.
This seems apparent through this thread.
 
Zionists embrace National Socialism.


IDF Psyop plays victim. After Snow White she's getting to fail upwards. Extraordinary talent, she's playing Cleopatra next.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter