The Israel Lobby

https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.282707/gov.uscourts.dcd.282707.26.0.pdf

I posted a link myself, has your reading become that bad?

Where do you find that in the decision?

p4, fact 20

Where do you find that in the decision?

p2, fact 5, 6 and on

Where did he say that?
You only linked to an article by Shaun King, (that Rabbi Mivisair was tweeting).
That Shaun King has made a fevered interpretation of the ruling isn't exactly compelling.


Oh, I am sure that there are shitty people who are going to take this and insist it means a Federal Judge said it is OK to burn the Israeli flag.
I mean, that's literally what your tweet and Shaun King's article is arguing.

Like there are shitty people who will say that ICE will detain people based on their accents only.

Like I said, Shaun King is not someone I'm inclined to trust a legal interpretation from.
(I'm not likely to trust anything from Shaun King, because he is a notorious scammer who's full of shit.)

Why would you be any more trustworthy?

You do enjoy assuming lots of wrong things.

in your opinion

Because your take is so laughably wrong.
It's literally the only part I found interesting.

I mean, think about it.
Do you know how fucking horrifying if it had been ruled that you can't burn the Isreali flag as a protest?
That it was the only flag protected in the US?

That's terrifying!

So I looked up the case.
And it was not remotely that.

You should be relieved.
We all should be relieved.

That said, I do think the Judge's language in the area of the flag as a symbol is sloppy and bad. The judge's language is way too broad about linking the Star of David, even if it appears on the Israeli flag, to Jewish identity. Given it is a political protest linked to Israeli government policy, the idea that Sumrall can't be viewed as representing the Isreali government because they obviously aren't a government official isn't great either.

Luckily, in the end, this is a decision about whether someone is allowed to ask for a three-yard stay-away order against someone who assaulted them as a preliminary injunction while their civil suit plays out doesn't have a lot of precedent-setting value, since it isn' t even the trial.

I really am not overly worked up over the fact the judge decided that Janine Ali must:

1. Stay at least three yards away from Kimmara Sumrall;
2. Stay at least 100 yards away from Kimmara Sumrall’s home and place of
employment;
3. Have no contact with Kimmara Sumrall by any means whatsoever;
4. Do not communicate or attempt to communicate with Kimmara Sumrall, either directly
or through any other person by telephone, written message, electronic message, or any
form of social media or otherwise

with the understanding that things may change in light of the actual case evidence when it moves forward.

I can see why you are not bothered by this ruling at all. Its worth noting how it was reported in Israel and not at all reported in the states.
Gygd2qvW0AQyYzB


That's interesting.
You actually HAVE the court decision already, before I even sent it to you.
And yet you seem to have chosen to still misrepresent it.
I will clip the whole paragraph, and highlight what you made sure to clip out there.




Of course the judge ruled that they were trying to choke and not remove the Israeli flag.
But what you ignore in that ruling that the judge stated that targeting the Star of David is as racist as using the 'n' word.
The judge has ruled that Israeli policy represents the entire Jewish people.

Are you happy that the judge ruled all Jews are responsible for the genocide?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu

No.
You posted a link to the plaintiff's complaint for the actual lawsuit.
You also posted a screenshot from the actual judge's decision about the preliminary injunction, so I thought maybe you just posted the wrong link by accident.
And I did acknowledge it at the end, there. It just appeared you didn't look very closely because of what you wrote.
And, well, in this post, you just made it more obvious that you didn't read or understand the document you posted (or the screen shot you posted, which I must now assume you didn't take yourself since you seem entirely confused about which document is which).


That's the plaintiff's complaint, not the judge's decision.

The judge was just deciding on a preliminary injunction on point E of your document, pages 15-16.

What you just pointed to was Sumrall's lawyers saying the IHRA's definition should be used (and even they didn't make the claim that " its antisemitic to protest against Israeli genocide or destroy the flag." in fact 20.
Your argument that " the flag of Israel and Israeli genocide represents the Jewish people and that to destroy the flag is a hate crime and antisemitic" isn't really well supported by the facts on page 2, either, mind you.

But either way, it doesn't matter - none of this is from the judge. This is the phrasing and framing of a known pro-Israel activist.
Not the judge.
Not the courts.
Not the law.

Why would you be any more trustworthy?

Thank Shaun King?
A random person on the internet is more trustworthy because a random person on the internet isn't known for a fact to be a scam artist.

I can see why you are not bothered by this ruling at all.

Since you apparently can't understand the difference between a complaint and a decision, I think only one of us is actually reacting to the ruling.

Its worth noting how it was reported in Israel and not at all reported in the states.
Gygd2qvW0AQyYzB

It's quite clear activists on both sides are doing their best to push their narratives about this decision.

Of course the judge ruled that they were trying to choke and not remove the Israeli flag.
But what you ignore in that ruling that the judge stated that targeting the Star of David is as racist as using the 'n' word.

No.
Read the paragraph.
Battery involving a racial symbol is more severe than racial slurs and targeting the Star of David for that attack is as good direct evidence of racial animus as the n-word.
Now, as I said before, I don't think that's really good reasoning at all. I think it is possible to target someone for battery based on them porting the Israeli flag and it be entirely political. The fact the flag has the star on it means a broad-based protection of the Star of David as a symbol of identity is a problem.
But since this was just "is this good enough evidence to justify this stay-away order while the trial goes on" I am not super-worried about it.
Let's see what language comes into the actual decision.

The judge has ruled that Israeli policy represents the entire Jewish people.

Please point to the part in the judge's decision that says that.

Are you happy that the judge ruled all Jews are responsible for the genocide?

I'd be very upset if he ruled that.
Luckily, he hasn't.
 
No.
You posted a link to the plaintiff's complaint for the actual lawsuit.
You also posted a screenshot from the actual judge's decision about the preliminary injunction, so I thought maybe you just posted the wrong link by accident.
And I did acknowledge it at the end, there. It just appeared you didn't look very closely because of what you wrote.
And, well, in this post, you just made it more obvious that you didn't read or understand the document you posted (or the screen shot you posted, which I must now assume you didn't take yourself since you seem entirely confused about which document is which).

This is already reminding me of a similar thread about the ICJ ruling that Israel not commit genocide so, so long ago. During that thread you incorrectly understood how the ICJ rulings are passed and the import of provisional measures.

That's the plaintiff's complaint, not the judge's decision.

The judge was just deciding on a preliminary injunction on point E of your document, pages 15-16.

What you just pointed to was Sumrall's lawyers saying the IHRA's definition should be used (and even they didn't make the claim that " its antisemitic to protest against Israeli genocide or destroy the flag." in fact 20.
Your argument that " the flag of Israel and Israeli genocide represents the Jewish people and that to destroy the flag is a hate crime and antisemitic" isn't really well supported by the facts on page 2, either, mind you.

But either way, it doesn't matter - none of this is from the judge. This is the phrasing and framing of a known pro-Israel activist.
Not the judge.
Not the courts.
Not the law.

Yes, and the judge ruled in favour of the plaintiff, legitimizing those arguments and calling Code Pink 'extremist'.

Thank Shaun King?
A random person on the internet is more trustworthy because a random person on the internet isn't known for a fact to be a scam artist.

I'm going with the Rabbi and Times of Israel, who also posted the same thing. You can focus on King if it makes you feel better.

Since you apparently can't understand the difference between a complaint and a decision, I think only one of us is actually reacting to the ruling.

That's funny, since I posted the decision and you posted the complaint.

It's quite clear activists on both sides are doing their best to push their narratives about this decision.

As it is clear which narrative you are pushing here as well.

No.
Read the paragraph.
Battery involving a racial symbol is more severe than racial slurs and targeting the Star of David for that attack is as good direct evidence of racial animus as the n-word.
Now, as I said before, I don't think that's really good reasoning at all. I think it is possible to target someone for battery based on them porting the Israeli flag and it be entirely political. The fact the flag has the star on it means a broad-based protection of the Star of David as a symbol of identity is a problem.
But since this was just "is this good enough evidence to justify this stay-away order while the trial goes on" I am not super-worried about it.
Let's see what language comes into the actual decision.

Please point to the part in the judge's decision that says that.

First, Sumrall has sufficiently shown that Ali purposefully discriminated against her on the basis of race.

The judge ruled that the flag of Israel is a racial symbol, that all Jews are therefore represented by a genocidal state.





I'd be very upset if he ruled that.
Luckily, he hasn't.

I'm sure you are very upset about the ruling.

Ok, now that the UN, Amnesty, HRW, B'teselem and a host of others have ruled Israel is committing genocide we now can add academia.
The question remains, do you support 'never again' or are you still willing to excuse genocide?

GytBCUfWUAImHaL
 
This is already reminding me of a similar thread about the ICJ ruling that Israel not commit genocide so, so long ago.

Yes.
You were constantly misreading things in that thread, too.
Good catch.

Yes, and the judge ruled in favour of the plaintiff, legitimizing those arguments and calling Code Pink 'extremist'.

No.
The judge did not rule in favor of the plaintiff.
The trial hasn't happened yet.
The judge granted a preliminary injunction.

The judge only engaged with facts relevant to that decision.

Did you even try to read the decision?

I'm going with the Rabbi and Times of Israel, who also posted the same thing. You can focus on King if it makes you feel better.

You went with King. (The Rabbi tweet was him retweeting King.)
But sure.
You have lots of activists on both sides saying that this decision means what you say it means.
That's your right.

That's funny, since I posted the decision and you posted the complaint.

I'm sorry, what?

1755648981568.png

Since I assume at this point you can't be trusted not to try and alter evidence - here is a screen shot of posts 219 and 220.
Note that you, in 219, post the link to the following document: gov.uscourts.dcd.282707.1.0_2.pdf

People who want to follow along can do so here: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/70813731/sumrall-v-ali/
The link on that page to "Main Document" under Document #1 is the complaint.

You can also link to "download the pdf". If you do so, (you can just hover over it) you will note that it is document gov.uscourts.dcd.282707.1.0_2.pdf.

If you go down to document 26 - Memorandum and Opinion - you will find it is document gov.uscourts.dcd.282707.26.0.pdf
Which is - as you can see in the image - the link I provided.

Please note that Frank's links "proving" things the judge decided in post 221 are - again - to the complaint.

Not sure why you're trying to gaslight people, Frank, but its kind of disturbing.

As it is clear which narrative you are pushing here as well.

It is.
I'm pushing the one about actually reading what is in the decision and not spinning it wildly.


Page 12 for those bothering to read (since linking to direct pages and paragraphs isn't possible here, no blame to Frank on that).
The explanation for why ("Purposefully yanking on an Israeli flag tied around a Jewish person’s neck to choke them is direct evidence of racial discrimination") is on page 14.

As mentioned, I think this is weak reasoning from the judge.

The judge ruled that the flag of Israel is a racial symbol, that all Jews are therefore represented by a genocidal state.

The judge ruled the Star of David is a racial symbol. (also page 14)

I think its position on the flag makes it ambiguous in this case. The judge thinks it is clear enough for the sake of a preliminary injunction.
(The judge states their reasoning on page 15, but again, I find this weak.)

I'm sure you are very upset about the ruling.

No.
I think his reasoning isn't very strong, but since this is only about whether or not the defendant has to stay away from the plaintiff, it doesn't bother me a hell of a lot right now.

When the actual trial happens, maybe the judge will say something that is an actual problem. I'll worry then.

Ok, now that the UN, Amnesty, HRW, B'teselem and a host of others have ruled Israel is committing genocide we now can add academia.
The question remains, do you support 'never again' or are you still willing to excuse genocide?

My position on genocide being bad hasn't changed.
 
Yes.
You were constantly misreading things in that thread, too.
Good catch.

Interesting, your memory is very selective and in this case, faulty.

No.
The judge did not rule in favor of the plaintiff.
The trial hasn't happened yet.
The judge granted a preliminary injunction.

The judge only engaged with facts relevant to that decision.

Did you even try to read the decision?

You have declared the preliminary injunction isn't in favour of the plaintiff?
Decided with facts like 'First, Sumrall has sufficiently shown that Ali purposefully discriminated against her on the basis of race.'

You went with King. (The Rabbi tweet was him retweeting King.)
But sure.
You have lots of activists on both sides saying that this decision means what you say it means.
That's your right.

Agreed.


I'm sorry, what?

View attachment 474719

Since I assume at this point you can't be trusted not to try and alter evidence - here is a screen shot of posts 219 and 220.
Note that you, in 219, post the link to the following document: gov.uscourts.dcd.282707.1.0_2.pdf

People who want to follow along can do so here: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/70813731/sumrall-v-ali/
The link on that page to "Main Document" under Document #1 is the complaint.

You can also link to "download the pdf". If you do so, (you can just hover over it) you will note that it is document gov.uscourts.dcd.282707.1.0_2.pdf.

If you go down to document 26 - Memorandum and Opinion - you will find it is document gov.uscourts.dcd.282707.26.0.pdf
Which is - as you can see in the image - the link I provided.

Please note that Frank's links "proving" things the judge decided in post 221 are - again - to the complaint.

Not sure why you're trying to gaslight people, Frank, but its kind of disturbing.

If I'm doing the gaslighting why did you post from the July 26 doc and not the Aug 4 one?
Why is posting this 'gaslighting'?
First, Sumrall has sufficiently shown that Ali purposefully discriminated against her on the basis of race.

It is.
I'm pushing the one about actually reading what is in the decision and not spinning it wildly.

The judge ruled that the flag of Israel represents all Jewish people and attacking it is racist, regardless of Israel committing genocide that is not supported by all.


Page 12 for those bothering to read (since linking to direct pages and paragraphs isn't possible here, no blame to Frank on that).
The explanation for why ("Purposefully yanking on an Israeli flag tied around a Jewish person’s neck to choke them is direct evidence of racial discrimination") is on page 14.

As mentioned, I think this is weak reasoning from the judge.

Sure, that's your opinion. That doesn't change the ruling.

The judge ruled the Star of David is a racial symbol. (also page 14)

I think its position on the flag makes it ambiguous in this case. The judge thinks it is clear enough for the sake of a preliminary injunction.
(The judge states their reasoning on page 15, but again, I find this weak.)

I don't find the judge's ruling weak, I find it antisemitic to use the IHRA definition to argue that all Jewish people support Israeli government policy, including apartheid and genocide. You can argue its just 'weak' as you see fit.


No.
I think his reasoning isn't very strong, but since this is only about whether or not the defendant has to stay away from the plaintiff, it doesn't bother me a hell of a lot right now.

When the actual trial happens, maybe the judge will say something that is an actual problem. I'll worry then.

First, Sumrall has sufficiently shown that Ali purposefully discriminated against her on the basis of race.
You don't find that problematic already?


My position on genocide being bad hasn't changed.

Lots of people think spitting is 'bad'.
Genocide should be in that 'never again', fucking evil, lowest of low, crime against humanity.
That 'never again' level of evil that means you couldn't possibly ever vote for someone who is backing genocide.
But you think its just 'bad'.

The case you are making here is that you are a touch upset with the ruling but more upset that I would note that the judge has ruled that being against Israeli government policy like genocide, is antisemitic.

Nothing like this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu