"I Am a Palestinian in Gaza and Hamas must Cede Control"

[Klatuu]

It does.
It is a report.
The UN special committee is not a legal organization or entity that rules on what is genocide and what isn't.
It is their POV that it is a genocide.
It also seems to be your POV.
Okay. So far so good.
But Israel should be allowed to challenge that and present evidence to the contrary.
Then the court can decide which bucket these allegations fall in.

Show the definition of an allegation you are relying upon

You have already conceded that a court finding is not required for an identification of genocide.

 

[Vinson]

It's amazing how you only seem to debate people who lie and you're the only honest one. You're a joke. Nobody believes anything you say and you are looking more and more like a fool every day. Every day more people want you gone from here.

Frankfooter is wacko troll, he shoots himself in the foot all the time. He doesn't care of having any dignity or integrity , he hopes to get the 72 virgins.

 

[Klatuu]

Frankfooter is wacko troll, he shoots himself in the foot all the time. He doesn't care of having any dignity or integrity , he hopes to get the 72 virgins.

Inane racism

 

[NotADcotor]

Inane racism

You used the word racism and the word inane. I don't think those words mean what you think they mean.

It's like you just throw random comments to respond to what people say which in no way apply.

 

[shack]

There is an almost inexhaustible amount of evidence of intent. Hats off to POS Nation for that.

According to which court?

 

[basketcase]

It only takes the opinion of one person now?
ok
...

I know you hate Palestinian polling but to summarize:
- 57% in Gaza think hamas was wrong to launch this war
- Only 39% in Gaza are satisfied with hamas
- Only 35% in Gaza support Hamas politically

https://www.pcpsr.org/sites/default/files/Poll%2093%20English%20press%20release%2017_Sept2024.pdf

 

[shack]

Frankfooter is wacko troll, he shoots himself in the foot all the time. He doesn't care of having any dignity or integrity , he hopes to get the 72 virgins.

That is the only possible logical explanation. He and his lies get humiliatingly exposed every day, yet he keeps on telling more ridiculous lies. He has no shame.

It's good to see that we're getting more and more calls from more and more respectable long time members for him to be off the board. And these are people who have never previously called for anyone's removal. This is how disruptive he is to the board.

 

[Frankfooter]

A report concluding that "it is genocide" doesn't mean it is genocide.

If you are so sure this report is wrong then prove its wrong.

 

[Frankfooter]

Specifically intent by the STATE.
Not the extreme comments by some of its far right politicians.

Politicians are the state.
Statements by politicians in power show intent by the state to commit genocide.

This is a statement of intent that was followed through in action by Israel.
This video is evidence at the ICJ.

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1844115279003189524

 

[Frankfooter]

Genocide cannot be proven anywhere else.
I dont think pro-Palestinians should be hung up on proving genocide either.
What if the genocide claim fails? The deaths dont matter then?

Are you going to argue that killing 268,000 civilians is ok if its not ruled as genocide?

 

[Frankfooter]

False equivalency.
The holocaust was an attack on civilians where people were deported to death camps to be gassed.
That is not happening in Gaza.

Gaza already was a concentration camp.
Israel has controlled the borders through an illegal blockade for 17 years.

 

[Frankfooter]

Because of the high standard of specific intent, proving genocide is often more challenging than proving other international crimes. If the required intent cannot be established, the conduct may instead fall under crimes against humanity or war crimes.

So easy, there are hundreds of pages of quotes like this, the top songs in Israel are about genocide and there are mountains of video from IOF showing intent.

 

[Frankfooter]

How long do you think that TERB will allow you to put the board at risk? There are limits to free speech and your hate speech is beyond those limits.

You need to stop saying that Israel is committing genocide. It is simply not true according to the UNGA.

The UN

 

[Frankfooter]

SUch intent like warning civilians of their attacks so they can get out of the way

Did Israel allow Palestinians to leave Gaza and get out of the way?

 

[Frankfooter]

That is the only possible logical explanation. He and his lies get humiliatingly exposed every day, yet he keeps on telling more ridiculous lies. He has no shame.

It's good to see that we're getting more and more calls from more and more respectable long time members for him to be off the board. And these are people who have never previously called for anyone's removal. This is how disruptive he is to the board.

shack counter:
78 accusations of lying, 46 intentional misquotes (straw man arguments) - 0 proof

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1858431485805478215

 

[shack]

The UN

How about the UNGA? How about a resolution from the UNGA?

 

[Klatuu]

How about the UNGA? How about a resolution from the UNGA?

Deflection

 

[whynot888]

Are you going to argue that killing 268,000 civilians is ok if its not ruled as genocide?

268k? Your dreams do get wetter and wetter

 

[Shaquille Oatmeal]

Are you going to argue that killing 268,000 civilians is ok if its not ruled as genocide?

I asked you that.

 

[whynot888]

Gaza already was a concentration camp.
Israel has controlled the borders through an illegal blockade for 17 years.

If it wasnt for Israel, Gaza would turn into a lawless shithole like Sudan