TRUMP WINS

Shaquille Oatmeal

Well-known member
Jun 2, 2023
1,329
883
113
How about an illegal that has been in the USA for decades then commits robbery or murder. Should they be deported or do they get to stay because they've "planted roots"?
So generally illegal immigrants commit less crime than citizens.
Native born Americans, followed by illegal immigrants, followed by legal immigrants - order of criminality.
However a substantial number of Americans think immigration and crime are related.

See this report.

In 2018, the illegal immigrant criminal conviction rate was 782 per 100,000 illegal immigrants, 535 per 100,000 legal immigrants, and 1,422 per 100,000 native-born Americans. The illegal immigrant criminal conviction rate was 45 percent below that of native-born Americans in Texas. The general pattern of native-born Americans having the highest criminal conviction rates followed by illegal immigrants and then with legal immigrants having the lowest holds for all of other specific types of crimes such as violent crimes, property crimes, homicide, and sex crimes.
There is more and more evidence that immigrants, regardless of legal status, are less likely to commit crimes than native-born Americans. However, a substantial number of Americans still think that immigration increases crime. As more evidence builds over time, we can only hope that Americans respond by updating their opinions so that they fit the facts.


So the longer they stay, the less likely they are to commit crime.
If it does happen, then it should be considered along humanitarian grounds to see if they have roots, families etc.,
 

Shaquille Oatmeal

Well-known member
Jun 2, 2023
1,329
883
113
You can physically secure a border all you want, but if policy exists that allow illegals to circumvent the law such as 'parole in place' then you only incentivize more illegal immigration.
It wont.
Disincentivizing illegal immigration is not through deportations.
People will just flee to other countries or states. (Wait for some of them to end up in Canada).
It is through border security to avoid illegal immigration.
And fixing the legal immigration system so people are encouraged to not overstay visas, which is a major source of illegal immigration.
 

Bucktee

Well-known member
Jan 26, 2024
645
903
93
So generally illegal immigrants commit less crime than citizens.
Native born Americans, followed by illegal immigrants, followed by legal immigrants - order of criminality.
However a substantial number of Americans think immigration and crime are related.
Irrelevant. If there were no illegal immigrants, they'd commit ZERO crime.

So the longer they stay, the less likely they are to commit crime.
If it does happen, then it should be considered along humanitarian grounds to see if they have roots, families etc.,
If an illegal commits murder, they should be deported, regardless of time spent living illegally in the country.

Your argument is essentially... 'the longer you've been breaking the law, the better the chances of you staying.'

Do you see the incentive this creates?
 

Shaquille Oatmeal

Well-known member
Jun 2, 2023
1,329
883
113
Irrelevant. If there were no illegal immigrants, they'd commit ZERO crime.

If an illegal commits murder, they should be deported, regardless of time spent living illegally in the country.

Your argument is essentially... 'the longer you've been breaking the law, the better the chances of you staying.'

Do you see the incentive this creates?
And if there were no people at all in the country then there would be 0 crime.
That does not work for an argument.
People and crime go together regardless of their status. We have to accept this.
The longer they stay the less likely they are to commit crime.
The lack of a piece of paper authorizing their presence is not such a big deal that you should engage in human rights abuses via mass deportations.
You are advocating for this despite not being affected by illegal immigrants.
This is the problem with this policy.
It drums up hatred when there is no need for it and ends up actually materializing into human rights abuses.
 

JohnLarue

Well-known member
Jan 19, 2005
16,985
2,717
113
But you are! Deporting people who pays taxes and made their life here withoutbeing criminal,
if you enter the country illegally you are a criminal
illegal should be self explanatory

boarders need to be secure
beside you are not treating those that legally apply equally by permitting illegal entry
Equal is not just equal when it is convenient


women are being bullied online with "your body, my choice" litteraly everywhere,
I have looked at both sides of this and .... its an unresolvable quagmire
I will not wade into this unresolvable quagmire

trans and lgbtq are scared to walk in the street so yes, absolutely can we leave the hate aside?!
I do not hate trans or lgbtq,
Not my concern or business who bangs who

There are two biological sexes
i actually feel empathy for these that are confused about this as that would be a tough life to live
But they do not deserve special treatment

i do believe parents have a right and obligation to protect their children

I also will not have my speech compelled
If someone requests I address them in a specific not-traditional manner (he/she) I may / may not decide to comply with their request, largely dependant on how that request was delivered ie a polite ask vs, an insulting demand.
Respect is earned, not compelled or demanded

Seeing tampons in the men's room just makes me shake my head and it confirms the motivation for this (whatever that maybe) has gone off the rails as common sense has been ignored.
 

Bucktee

Well-known member
Jan 26, 2024
645
903
93
And if there were no people at all in the country then there would be 0 crime.
That does not work for an argument.
This isn't a rebuttal. It makes no sense. There is no country if there are no people.

People and crime go together regardless of their status. We have to accept this.
The longer they stay the less likely they are to commit crime.
But we don't have to accept illegal immigrants. If they cannot stay, they cannot commit crime whether they're here for a day or decades.

The lack of a piece of paper authorizing their presence is not such a big deal that you should engage in human rights abuses via mass deportations.
Nobody has a right to citizenship in another country by illegally crossing its border.

This is not a human rights issue. It's an issue of national sovereignty, security, and the rights, freedoms, and protections of citizens.

You are advocating for this despite not being affected by illegal immigrants.
This is the problem with this policy.
It drums up hatred when there is no need for it and ends up actually materializing into human rights abuses.
The crime, the devaluing of wages, and the culture of illegal immigrants impact everyone.

The cow farmer doesn't think that cow manure is affecting anyone and he doesn't even smell it. But everyone else far enough from his farm can smell the cow shit on him when he comes to visit.

You're the farmer. You're impacted without knowing it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jimidean2011

Bucktee

Well-known member
Jan 26, 2024
645
903
93
if you enter the country illegally you are a criminal
illegal should be self explanatory

boarders need to be secure
beside you are not treating those that legally apply equally by permitting illegal entry
Equal is not just equal when it is convenient
Exactly.

Illegals are a privileged minority. They break the law and are rewarded for it while everyone else has to stand in line.

We are advocating that they be treated equally like everyone else that wants citizenship.

But when one is privileged, equality feels like oppression.
 

Shaquille Oatmeal

Well-known member
Jun 2, 2023
1,329
883
113
This isn't a rebuttal. It makes no sense. There is no country if there are no people.



But we don't have to accept illegal immigrants. If they cannot stay, they cannot commit crime whether they're here for a day or decades.



Nobody has a right to citizenship in another country by illegally crossing its border.

This is not a human rights issue. It's an issue of national sovereignty, security, and the rights, freedoms, and protections of citizens.



The crime, the devaluing of wages, and the culture of illegal immigrants impact everyone.

The cow farmer doesn't think that cow manure is affecting anyone and he doesn't even smell it. But everyone else far enough from his farm can smell the cow shit on him when he comes to visit.

You're the farmer. You're impacted without knowing it.
Which is why you strengthen border security and fix the immigration system to reduce illegal immigration.
And deport anyone in the future.
But with the already present 11M, you deport the criminal ones and give a path to citizenship for the rest.
It is the most practical solution that benefits the state while avoiding a human rights crisis.
Illegal immigrants do jobs that Americans wont do or do not want to do.
So devaluing of wages is not an issue.
 

roddermac

Well-known member
Sep 17, 2023
1,417
1,039
113
Which is why you strengthen border security and fix the immigration system to reduce illegal immigration.
And deport anyone in the future.
But with the already present 11M, you deport the criminal ones and give a path to citizenship for the rest.
It is the most practical solution that benefits the state while avoiding a human rights crisis.
Illegal immigrants do jobs that Americans wont do or do not want to do.
So devaluing of wages is not an issue.
They tried this and were called racists for it. That was the real issue. Then Biden opened everything up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jimidean2011

JohnLarue

Well-known member
Jan 19, 2005
16,985
2,717
113
And if there were no people at all in the country then there would be 0 crime.
That does not work for an argument.
once again your logic is very flawed

if there were no people at all in the country, it would not be a country, it would be an uninhabited chunk of land

People and crime go together regardless of their status. We have to accept this.
The longer they stay the less likely they are to commit crime.
Actual no
They committed a crime by entering the country illegally
And they are committing a crime every day they remain in the ILLGALLY enter country

Illegal should be self explanatory

You loonies really get confused about well defined words


The lack of a piece of paper authorizing their presence is not such a big deal that you should engage in human rights abuses via mass deportations.
Detaining a criminal (ie illegal) and returning them to the scene of the crime (the boarder) and is not a human rights abuse
They did not have the right to enter the country
If you enter my home without permission, you are going to leave one way or another

You are advocating for this despite not being affected by illegal immigrants.
We want to treat all applicants for immigration equally, the only way to do that is to accept legally processed applicants and only legally processed applicants
All others are criminals

You loonies shout scream , jump up and down about equality and then hypocritically expect criminals to be treated as special, while ignoring the long list of legal applicants

Equal should be self explanatory.
it is bewildering you get confused by a word you use so often

It drums up hatred when there is no need for it and ends up actually materializing into human rights abuses.
You whine that deporting criminals are human rights abuses
While at same time declare China a success story despite knowing they murdered 20 to 50 million (or more) of their own people
Your logic is a clown show
 

kittykellykat

Kelly @ Secret Escorts
Jun 15, 2023
255
633
93
Are you serious?

Today is a very sad day for women's, lgbtq's AND sex workers rights. It's not our battle but it is. This will also affect ours. If a guy like Pollievre pass, there will be a humongous shitshow around here (I don't like the Liberal either, if that matters). What is going on is really, really bad.

Also the Trumpist on a review board that copulate with sex workers but celebrate this kind of victory sound so weird to me. Make it make sense!
What rights are you worried sex workers will lose in Canada under a conservative government exactly? Or as a woman, for that matter? Real question.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jimidean2011

Josephine

Making your life special
Supporting Member
Nov 6, 2023
471
808
93
Etobicoke
What rights are you worried sex workers will lose in Canada under a conservative government exactly?
Conservative = right. Right do not like prostitute. They don't like you. From there anything is possible.


Per example:

1000023683.jpg 1000023684.jpg 1000023685.jpg 1000023686.jpg 1000023687.jpg 1000023688.jpg 1000023689.jpg 1000023690.jpg 1000023691.jpg
That was just talk then boom

Bill c36 is a conservative bill
 
Last edited:

Shaquille Oatmeal

Well-known member
Jun 2, 2023
1,329
883
113
You whine that deporting criminals are human rights abuses
While at same time declare China a success story despite knowing they murdered 20 to 50 million (or more) of their own people
Your logic is a clown show
You whine that China is not a success story because of their human rights abuses despite being the 2nd largest economy and soon to be the largest economy in the world.
While at the same time supporting human rights abuses by deporting millions of non-criminals because they did not have a piece of paper.
Your logic is a clown show and your posts are unreadable.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: jimidean2011
Toronto Escorts