What is the Best Way to Buy a Car?

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
51,697
10,105
113
Toronto
When I say best, I'm mainly referring to price. FYI, I would not object to going to a dealership to do it in person.

And how would the strategy differ between buying new vs. used? Trade-in value is not a factor for me.
 

jeff2

Well-known member
Sep 11, 2004
1,615
882
113
I would look at the APA or Car Help Canada. These are non profits and they ensure you do not get scammed.
They have negotiated prices for you with dealers. They know the dealer cost.
I have not used them because I am a maintenance fanatic and still have an old car my uncle gave me but I used to watch their shows on TV.


 
Last edited:

Ceiling Cat

Well-known member
Feb 25, 2009
28,712
1,444
113
I would look at the APA or Car Help Canada. These are non profits and they ensure you do not get scammed.
They have negotiated prices for you with dealers. They know the dealer cost.
I have not used them because I am a maintenance fanatic and still have an old car my uncle gave me but I used to watch their shows on TV.
IMHO, the APA or Car Help Canada will not get you the most amazing prices. They have to deal with these people and they can not afford to piss them off. Use logic, you will not get 20% off. Low ball them, and then get their price. Go from dealer to dealer and get prices, then work with the lowest price. If no one can beat their price they may be low balling you only to tack on extras before you sign. Never accept any add ons. Always tell them you are taking financing from them, even if you are not. You can change your mind at the last minute. Get them to throw in winter rims or even winter tires if you are negotiating in the fall. Do not accept any add ons already on the vehicle, like window and car part anti theft markings, rust proofing, or ceramic car coating.

FYI - Spray on ceramic wax works fine for me. The dirt just slides off with rain and snow. A $12 can of Rust Check sprayed into the door weep holes is just as good as a $200 rust treatment
 

xix

Time Zone Traveller
Jul 27, 2002
4,211
1,427
113
La la land
Finance or lease?
Finance you can go anywhere with the car.
Lease you are only allowed a certain amount of KM per year. After that you pay for it. Maintenance is almost free.

My co-worker has leased for the past 20 years and every 4-5 years he switches cars. The guy has never traveled anywhere not even TO.
He is a prisoner.

He is better off taking the train or city bus.
 

jeff2

Well-known member
Sep 11, 2004
1,615
882
113
IMHO, the APA or Car Help Canada will not get you the most amazing prices. They have to deal with these people and they can not afford to piss them off. Use logic, you will not get 20% off. Low ball them, and then get their price. Go from dealer to dealer and get prices, then work with the lowest price. If no one can beat their price they may be low balling you only to tack on extras before you sign. Never accept any add ons. Always tell them you are taking financing from them, even if you are not. You can change your mind at the last minute. Get them to throw in winter rims or even winter tires if you are negotiating in the fall. Do not accept any add ons already on the vehicle, like window and car part anti theft markings, rust proofing, or ceramic car coating.

FYI - Spray on ceramic wax works fine for me. The dirt just slides off with rain and snow. A $12 can of Rust Check sprayed into the door weep holes is just as good as a $200 rust treatment
It is true that add ons are where they make money. Margins are pretty slim on compacts in particular, which most Canadians buy.
The very best prices(talking about new cars) may not be with APA or Car Help, but I would imagine that you will not get ripped off. For people who do not like haggling, it is probably ok.
I am still grandfathered into $ 99.00 a year at Krown Rust. But they are now asking for tips.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
51,697
10,105
113
Toronto
Finance or lease?
Finance you can go anywhere with the car.
Lease you are only allowed a certain amount of KM per year. After that you pay for it. Maintenance is almost free.

My co-worker has leased for the past 20 years and every 4-5 years he switches cars. The guy has never traveled anywhere not even TO.
He is a prisoner.

He is better off taking the train or city bus.
I would never lease. It is not a business write off for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jenesis

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
51,697
10,105
113
Toronto
IMHO, the APA or Car Help Canada will not get you the most amazing prices. They have to deal with these people and they can not afford to piss them off. Use logic, you will not get 20% off. Low ball them, and then get their price. Go from dealer to dealer and get prices, then work with the lowest price. If no one can beat their price they may be low balling you only to tack on extras before you sign. Never accept any add ons. Always tell them you are taking financing from them, even if you are not. You can change your mind at the last minute. Get them to throw in winter rims or even winter tires if you are negotiating in the fall. Do not accept any add ons already on the vehicle, like window and car part anti theft markings, rust proofing, or ceramic car coating.

FYI - Spray on ceramic wax works fine for me. The dirt just slides off with rain and snow. A $12 can of Rust Check sprayed into the door weep holes is just as good as a $200 rust treatment
Thanks CC.
 

coolmanfever

Well-known member
Feb 14, 2017
941
524
93
It is a pain. But you just have call and submit offers all the dealership around you for the car of interest

Or

Buy tesla online
 

Ceiling Cat

Well-known member
Feb 25, 2009
28,712
1,444
113
Never let Sneaky the Bastard add anything to your contract, Price + taxes all in or you walk. Too many times I have had the last minute extras pulled on me. If you get a rude bastard, milk him for information and go elsewhere.

I had one Jackass slap one hand on the table and stick his palm out and demanded my credit card even before he gave me a price.


Has the covid shortage finally ended?
Yes, it has. Supply is increasing GM. Ford and Stellates vehicles are in good supply. Especially the pick up trucks. Toyota and Honda cars are selling close to retail but no longer above sticker.
 

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
51,697
10,105
113
Toronto
Does anybody feel that buying online with no negotiation, like Carvana or whatever, will get you a best price? I highly doubt it but have no personal frame of reference.

It seems to me to be a Gen X or Y or Z thing that just does everything online as a default approach.
 
  • Like
Reactions: xix

jeff2

Well-known member
Sep 11, 2004
1,615
882
113
Does anybody feel that buying online with no negotiation, like Carvana or whatever, will get you a best price? I highly doubt it but have no personal frame of reference.

It seems to me to be a Gen X or Y or Z thing that just does everything online as a default approach.
There is also Unhaggle. I do not know much about it but assume it is not non profit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill

jeff2

Well-known member
Sep 11, 2004
1,615
882
113
Pay in cash. It’s a depreciating asset. Doesn’t worth but in car worshiping countries m. It is the only way.
Yes, it is a depreciating asset. But, it can last quite a while if people do a lot of maintenance. The car company is only concerned about the maintenance to get you through the warranty period.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jenesis

princekwekua

Well-known member
Oct 26, 2021
1,850
1,600
113
When I say best, I'm mainly referring to price. FYI, I would not object to going to a dealership to do it in person.

And how would the strategy differ between buying new vs. used? Trade-in value is not a factor for me.
Used car is the way to go. 3 - 4 year olds, 60,000 km
Decide which car you want. Say Acura RDX - one of the best vehicles for value out there
Then google used Acura RDX
Autotrader.ca and cargurus.ca will give you tons of options - mileage and price
Buy dealer option. Certified. Never private
 

Nickelodeon

Well-known member
Apr 13, 2003
2,001
455
83
64
toronto
Used car is the way to go. 3 - 4 year olds, 60,000 km
Decide which car you want. Say Acura RDX - one of the best vehicles for value out there
Then google used Acura RDX
Autotrader.ca and cargurus.ca will give you tons of options - mileage and price
Buy dealer option. Certified. Never private
This is the best answer out of all of the replies you've received to your question. When you go this route, you might even find lower mileage cars depending on who has driven it. Certified CPO will also protect you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jenesis and Adamxx

ramblin

Well-known member
Nov 16, 2019
1,116
2,277
113
My advice is to first determine the car you want, with the options you want. Write everything down on a piece of paper and stick to it no matter what.

That way while shopping you can compare 'apples'-to-apples' easily. Once the comparison becomes 'apples-to-oranges' you lose any advantage you have. If buying via a dealership they will try to get you off your 'apples-to-apples' comparison so that they can get an advantage, i.e. "We don't have that car with those options on the lot, but we do have this other car with these other options which is a great value..."
 

richaceg

Well-known member
Feb 11, 2009
14,066
5,892
113
Best way to buy a car is to walk in with cash.. you will get the best deal and if you're lucky, you get a young hungry hit sales chick they love guys with wads of cash to burn....
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jenesis

Jenesis

Fabulously Full Figured
Supporting Member
Jul 14, 2020
9,488
9,654
113
North Whitby Incalls
www.jenesis.ch
When I say best, I'm mainly referring to price. FYI, I would not object to going to a dealership to do it in person.

And how would the strategy differ between buying new vs. used? Trade-in value is not a factor for me.
I never buy new. A car is a depreciating asset that loses so much value as soon as you drive it off the lot new. It makes no sense to me personally.

I use auto traders for dealerships with a car I may want. Then I research the dealership. Then I take a test drive of course.

For negotiating, I request to see the work done on the car when it came to the dealership. I ask how long it has been on the lot and I bring, if I can, print outs of other cars that may be a lower price point. The last car I bought was on the lot for 3 months. They were actually losing money on it but it was priced right so I took it at their request amount.

Oh and if you can, pay cash. Makes it easier and gives you some room on negotiations as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shakenbake
Toronto Escorts