No.
What a bizarrely silly thing to believe.
I get that you hope that and the Chicago PD is just as happy to start a riot now as they were in 68.
The protests are bigger already, aren't they?
Hopefully they don't get violent at all.
No.
What a bizarrely silly thing to believe.
I get that you hope that and the Chicago PD is just as happy to start a riot now as they were in 68.
No.
What a bizarrely silly thing to believe.
I get that you hope that and the Chicago PD is just as happy to start a riot now as they were in 68.
It was in that times of Israel article.
Why do you think Israel didn't push for full on war after they got Iran to respond?
That was the justification they've been waiting on for years.
Bait Iran with the embassy attack and then use the response to justify war.
Why do you think they backed down?
The protests are bigger already, aren't they?
Hopefully they don't get violent at all.
You might want to work on your communications skills.
And yes, I look forward to seeing them exposed as hypocrites again.
Not much point in working on communicating anything that doesn't fit into your narrative, Butler.
I've already learned that.
That you haven't noticed how much the political press in the US wants a brokered convention or convention riots and has for the last 20 years just shows how little attention you pay to the press.
From the hypocrites line, I assume your expectation is there will be protests and the Dems will welcome and encourage violent police action to break it up?
(I believe you even said the Illinois national guard will be involved?)
I think the same will happen in Milwaukee. The GOP are already whining about security to the Secret Service.
But yes, the elite Dems won't allow the plebs and serfs to spoil their coronation
I don't know.
There are any number of reasons.
The simplest would be that Israel didn't think it was ready to handle an escalation right now.
But yes, I was referring to the Times of Israel story since it sounds like you and Butler agree that is what happened and therefore the ground attack on Rafah must be imminent with full support of the US having been given.
Netanyahu wouldn't have bombed an Iranian embassy by accident or without planning for an escalation. The bigger question is why he didn't escalate it if he attacked the embassy with that in mind. The simpler explanation is that outside pressure held him back or the lack of US support for an Iranian war they can't do alone stopped him.
At this point I don't think it likely that there will be an attack on Rafah.
Netanyahu has had enough time to prep if he wants to do it. I think he's more interested in being on the cusp of attacking than actually attacking. Selling his government that they have to stand with him because it will happen while also realizing there is nothing to gain from a military advantage and much to lose of what's left of Israel's standing if they attack.
Right.
He couldn't handle an escalation at this time because the support he hoped for wasn't there.
That is completely different from "The US gave him a green light on Rafah if he doesn't escalate".
You do see that, don't you?
Interesting.
So you think that Bibi is rejecting Joe Biden's green light to ground invade Rafah?
Bibi is less "pro-genocide" than Joe Biden now?
Or have you completely given up on the "Joe Biden gave Bibi the green light" theory?
This is all starting to sound dangerously close to the idea that Israel is actually making its own choices about what Israel can do, and isn't a puppet of "Genocide Joe", who is single-handedly responsible for the death of all the Palestinians, if I recall your earlier rhetoric.
These protests don’t mean anything for policy in the states. It’s a pro israel government so the news is always going to spin it towards Israel. Also, the protestors are annoying the hell out of most civilians by blocking traffic. In the school protests they are even harassing Jews. Seems like it will continue to have a negative impact on what they are trying to achieve
Vietnam lasted a very long time and it was also a war the US was directly involved with. It’s a complex beast to compare to.
Regarding BLM and climate change, this is also something direct, but also a key aspect of it is capitalism. If companies did not stand up for blm and climate they would be alienating a large group of customers.
For Palestine, while humanitarian crisis in that region is one of the top reported news. events in the world, the United States is indirectly involved and will never strong arm Israel into acting differently. Also outside of news it just doesn’t track with most Americans. They have enough stuff at home to worry about. Companies and the government will also never ever take a stance that might be construed as anti-semitism. That’s why I believe these specific protests don’t matter.
These protests don’t mean anything for policy in the states. It’s a pro israel government so the news is always going to spin it towards Israel. Also, the protestors are annoying the hell out of most civilians by blocking traffic. In the school protests they are even harassing Jews. Seems like it will continue to have a negative impact on what they are trying to achieve
No, its not completely different. Its all part of the same message. The support he hoped for was from Biden, instead of that support he was offered some consolation prize in being supported in allowing an attack on Rafah, which Biden had been publicly opposing, if that's worth anything.
Do you also use straw man claims with students?
I understand that's part of maintaining power for some profs, but its not an honest way to debate or grade. Its making use of what you assume is the power of the position to mischaracterize others statement and maintain the position of expert. Your ability to analyze is strong, you don't need to resort to logical fallacies.
Another straw man argument here, valcazar.
Netanyahu (and I won't use his pet name to make him sound sympathetic as you do) has always been the one in the drivers seat, the one who chose to ignore warnings and chose to use the genocide as a way to save a political career in major trouble. Biden has a been a zionist for decades and has actively chosen to aid and abet the genocide, including signing off $26 billion in more weapons on the day the UN issued a report saying Israel is committing genocide.
Netanyahu has run multiple attacks on Gaza over the years and previous to the genocide had tried to do as much damage as possible without setting off mass foreign outrage. This is the first time he's pushed beyond that but this is also the first time he's been under trial for corruption and barely holding on to power. But this is also the first time Israel has been hit with UNSC resolutions, ICJ charges and rumoured ICC charges on him personally.
There is no military goal to attacking Rafah, there is nothing he can gain for Israel and the civilian casualties will be massive.
Haaretz seems to think Netanyahu is using the threat of Rafah as a bargaining chip with Egypt, I'm more inclined to think Netanyahu is using the threat to maintain power while he tries to think of another endgame other than a long visit to the Hague next time he leaves the country.
![]()
Analysis • Is Israel's coveted Rafah operation a strategic target or a bargaining chip?
For Egypt, ending the war is vital no less than it is for Hamas, and the preparations for a Rafah operation – which could worsen the humanitarian crisis, strain its relationship with Israel, and cause masses of Gazans to cross the border – have made the mediator an interested partywww.haaretz.com
![]()
Israel working to block feared ICC arrest warrants against PM, others over Gaza war
Government source says The Hague focusing on allegations that Israel 'deliberately starved' Gazans; IDF gives rare press briefing over Shabbat to highlight humanitarian effortswww.timesofisrael.com
As straw man arguments go, this one is particularly weak. Definitely not your best work.
Netanyahu is committing genocide and Genocide Joe sits in the one chair that could stop it and is instead aiding and abetting the genocide, sending in more weapons and still blocking international actions.
And yet here we are.
Protests for Palestine have been bigger than all of those now.
I see.
You are just determined to cling to the narrative you prefer regardless of any evidence one way or the other.
Oh well.
What straw man claims have I been using here?
You invented a deal that you had no evidence for and are now doubling down on that deal secretly being true despite the lack of evidence.
I'm not the one asserting things with no evidence, Frank.
You should also be very wary of thinking logical rigour is the be all and end all of an argument and logical fallacies are automatically bad.
That will lead you to all kinds of bad results in the real world.
Bibi is a fucking monster, I agree.
But you are now saying that he had the greenlight from Joe but isn't using it.
Given you consider Biden responsible for the genocide, the fact Netanyahau isn't prosecuting something Biden greenlit means he is more reasonable, right?
I know you can't suddenly be coming around to the idea that individual actors and nations and regimes have multiple pressures they contend with and multiple goals they want to achieve and the fact these things might interact and conflict in different ways means something to how things play out.
That would be crazy awesome for you suddenly to believe.
What?
He has his own agenda?
That's amazing!
When did you figure this out?
Holy shit, you think "Israel has agency" is a strawman?
After what you just wrote?
Do you even understand what a strawman argument is?
Wow.
You really do think "Israel has agency" is a complete fabrication even when arguing about all the reasons Israel and the current government have their own agenda for doing what they are doing.
Holy fuck.
That's amazing.
You think these have been bigger than the Vietnam war protests and the BLM protests?