Israel at war

Leimonis

Well-known member
Feb 28, 2020
9,946
9,743
113
TikTok is being banned to stop protests against Israel now?
Seems like a good idea to ban Chinese propaganda machine that is aimed at dividing and pitting western population against each other much like Russians did with Facebook in 2016
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Goodboy7

Frankfooter

dangling member
Apr 10, 2015
93,184
23,117
113
Seems like a good idea to ban Chinese propaganda machine that is aimed at dividing and pitting western population against each other much like Russians did with Facebook in 2016
Then you might as well ban the social media platforms run by right wing extremists as well.

How come there are so many more Jews at the Palestine protests than the zionist protests?

Even white supremacists can get a bigger crowd than zionists now.

Of course Yemen still wins.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu

Valcazar

Just a bundle of fucking sunshine
Mar 27, 2014
32,734
60,985
113
That's rather naive.

Trump has no real alliances except to those he owes money to.
He'll kiss Putin's ass, be friendly with MBS and Xi but would he keep backing Netanyahu in Nov when the genocide will either be over or incredibly horrific? Would he back Israel if AIPAC loses power? Will AIPAC risk funding rump if all they're doing is buying him more lawyers?

Do you really think that the genocide will continue until Nov and Israel could do something even worse then?
Are you under the impression Israel is stopping?
I thought you believed this has been going on for 75 years?
Why don't you believe Trump and the Republicans when they say they think Biden is too soft in his support of Israel?
Why don't you believe the Israeli government when they say Biden isn't supportive enough and Trump will be better?

Even if you think Trump will suddenly abandon Bibi, why do you think the party that is actively campaigning on being more strongly pro-Israel and anti-Palestenian winning the election will be a signal to the US government that it should stop being so pro-Israel?
 

Valcazar

Just a bundle of fucking sunshine
Mar 27, 2014
32,734
60,985
113
It's an interesting analogy to make.

I appreciate he admits he is forcing some things to make it fit - not everyone would do that.

As I said in the other thread, the threat of police violence is a real one.
The "People protested the vietnam war and got Nixon who escalated the war" is also a parallel about the unintended consequences worth reminding people of.
The campus protests are tougher to match up, of course - the Vietnam protests in 68 were at a different place than the campus protests now. The fact it isn't a war sending US troops to via draft can't be discounted.

But still, people are making the 68-2024 analogies for a reason and they aren't crazy to do so.
 

Frankfooter

dangling member
Apr 10, 2015
93,184
23,117
113
Are you under the impression Israel is stopping?
I thought you believed this has been going on for 75 years?
Why don't you believe Trump and the Republicans when they say they think Biden is too soft in his support of Israel?
Why don't you believe the Israeli government when they say Biden isn't supportive enough and Trump will be better?

Even if you think Trump will suddenly abandon Bibi, why do you think the party that is actively campaigning on being more strongly pro-Israel and anti-Palestenian winning the election will be a signal to the US government that it should stop being so pro-Israel?
Israel will stop the genocide, yes, but of course they won't stop the settler colonialism until outside pressure forces them.
2021, 2018, 2014, 2012, 2011, IIRC, all those attacks on Gaza stopped eventually. The longest being the Great March of Return, but that was only a weekly protest that lasted nearly a year. About 200 died and 14,000 or so injured, but it wasn't near what this was. This one is by far the most serious and deadly, and its only because Netanyahu is pressured and Biden is allowing it to happen. Previously Netanyahu knew when to stop before global outrage was too much, as when the 2021 protests became a PLM movement.

All Israeli attacks eventually stop.

The bigger problem is how to end the Negroponte doctrine and allow the UN, ICC and ICJ to finally take place and even more importantly, for the grassroots support for BDS to do what it did to South African Apartheid.

Will Netanyahu still be in power to try another attack in the next 4 years with an orange POTUS? That's unclear. He's incredibly unpopular but Netanyahu has survived other political challenges. Would he try this again? Unlikely. If he did would rump back him, probably. But will rump live through another 4 years in office? Also unlikely.

Will the dems change if Biden loses? Very likely. The wave against AIPAC is real and losing will look massive.

Your option is to put Biden back in, watch him protect Netanyahu as the ICC and ICJ try to rule and the US vetos those actions and blocks all UNSC resolutions, allowing the issue fester in the background for another 4 years until Ben Gvir or whoever leads next tries something much worse.

Do you really see that as better?
Do you have an alternate storyline that looks more plausible and has a better outcome?
 

Frankfooter

dangling member
Apr 10, 2015
93,184
23,117
113
It's an interesting analogy to make.

I appreciate he admits he is forcing some things to make it fit - not everyone would do that.

As I said in the other thread, the threat of police violence is a real one.
The "People protested the vietnam war and got Nixon who escalated the war" is also a parallel about the unintended consequences worth reminding people of.
The campus protests are tougher to match up, of course - the Vietnam protests in 68 were at a different place than the campus protests now. The fact it isn't a war sending US troops to via draft can't be discounted.

But still, people are making the 68-2024 analogies for a reason and they aren't crazy to do so.
Maybe comparing this attack on Gaza to the Tet Offensive is closer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu

Valcazar

Just a bundle of fucking sunshine
Mar 27, 2014
32,734
60,985
113
Seems like a good idea to ban Chinese propaganda machine that is aimed at dividing and pitting western population against each other much like Russians did with Facebook in 2016
The whole TikTok bill is more complicated than I want to get into right now.
I'm just curious if this is the argument that people actually believe - that TikTok is being banned because Israel demanded it.
 
Toronto Escorts