It is my belief that RedBag and WyattEarp are the same person.
I guess I am lucky that you didn't compare me to Hitler.
It is my belief that RedBag and WyattEarp are the same person.
You just don't understand the law.You're quibbling about process. Insurrection should be proven in a Federal court and decided by a jury. It's unequivocally U.S. due process. Colorado judges can't keep someone off the ballot (which is a form of punishment) for the crime of insurrection when no such crime has been tried and decided.
The dissenting judges in Colorado laid the entire argument out. Per the WSJ: The court’s chief justice, Brian Boatright, cited the lack of a conviction for insurrection in his dissent from the Colorado majority. And in a separate dissent, Justice Carlos Samour wrote that Mr. Trump was denied the “procedural due process” required before disqualification is justified. It's not complicated law.
It doesn't all really matter because I think the Supreme Court will overturn the Colorado court 7-2 or 8-1. Supreme Court Justices have lifetime tenure on the highest court in the country. The "Supremes" can free themselves of the political baggage that goes along with any Trump cases.
You know nothing about this Red Bag individual. Maybe Red Bag is worse than Hitler?I guess I am lucky that you didn't compare me to Hitler.
It's not as complicated as you want to spin it. Due Process requires a trial and decision. Don't get hung up on the jury concept. There were three dissenting judges out of seven making similar arguments.You just don't understand the law.
Civil cases are heard all the time without a jury. And those decisions are perfectly valid and procedurally correct and full due process. Are you telling me that no one in the USA is legally divorced because divorce court has no juries?
Facts are judicially found all the time in non jury cases and those findings are as correct and as legal as jury decisions. This appears to be something that you have difficulty grasping, probably because your legal education comes from reading DC Draino and other nonsense.
So if a motion is brought to strike Trump from the ballot for insurrection and it is found judicially as a fact that he is an insurrectionist, no one needs a jury trial. Trump isn't going to jail. He's just suffering a civil disqualification.
And spare me the "form of punishment" blablabla. A guy who's ordered to pay $5,000 per month alimony might feel that's a "form of punishment", but it's a civil ruling - just like being disqualified from the ballot in CO.
A lot of douche bags are red that's for sure.You know nothing about this Red Bag individual. Maybe Red Bag is worse than Hitler?
Now as far as SCOTUS and Gorsuch, the States have a lot of self-determination on how to conduct an election particularly for State and local elections. However, Colorado's court is interfering with a national election. The precedence of Federal control over elections is codified by several amendments to our Constitution. A good example is the 26th Amendment that gives U.S. citizens 18 years old and over the right to vote in ALL States in ALL elections. A State can't opt out and raise the age even in local elections.
I'm not sure I follow your logic. Insurrection in this case is really a Federal crime. Clearly if the Supreme Court let the Colorado ruling stand, then by inference Trump would be ineligible to run for President.Sure, but what they specifically cited him in was his decision that when it came to eligibility to be on the ballot, the individual states decided who was eligible.
The thing is, I don't expect SCOTUS to overturn the Colorado decision on the grounds the state can't determine eligibility in general or doesn't have control of its election.
(There is a really good argument to be eventually had as to whether or not States should have any say in Federal elections, but that's a whole other discussion.)
But Colorado is applying a Federal requirement here, though, so it isn't a case of them wanting to go cowboy or opt out of a Federal requirement.
The argument that is likely (if we are lucky) is going to be about what that Federal requirement actually entails and how it needs to be applied and adjudicated.
Another interesting historical reference is that I believe Lincoln was left off the ballot in several Southern states in the 1860 Presidential election.
I read people in Western Virginia (now the State of West Virginia) voted for Lincoln. Was it a matter of Lincoln's campaign not making an effort in the South or was there intimidation to prevent the Lincoln campaign from fair access to voters?No.
The Lincoln campaign didn't print ballots where it knew it had no chance. (And there was probably nobody who stepped forward and said he would vote for Lincoln in the electoral college in those states, so people couldn't even write in a vote.)
We didn't have unified "here are all the official candidate" ballots until almost 1900. (Can't remember when exactly, but I think late 1880s/early 1890s.)
Neither is the argument "if it weren't for checks and balances, Trump would be a dictator".
AFAIK, the appeal isn't about jurisdiction.I'm not sure I follow your logic. Insurrection in this case is really a Federal crime. Clearly if the Supreme Court let the Colorado ruling stand, then by inference Trump would be ineligible to run for President.
So perhaps we are saying the same thing from different angles, but I am saying this is a matter for Federal courts not individual State courts.
There's also the matter of our right to a trial by jury for a federal crime. Obviously, there was no jury decision in Colorado or elsewhere.
So much going on here. Does January 4 appeal still on or will it be connected to this decision? Does the Supreme court have to make a decision by January 4 for the Colorado decision?
Supreme Court rejects Jack Smith’s request for justices to quickly hear Trump immunity dispute
It's not as complicated as you want to spin it. Due Process requires a trial and decision.
As I said, I think some of the liberal Supremes will decide to throw this out. What then? Is it reasonable to question your legal education, your sanity? This is not the slam dunk legal decision you seem to be arguing.
I'm not sure I follow your logic. Insurrection in this case is really a Federal crime. Clearly if the Supreme Court let the Colorado ruling stand, then by inference Trump would be ineligible to run for President.
So perhaps we are saying the same thing from different angles, but I am saying this is a matter for Federal courts not individual State courts.
I read people in Western Virginia (now the State of West Virginia) voted for Lincoln. Was it a matter of Lincoln's campaign not making an effort in the South or was there intimidation to prevent the Lincoln campaign from fair access to voters?
Texas and California secede in this?
That's a really weird combination.
Civil War always was a contradiction in terms. These days it's downright ugly...I think it was mostly not making an effort in a lost cause, but the violent threats were almost certainly part of it as well.
That there also just flat out weren't any electors I think is true in some states as well. (No one was going to stand up and make themselves a target.)
My understanding is that in the end, Lincoln figured he didn't need the electoral college votes from there and there was no point in wasting resources.
He had solid majorities in enough states to win without contesting those states, so he didn't.