A better way to phrase it is did the siege of Gaza that is currently ongoing not start right after the Oct. 7 attack?Did any of these happen before Oct 7, shack?
A better way to phrase it is did the siege of Gaza that is currently ongoing not start right after the Oct. 7 attack?Did any of these happen before Oct 7, shack?
That's what happens when you try to fight someone more powerful than you...Did any of these happen before Oct 7, shack?
![]()
A better way to phrase it is did the siege of Gaza that is currently ongoing not start right after the Oct. 7 attack?
We hear your same repetitive justifications for the terrorist attack on Oct. 7 that killed 1,400 civilians.Yes, Israel has been doing the same thing for 75 years.
Wouldn't that be a refreshing post to see.I support the Oct. 7 attack by Hamas.
Wouldn't that be a refreshing post to see.
If that needle is causing so much pain, then Israel is willing to accept that criticism, haystack be damned. The needle poked too many people and needs to be removed.
If that needle is causing so much pain, then Israel is willing to accept that criticism, haystack be damned. The needle poked too many people and needs to be removed.
If that needle is causing so much pain, then Israel is willing to accept that criticism, haystack be damned. The needle poked too many people and needs to be removed.
And we've already agreed that a boycott would take years probably cost tens of thousands of Gazan lives than if Hamas surrendered and returned the hostages and the bombings and siege would end immediately.I support BDS, a Palestinian movement to end apartheid through non-violent sanctions.
Probably since the time Hamas has been firing rockets into Israel, even after Israel left the area.How long has the blockade of Gaza been going, shack?
What part of the rules I posted vindicate this?
Here is the post again.Under international law it's not that cut and dry. The rules of war still require a proportional proportionality analysis unless it's self-defense, but for it to be self-defense attacks have to be originating from the hospital or anticipated to originate from the hospital at the time the strike is initiated.
Your enemy is allowed to be at hospitals. They can be there tending to wounded, the can be there being tended to as wounded, they can be there visiting family, they can be there just hanging out. Even if it was a Hamas-only military field hospital, there are still parts of Geneva, Hague and Rome that apply protecting it. All hospitals are protected targets. Bring a protected target doesn't mean you can't attack them ever, but it means there are very strict conditions on when you can and "there are enemy there" is not sufficient. Certainly "there are probably some enemy there" isn't sufficient.
Yes.Here is the post again.
Direct fire from windows qualify?
None taken. I put it at the top in its own line for that reason.No offence, but I stopped reading after yes![]()