Will Israelis or Palestinians Win the PR War?

Butler1000

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2011
30,403
4,610
113
The Palestinians will, on account of their suffering being very real and right there in front of everybody to see.

But again, the audience also matters. Overall, I'd say the Palestinians will.
What part of the world? Because remember algorithms and peoole curate their social media intake. I'm sure in the ME we know who is winning. But I can say the same about Evangelicals in The USA. And yes that includes a lot of Democrats.

I think a lot of people, beyond a sentiment of not wanting to see people dead, have a more "a pox on both houses" attitude about Gaza at this point, and really won't care much if it all just goes away.
 

richaceg

Well-known member
Feb 11, 2009
13,833
5,618
113
The number of countries that support Israel is very low, even today. After a terror attack, Israel's own actions will mask Hamas' brutality.
Israel could care less about other countries support...None of those countries would came to Israel's aid during the 1947 attack from the arabs...from the 6 day war...
 

Leimonis

Well-known member
Feb 28, 2020
9,614
9,366
113
The real solution is for Israel to give back land to the Palestinians, and give them complete sovereignty.
if they could give that land to Tibet monks they'd probably do it tomorrow.
How are they expected to trust that Arabs would not use it to better arm themselves and attack again?
 

Leimonis

Well-known member
Feb 28, 2020
9,614
9,366
113
The attacking Arabs have all made peace with Israel which were namely the Arab nations around Israel. The current conflict is between a terror group and Israel. If Hamas is taken out, or fades away, and Palestinians also compromise, then peace is possible along with statehood.
I don't see it happening. What about falestin from river to sea? You have millions of radicalized people that fully believe that terrorism is a legitimate way to fight Jews and if they are given land it will only prove it. How is that going to fade away?
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill

toguy5252

Well-known member
Jun 22, 2009
15,964
6,107
113
The attacking Arabs have all made peace with Israel which were namely the Arab nations around Israel. The current conflict is between a terror group and Israel. If Hamas is taken out, or fades away, and Palestinians also compromise, then peace is possible along with statehood.
you may wish to invest in an atlas.
 

mandrill

Well-known member
Aug 23, 2001
76,086
86,346
113
Millions are not radicalized. Infact radicalization is not a pre-requisite for terrorism. Terrorism can exist without radicalization.

Remember Hamas is also elected.
Back in 2007, was it? Have they held free and fair elections since then?

Why would they? They're doing righteous, holy work. Plus getting VERY rich off corruption.
Its not about religion per se either. It is about land, culture, politics, religion and Israel's oppression of those people all tied into one. It is a sectarian conflict for which Israelis are equally guilty and infact share many of the same attitudes with the Palestinians that you would consider terrorism. I posted some videos, here is one I will link. Give it a watch.

So remove the issues about land, politics, oppression etc., through compromise, then that is a first step towards peace. Otherwise the way they live today is horrible. I was thinking about it yesterday that we are all so lucky to not have our accident of birth in the West Bank or Gaza. Can you imagine being locked in a land that you cannot even leave? Its horrible. That sort of thing is a breeding ground for terrorism.
Why can't they leave?.... Because other Arab countries won't allow them to.

Here's the problem. For 2 decades, the only version of the truth that they have been allowed to hear is that given to them by HAMAS. Sure. Some Gazans just want to live in peace and are great, smart, friendly people. So were some Germans in 1938.

Want to bet that a large % of Gazans hate Israelis and want to exterminate them? Because that's the only truth they've ever been allowed to hear?

If you were an Israeli, would YOU want your family to live next to them?
 
  • Like
Reactions: richaceg

toguy5252

Well-known member
Jun 22, 2009
15,964
6,107
113
Yeah but they won't attack Israel, as they haven't after their last try 75 years ago. And what is Urman?
sorry Yemen. Rockets have been coming into Israel for the last 2 weeks from Lebanon and their have been skirmishes with Syria an multiple rockets from Yemen have been intercepted, you can try and change history or geography butthe premise of your post was simply wrong.
 

Butler1000

Well-known member
Oct 31, 2011
30,403
4,610
113
The attacking Arabs have all made peace with Israel which were namely the Arab nations around Israel. The current conflict is between a terror group and Israel. If Hamas is taken out, or fades away, and Palestinians also compromise, then peace is possible along with statehood.
Lebanon? Syria? Nope.
 

toguy5252

Well-known member
Jun 22, 2009
15,964
6,107
113
Yes, now it is. Since the conflict has started again. But that is the purpose of making compromises and working on peace, for those things to not happen. The issues are not just from one side.
the point is that Israel is surrounded by adversaries. There are moments of quiet but the threat is always there. Israeli policy recently has not helped the situation and settlements and settler violence are definitely huge impediments but to Hamas and it Iranian master that is not the problem. The problem is the existence of Israel so unless that changes there can never be piece.
 
  • Like
Reactions: richaceg

Leimonis

Well-known member
Feb 28, 2020
9,614
9,366
113
That is Bibi's problem with Palestine as well. Their existence. The current Likud government, which runs on a platform of "No Palestinian statehood", has the same thinking. Which many Israelis support. Which is why I unequivocally condemn both sides for this mess.
ultra right fuck everything up, and so do ultra left :(
 

toguy5252

Well-known member
Jun 22, 2009
15,964
6,107
113
That is Bibi's problem with Palestine as well. Their existence. The current Likud government, which runs on a platform of "No Palestinian statehood", has the same thinking. Which many Israelis support. Which is why I unequivocally condemn both sides for this mess.
bibi is not good for any prop td for peace but driving the Palestinians into the sea is not the reason de etra for Israel. Israel has been trying to make peace for 70 years. The encroachment of the settlements has occurred because there has been no peace. The settlements are not the Palestinians fault but you cannot deny the connection. Israel in the past has said it would abandon many settlements as part of a peace deal but the apparent expectations by Palestinian leadership that they achieve 100% of their demands is a non starter as is the so-called right of return.
 

toguy5252

Well-known member
Jun 22, 2009
15,964
6,107
113
I agree Palestinians have a no compromise position, which is my criticism of them as well. But they feel, rightfully, that they cannot compromise given the land encroachment and the enormous hardships put upon them by the Israeli govt. They ask - 'what is left to compromise?". Which is legitimate. Will Israel even be able to remove the 670K settlers in the West Bank? Very unlikely. So how will they compromise? They cannot. So Israel's position, although not explicitly stated, is still a "no compromise" position, the same as the Palestinians.
the no compromise mindset means there will never be peace. I don’t know the number but users moved all Israelis out of Gaza which was a ver risky political move but they did it. Israel has always said the would and on or give some but not all the settlements in the WB. That is the nature of negotiation and compromise.
 

Frankfooter

dangling member
Apr 10, 2015
91,516
22,155
113
My point was that the public cherry picks issues to be concerned about. The Palestinians generate massive support. The Houthis and Eritreans are pretty much ignored. They rarely or never make the news and few people protest on their behalf.
True, but the US and Canadian governments also don't send billions in weapons to Houthis or Eritreans, nor do they declare them our closest allies.

Instead the MSM just buries the stories.

 
Toronto Escorts