Pickering Angels

Leafs 2023-2024 Thread

smuddan

Well-known member
Mar 7, 2007
2,306
303
83
Yes, but Marner totally disappeared in round 2 against Florida. Also, if I'm not mistaken, Marner has always been a poor playoff performer in previous yrs, with the Leafs!!
I’m not totally against trading Marner, he’s part of the core 4 and should share the blame for the team’s repeated playoff failures, but so should the other three and Tavares and Matthews in particular.

I would not however label him as “ totally disappeared “ in the Panthers series. He had one goal and two assists and Nylander had two goals and one assist. Both Matthews and Tavares each had one assist.

Dart made a good point about Marner’s 10m and Nylander’s 7m salaries but for reasons outlined in my previous post, I’d rather have Marner at 10 over Nylander’s 7m. You can’t trade all four and if one has to go, my choice would be Nylander.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mitchell76

smuddan

Well-known member
Mar 7, 2007
2,306
303
83
Yes, he is one of my favourite posters too. Intelligent, rational, objective, articulate and civil.

I'll just add one point. Marner is making $11mm, Nylander is making $7mm.
Old Irish proverb: "To whom much is given, much is expected."
Thanks for the kind words. The majority of us on this board are here to have a good time to talk about our favourite team and sports. There’s really no need to be aggressive and get personal.
 

superstar_88

The Chiseler
Jan 4, 2008
5,635
1,201
113
Leafs aren't going to trade Matthews. Big 40-60 goal centers are far too valuable in this league. Tavares is the one they should move but they can't. That's leaves Marner and Nylander. Not sure what they're going to do but it will be interesting.

If there's one thing we know now, it's that Florida has an insanely hot tender at the moment. He's been the difference maker. Boston, Toronto and Carolina aren't' bad teams. They just can't solve Bobrovsky.
The Boston series was very high scoring. Florida was the highest scoring team last year. By a wide margin actually.
This season Boston was 1 of 2 teams that scored more than 300 goals.
Bobrorsky against Boston in 5 games was 3.94 GGA 0.891 SV%
Against Leafs in 5 games he was 1.89 GGA 0.943 SV%
Against Carolina in 3 games so far he is 0.69 GGA 0.978 SV%

Boston had key injuries to Bergeron and Krejci and Ullmark didn't play game 7.
Game 7 went to OT so it was that close. Boston had the lead with a minute left in the 3rd period.
 
Last edited:

Ref

Committee Member
Oct 29, 2002
5,120
1,060
113
web.archive.org
Yes, but Marner totally disappeared in round 2 against Florida. Also, if I'm not mistaken, Marner has always been a poor playoff performer in previous yrs, with the Leafs!!
Management and coaching are what the Leafs need to focus on. Florida beat Toronto because of two things, lack of secondary players and they were out coached.

Many GMs' have the same challenge, they have a few highly paid stars and need to build a team around them. There is another thread that showed the top paid players between Florida & Toronto. The difference was only 4 million$. That's not much of a difference. The Florida GM (and other GM's) are more skilled at building a team to support those key players, and that is where Dubas has failed. Dubas even tried to change the "grit" factor at the trade deadline and that only resulted in winning the first round (against a tired Tampa team that limped into the playoffs).

Per the actual series, the Florida coaching staff designed a game plan on shutting down the core 4 and Keefe was unable to counter that strategy.

A stronger supporting cast and a reliable goalie (I cannot understand why they thought Murray was the answer!!!), perhaps a new coaching strategy and this group of men could bring it all home.

Put this core 4 on any other team (replace their core 4 stars), and that team is a legitimate cup contender.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mitchell76

superstar_88

The Chiseler
Jan 4, 2008
5,635
1,201
113
Career playoff stats for the Leafs:
Nylander 50 games 17 goals 40 pts -1 TOI 17:54
Marner 50 games 10 goals 47 pts +9 TOI 21:51
Matthews 50 games 22 goals 44 pts even TOI 21:39
Tavares 31 games 11 goals 22 pts -9

For MNM their stats aren't as good as regular season but between them are relatively comparable to how they stack up. Matthews being the best goal scorer and Marner being the best point producer. Marner's +9 also stands out. Marner and Matthews also play more minutes so have more of an impact.
Of the core 4 Tavares looks to be the weakest. Especially given his salary. His -9 stands out. He's more a PP specialist.

In only his second season Marner was fantastic in the first series against Boston. He played with Tavares and Hyman against the SuperLine and stopped them even strength. In 7 games Marner had 2 goals and 9 pts and was +2. Boston's PP was unstoppable though.

As for Nylander his best series was against Montreal. In 7 games he scored 5 goals and had 8 pts. He was also +3
Of note in that series Tavares was injured so Nylander wasn't tied to an anchor. He made Kerfoot look good.
Last year against TB he scored 4 goals and 7 pts. +1 also
This year 4 goals 10 pts in 11 games.
Against Columbus in 5 games he had 2 goals and 4 pts.
 
Last edited:

glamphotographer

Well-known member
Nov 5, 2011
17,104
17,311
113
Canada
Management and coaching are what the Leafs need to focus on. Florida beat Toronto because of two things, lack of secondary players and they were out coached.

Per the actual series, the Florida coaching staff designed a game plan on shutting down the core 4 and Keefe was unable to counter that strategy.

A stronger supporting cast and a reliable goalie (I cannot understand why they thought Murray was the answer!!!), perhaps a new coaching strategy and this group of men could bring it all home.
New GM means Keefe and the rest of the coaching staff are gone.
 

GameBoy27

Well-known member
Nov 23, 2004
12,901
2,904
113
Yes, but Marner totally disappeared in round 2 against Florida. Also, if I'm not mistaken, Marner has always been a poor playoff performer in previous yrs, with the Leafs!!
Just about every forward had disappeared against Florida in the last two rounds. Can you say Red Hot Goalie?
 

Insidious Von

My head is my home
Sep 12, 2007
40,201
7,531
113
Treliving, holy fuck, you'd think they could do better than that...Chicago Cubs clear the tracks!


Talk about failing miserably upwards.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mitchell76

smuddan

Well-known member
Mar 7, 2007
2,306
303
83
Time is of the essence to name a new GM to deal with the Matthews/Nylander/Marner situation before July 1st. After that date they will not be able to freely trade either Matthews or Nylander if they are not going to resign with the Leafs. Such decisions could also impact on their plan on Marner if one of the core three is to be moved for upgrades elsewhere. The new GM will need to start negotiations right away with these players and to seek potential trade partners.

Then there are the other 10 free agents to deal with. I hope their no 1 priority is to bring Schenn back. Rielly seemed to bring out the worse in any partner he played with but Schenn not only avoided that, he was also able to bring out the best in Rielly. He also brings physicality that the team so badly lacks.
 

Darts

Well-known member
Jan 15, 2017
23,023
11,256
113
Nylander's trade value will never be higher than now.

We are stuck with the three $11mm players because.................................

Who wants to pay $11mm when you (at least the Panthers did) can get a Matthew Tkachuk for $9.5mm per?
 

Ref

Committee Member
Oct 29, 2002
5,120
1,060
113
web.archive.org
Nylander has always been a strong producer. Not every forward on every team is the ultimate "two-way" player. He is also fun to watch as his puck handling and skating are amongst the best in the league. Marner is similar (and a little better) from a puck handling/skating perspective, however he excels in other areas (i.e. penalty killing).

The core is good and yes the Leafs overpaid for them as a group. But an experienced GM would have seen that and maybe not signed a Tavares.

What amazes me is how Reilly's game changed when Schenn came along. To me, a good GM and coach would have figured that out before the trade deadline.
 

Markdougs8989

Active member
Oct 8, 2021
214
120
43
I seriously believe that.

Tavares screwed over the Islanders by talking about how much he wanted to stay in New York so they didn't trade him, and now we see people are already photoshopping pictures of Matthews sleeping in L.A. King pyjamas.
If they don’t sign him by certain date I say trade him.
 

glamphotographer

Well-known member
Nov 5, 2011
17,104
17,311
113
Canada
I think Matthews is going to be asking for upwards of $15M and 3 years, the Leafs will ask for more term.
 

superstar_88

The Chiseler
Jan 4, 2008
5,635
1,201
113
It's official. Leafs have a new GM
He should have the best support group money can buy.
He can hire his own Spezza to pump fists with.

Calgary had more points than Florida this season yet missed the playoffs which made him available.
Pittsburgh lost their last 2 games to Chicago and Columbus to miss the playoffs resulting in GM fired.
Florida was that close to disaster losing their last 2 regular season games.
 
Last edited:
Toronto Escorts