you really can not be serious
Let me explain it in a way you would understand.
We need 10 cookies. We currently have 5. How many more do we need? The answer is we need 5 MORE cookies. Not 5 LESS.
In you go where you belong:
you really can not be serious
if the immigrant or a citizen is working in any job, then they are productive regardless of their pay scales. How much one wants to earn is the individuals right to decide, citizen or not.
Anything else is unadulterated bullshit
bring in low skilled people lowers national productivitythen they are productive regardless of their pay scales
Let me explain it in a way you would understand.
We need 10 cookies. We currently have 5. How many more do we need? The answer is we need 5 MORE cookies. Not 5 LESS.
Productivity
at the national level is typically defined and measured in terms of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) per capita,
increasing the volume of people without a proportional increase in the GDP reduces productivity- by definition
you are losing you grip on reality
where did you not learn economics ?
1. now pay attention
national productivity - Google Search
Productivity at the national level is typically defined and measured in terms of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) per capita, per employed
this is so wrong is mind numbing that you actually posted it
bring in low skilled people lowers national productivity
an electrician charging out @ $80 / hr is a hell of lot more productive than a minimum wage employee
2. A Canadian citizen has the right to decide how much they earn which is constrained by ... a job offer
you may think you should get paid 300k a year, but that aint happening until you get... a job offer
is this the reason for your sour, off putting uncompromising illogical nature ?
are you bitter because you were never offered the comp you think you deserve
3. An immigrant applying for Canadian citizenship does not have the same rights as a Canadian citizen>>> not until their application is approved , constrained by a ... job offer
you do not seem to appreciate the opportunity of a lifetime which is being offered here... Canadian citizenship
and all that is being asked is to secure a job offer
increasing volume of people, increases consumption of goods and services which consequently raises GDP. GDP is the value of the total good produced or sold. Learn basics of economics before you harp on about economics over and over again.
your too stunned to realize the amount anyone can consume is always less than what they make/ produce
Yup so per your own definition, productivity is defined and measured in terms of GDP per capita, per EMPLOYED. I said, what employment someone chooses for themselves is up to them. So whether they be Janitor or CEO, they both add to the GDP and consequently productivity.
actually until he / she becomes a Citizen, they are guest of CanadaThe only right an immigrant doesn't have that a Canadian has is the right to vote and run for office.
Nope it is an important productivity criteria which should not have been messed with by moronsJob offers are not required for immigration and should never be. That is a moronic policy.
Again, I ask you, specificity. You havent brought specific data. You dont have an argument. You are talking outta your ass.
adding via immigration an incremental janitor who makes less than the national average reduces productivity
You are too stunned to understand how ratios work
actually until he / she becomes a Citizen, they are guest of Canada
Nope it is an important productivity criteria which should not have been messed with by morons
Give me specific numbers or realize how god damn foolish you have been
- out of the 1MM immigrants how many are working?
- And how many of the 1MM immigrants are making more / less than the national average salary ?
- And how many are of the 1MM immigrants paying more / less than the national average in taxes?
news flash for you ignorant fool
you do not get to define evidence as what you specifically ask for
if you want specifics, go get them yourself
what a fool !
Not true at allIs that so? So then currently we must be producing more than we can consume!
???Aka our productivity must be super high.
So your earlier assertion of Canada suffering low productivity was a lie.
it also means that the 1M immigrants were super productive and your argument falls flat on its face.
nobody is expecting an immigrant to take lessDifferent jobs pay different standard salaries give or take a few based on how much a person is willing to negotiate. Again what jobs someone chooses to take, how much they are willing to accept as pay is up to each individual.
It is a free market and people get to pick and choose what they do and how much they get paid.
This has no impact on productivity. Infact you could argue that a person being paid less to do the same job as someone who is paid more, is infact more productive because they produce more for less.
Not true at all
consumers have been funding their consumption with ever increasing debt
Governments have been even worse
that is not going to end well
???
you are incredibly foolish
why would you not consider that it would take me 2 minutes to obtain evidence counter to such a damn fool statement like that?
![]()
not at all
i did not think you were that uninformed / foolish
wrong again
your priorities are ideological
learn some economics
the facts just keep mounting up against your ideologically driven position
again try applying logic /facts/ sound judgement before allowing your ideology todeterminedictate your position on an issue
nobody is expecting an immigrant to take less
we want well paid productive immigrants, hence the benefit of having a job offer in hand
you could try and argue that, but you would be wrong
this is plain and simple immigrants with in-demand skills & a job offer are going to be more productive than those with out
They are going to be a happier lot as well
We can not afford to bring in millions of people without marketable in -demand skills
Job offers are not given to people without immigration status and for people who are not physically present in Canada. It takes over a year for an immigration application to be processed so you expect a Canadian employer to give job to a guy who isn't even sure he would get through immigration for the next 1,5 years? There is absolutely NO possibility. Its moronic to predicate immigration on job offers. The govt rightfully deprioritized that.
Your goal is to create a catch 22 situation where an immigrant cant get a job without being here, and he cannot be here without a job just to prevent non white people from immigrating. That is purposefully malicious. Now I know why you were accusing me of socially engineering change. THAT is your biggest issue.
Immigrants who come in are some of the best and brightest with skills that we need. They can come here and look for a job and they will be productive. There is also no rush to be productive immediately from day 1. The can take their time.
You have no argument and you are talking outta your ass.
Question: how many times have you been proven wrong with a simple rebuttal ?
Answer: So many time I have lost count
you are wrong again
international job placement agencies in canada - Google Search
if it as you describe, these recruitment companies would not exist
people get international job placements all the time
just because you were not sharp enough to make it work for you, does not mean it cannot happen for bright intelligent immigrants
your priorities are ideological
learn some economics
the facts just keep mounting up against your ideologically driven position
again try applying logic /facts/ sound judgement before allowing your ideology todeterminedictate your position on an issue
It is YOUR ARGUMENT that I am using against you because you are bobbing and weaving around the issue.
So per your own data in this post, it means that Canadians in general are less productive, so it has nothing to do with immigrants. After all, you cannot blame low productivity on 1M immigrants that 40M Canadians couldn't fix.
So there is no reason to reduce immigrants. We have a shortage of labor per your own posts, so we should admit more to fill up those shortages.
Aka our productivity must be super high.
bullshitYup, "just a simple google search" eh? Yeah most of those are immigration fraud.
Sure... prior to submitted Ing their applicationNow I know how you get your "info". Those bright intelligent immigrants can come here and search on their own.
nope it makes all the economic sense in the world to prioritize the value of a job offerImmigration should never be predicated on job offers and the government was right to deprioritize it.
So far you have presented jackshit - google searches, immigration fraud placement firms, ZERO data to support your ludicrous and self contradicting claims.
you are stunned
you stated
which is incorrect as proven here
![]()
one of many times you put your economic ignorance on full display
it is a problem which requires fixing via upgrading the skills of the workforce
bringing in millions of unskilled immigrants is only going to make this issue worse
match up the immigrants with marketable skills to the numerous skilled positions available & everyone wins
the confirmation is a job offer in hand
it is that simple
your priorities are ideological
learn some economics
the facts just keep mounting up against your ideologically driven position
again try applying logic /facts/ sound judgement before allowing your ideology todeterminedictate your position on an issue
bullshit
people are placed international on a regular basis
those companies would exist otherwise
Sure... prior to submitted Ing their application
although it makes a lot more sense to have the employer pick up the cost of the travel ... go ahead be stupid
international students have 4 years to seek out and secure a job offer
it happens all the time
nope it makes all the economic sense in the world to prioritize the value of a job offer
i can not help you if you insist on remaining ignorant
your priorities are ideological
learn some economics
the facts just keep mounting up against your ideologically driven position
again try applying logic /facts/ sound judgement before allowing your ideology todeterminedictate your position on an issue
All based on your own argument. You argued productivity was low at first. And then you said we always produce more than we consume - which leads to the conclusion that productivity is high. Now you revert back to your old statement that productivity is low.
it is a problem which requires fixing via upgrading the skills of the workforceIf productivity is high - then immigrants are part of the system and they are doing well.
If productivity is low - then Canadians are to blame because immigrants are a minority.
this is not about assigning blame you moronIn both cases immigration is not to be blamed.
Given skills are measured by human capital factors and given human capital factors are being prioritized, the immigrants that come in are highly skilled and will therefore be highly productive and consequently the govt is focusing on the right things.
we have skilled labor shortages so we need MORE skilled immigrants matched up to the in-demand skilled job vacanciesWe have shortages and we are in a demographic decline, so we need MORE immigrants. Not less.
Just because you keep repeating "facts keep mounting up" doesn't mean you have any facts to actually support your ludicrous claims. You are talking outta your ass.