Donnies done!

The Trump derangement syndrome does not appear to be something that will simply be eradicated when Trump is gone from politics. The emotionality on both sides seems to be with us no matter who will be in power.

Only if MAGA lives on.
But now that Gen z is voting and the extreme side of the GOP lost bigly, its not likely to last.
DeSantis may try to keep it alive, but we'll see how he does.

Hopefully this is the end of the populist experiment in the US for some time.
 
The DNC doesn't have much to do with it.
They don't choose who runs or come up with the candidates.
I think the original poster might be referencing the machinations behind the scenes. I think the Democratic and Republican leadership has some sway in encouraging and discouraging who runs.

If the party leaders are not discouraging Biden and Trump from running right as we speak, I would be greatly disappointed.
 
Only if MAGA lives on.
But now that Gen z is voting and the extreme side of the GOP lost bigly, its not likely to last.
DeSantis may try to keep it alive, but we'll see how he does.

Hopefully this is the end of the populist experiment in the US for some time.
Populism appears to be here to stay not just here, but many Western countries.

I think it's a mistake for the Left to reject it entirely and not learn from it. That's the emotional aspect on both sides part. If populism challenges liberal thought, it gets dismissed out of hand and must be eradicated to achieve some greater virtue.

Canada does not have that challenge because you embody the Canadian polity perfectly and the CBC delivers the information that the polity wants. I'm paraphrasing of course, but I think that's the jest of what you have written here in the past.
 
I think the original poster might be referencing the machinations behind the scenes. I think the Democratic and Republican leadership has some sway in encouraging and discouraging who runs.

Sure, but that's not the DNC.
The whole "The DNC is secretly controlling the nominees" was just weirdo paranoia from the online Bernie crowd who needed a boogeyman.

If the party leaders are not discouraging Biden and Trump from running right as we speak, I would be greatly disappointed.

It looks like "discouraging Trump" involves trash talking him on TV and hoping he doesn't have the stamina to fight back.

I am sure there are behind the scenes discussions with Biden about running again among various people - but no one has the clout to order him not to run. A massively unified front might do it, but that's unlikely.
 
Populism appears to be here to stay not just here, but many Western countries.

Populism as a rhetorical style never goes away. It just ebbs and flows in intensity depending on what it is being deployed in service of.

"We, the real people, will strike back at those nasty elites" will always have appeal. How well it works and how dangerous it is has a lot to do with what is going on in the world, and who is being case as "we, the real people" and who is being cast as "those nasty elites".

I think it's a mistake for the Left to reject it entirely and not learn from it.

Lots of the left uses populism. Bernie's campaign was largely populist - especially the online faction.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
Populism appears to be here to stay not just here, but many Western countries.

I think it's a mistake for the Left to reject it entirely and not learn from it. That's the emotional aspect on both sides part. If populism challenges liberal thought, it gets dismissed out of hand and must be eradicated to achieve some greater virtue.

Canada does not have that challenge because you embody the Canadian polity perfectly and the CBC delivers the information that the polity wants. I'm paraphrasing of course, but I think that's the jest of what you have written here in the past.

CBC delivers the information the polity wants?
They just deliver the news, but feel free to post actual examples of what you mean.

Populism is not about politics, its about directing anger towards POC in order to install authoritarian leaders.
We've learned that lesson.

PeePee is pushing the anger side up here but trying to keep the racism out of it, which just leaves it as anger without either identifying the problem or providing solutions.
Unless its his bitcoin push.
 
The "hey, I rigged it for DeSantis in 2018" is kind of interesting.
But one's first reaction is to conclude "Hmmmm.... Donnie's even nuttier now than he was 2 years ago."
 
The "hey, I rigged it for DeSantis in 2018" is kind of interesting.
Lol...IMO GOP is done with Trump...they now have someone they thought would be realistically represent them...and typical Trump will not back down...he's still pretty much a dog in the election with his MAGA following...but looks like the GOP will back Ron D....bigly...
 
Lol...IMO GOP is done with Trump...they now have someone they thought would be realistically represent them...and typical Trump will not back down...he's still pretty much a dog in the election with his MAGA following...but looks like the GOP will back Ron D....bigly...

We will see how long that lasts.
They've crossed swords and backed off repeatedly when Trump goes after them.
Will they stick to their guns this time?

Anyone other than Trump is going to get lots of good coverage from the media - who desperately wants to pretend things will be back to normal with Trump gone.

The GOP just needs to stick together and not knife each other in the back or act like complete cowards.
Can they do it?
 
CBC delivers the information the polity wants?
They just deliver the news, but feel free to post actual examples of what you mean.

I don't watch the CBC.

I'm spoofing an earlier conversation where I think you inadvertently tripped up your words. When we were talking about media bias in the U.S. you proudly said the CBC was completely objective. Then you basically said the CBC delivers what Canadians want to hear.

I basically challenged the idea that only delivering news and information that Canadians wanted to hear was in fact not objective reporting.

I'm fairly certain it didn't come out the way you wanted. However, I still think you have a personal bias toward progressive causes and information that supports that view. I also think all news organizations have some bias.
 
But one's first reaction is to conclude "Hmmmm.... Donnie's even nuttier now than he was 2 years ago."
He could very well be nuttier than two years ago (and six years ago). If this is redundant I apologize, but that is a common effect of aging.

Trump could likely be clinically insane or demented or whatever in four years. However, he won't have a microphone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
Populism is not about politics, its about directing anger towards POC in order to install authoritarian leaders.
We've learned that lesson.

PeePee is pushing the anger side up here but trying to keep the racism out of it, which just leaves it as anger without either identifying the problem or providing solutions.

There are several populist policies that have nothing to with racial or migrant issues. Generally, populist issues that resonate get absorbed into mainstream thinking. You don't even notice it, but it happens.

For example, due to political conflict not everyone was on board with Trump in regards to taking on China. Now the Biden Administration has approached China much stronger. Another example might be NATO spending. I seem to hear more liberals questioning Europe's contribution to NATO and the Ukraine.

Migrant issues are always a delicate matter in any Western country. There's some support for migrants, but when numbers surge support wanes. Then you get into the electorate wanting the border secured, but not really wanting to know the details of how it's done.

It's much easier to throw a blanket around populism. It's a lot harder to discuss and dismiss the all the individual ideas that find popular support. "It's all about race" is kind of lazy thought.
 
It's a lot harder to discuss and dismiss the all the individual ideas that find popular support.

Populism isn't "things that have popular support" though.

Not sure how "be tough on China" is supposed to be populism, either. (Or why you think that started with Trump.)
Same with NATO spending.
 
We will see how long that lasts.
They've crossed swords and backed off repeatedly when Trump goes after them.
Will they stick to their guns this time?

Anyone other than Trump is going to get lots of good coverage from the media - who desperately wants to pretend things will be back to normal with Trump gone.

The GOP just needs to stick together and not knife each other in the back or act like complete cowards.
Can they do it?
I never followed US politics that much but from what I have seen, politicians don't have loyalty other than to themselves...backstabbing is one of the focal points in order to be a good politician...Julius Caesar can tell you I'm bang on...
 
I never followed US politics that much but from what I have seen, politicians don't have loyalty other than to themselves...backstabbing is one of the focal points in order to be a good politician...Julius Caesar can tell you I'm bang on...

No.
Politicians aren't purely venal nor are they only loyal to themselves.
Some are sure, and sometimes there would be better outcomes if they were.

But like thinking all CEOs are in fact amoral psychopaths, the reality is more complicated than that and will trip you up if you embrace the myth too hard.
 
No.
Politicians aren't purely venal nor are they only loyal to themselves.
Some are sure, and sometimes there would be better outcomes if they were.

But like thinking all CEOs are in fact amoral psychopaths, the reality is more complicated than that and will trip you up if you embrace the myth too hard.
Very well said.

Ego drives a lot of positive outcomes.
 
No.
Politicians aren't purely venal nor are they only loyal to themselves.
Some are sure, and sometimes there would be better outcomes if they were.

But like thinking all CEOs are in fact amoral psychopaths, the reality is more complicated than that and will trip you up if you embrace the myth too hard.
I never said all politicians are backstabbers...
 
Populism isn't "things that have popular support" though.

Not sure how "be tough on China" is supposed to be populism, either. (Or why you think that started with Trump.)
Same with NATO spending.
In my opinion, until 2016 there was a thinking that China and its growing middle class would be pulled into the Western sphere. I take a simple approach. If someone (in this case Trump) is criticized for policy actions, there is still some political capital in supporting the opposing view.

Even simpler said, Biden is tougher on China than Obama.

I know where this road goes. Even you play it. Trump cannot be given credit for anything. So be it.
 
Trump’s ego cannot take too much negative scrutiny from the GOP. The midterm elections are also a de facto GOP leadership convention in real time.
Trump’s base remains loyal bit it may not be enough for him, loosing the 2020 election and an anemic performance in 2022 midterms.
However the Democrats do not have a leader going into 2022 do they ?