Donnies done!

There are several populist policies that have nothing to with racial or migrant issues. Generally, populist issues that resonate get absorbed into mainstream thinking. You don't even notice it, but it happens.

For example, due to political conflict not everyone was on board with Trump in regards to taking on China. Now the Biden Administration has approached China much stronger. Another example might be NATO spending. I seem to hear more liberals questioning Europe's contribution to NATO and the Ukraine.

Migrant issues are always a delicate matter in any Western country. There's some support for migrants, but when numbers surge support wanes. Then you get into the electorate wanting the border secured, but not really wanting to know the details of how it's done.

It's much easier to throw a blanket around populism. It's a lot harder to discuss and dismiss the all the individual ideas that find popular support. "It's all about race" is kind of lazy thought.
Those aren't "liberals"; those are tankies. And they've been pro Russia and anti NATO for 50 years. Nothing to do with Trump or the GOP.
 
I don't watch the CBC.

I'm spoofing an earlier conversation where I think you inadvertently tripped up your words. When we were talking about media bias in the U.S. you proudly said the CBC was completely objective. Then you basically said the CBC delivers what Canadians want to hear.

I basically challenged the idea that only delivering news and information that Canadians wanted to hear was in fact not objective reporting.

I'm fairly certain it didn't come out the way you wanted. However, I still think you have a personal bias toward progressive causes and information that supports that view. I also think all news organizations have some bias.

Sure, there is always some bias in news sources.
CBC is just biased towards good journalism and fairly neutral commentary, reflective perhaps of the views of most Canadians.

Its kind of like the place I go first for american news these days is the Guardian.
 
In my opinion, until 2016 there was a thinking that China and its growing middle class would be pulled into the Western sphere. I take a simple approach. If someone (in this case Trump) is criticized for policy actions, there is still some political capital in supporting the opposing view.

Even simpler said, Biden is tougher on China than Obama.

I know where this road goes. Even you play it. Trump cannot be given credit for anything. So be it.

I don't know what credit you want me to give Trump here, though.

Some people thought China would be pulled into the Western sphere. Some people wanted to go harder on China.
Unless you want to say "it was elite consensus that China was going to become more Western but real Americans hated China and wanted a tougher stance but were being blocked by the out-of-touch elite" I don't think you can call it populism. You can say Trump's specific brand of anti-China stuff was populist but Biden certainly hasn't been following that lead. He seems to be dealing with China far more as "here is a major world power we have to deal with".

I am just struggling to understand your view of populism here.
 
Sure, there is always some bias in news sources.
CBC is just biased towards good journalism and fairly neutral commentary, reflective perhaps of the views of most Canadians.

That seems like some lame bullshit.

And Frank, my personal weakness is I am a perfectionst. Lol.

I can't give you a toaster for trying. Perhaps a slice of toast.
 
Last edited:
I don't know what credit you want me to give Trump here, though.

Some people thought China would be pulled into the Western sphere. Some people wanted to go harder on China.
Unless you want to say "it was elite consensus that China was going to become more Western but real Americans hated China and wanted a tougher stance but were being blocked by the out-of-touch elite" I don't think you can call it populism. You can say Trump's specific brand of anti-China stuff was populist but Biden certainly hasn't been following that lead. He seems to be dealing with China far more as "here is a major world power we have to deal with".

I am just struggling to understand your view of populism here.
Val, your bias here is Trump was not good on any policy. I'm guessing you might have been part of the group who criticized him for not having any positions or policies in 2016 then spent four years criticizing anything he tried to do.

You have to credit some of Trump's popularity with his skepticism for globalism. As I have said, my opinion is this skepticism accelerated under Trump. Remember the Trans-Pacific Partnership. Hillary switched her view and no one said boo. And yes, anti- globalism is a part of populism.

Be honest, you also have humped the race thing for the Trump phenomenon. Why would you want to dilute that?
 
Unless you want to say "it was elite consensus that China was going to become more Western but real Americans hated China and wanted a tougher stance but were being blocked by the out-of-touch elite" I don't think you can call it populism................

I would say that is the exact definition of populism. I think you are conveniently ignoring Wall Street and many multinational CEOs wanted to go soft with China. That's probably not completely changed.

In regards to the Trans-Pacific Partnership, here's a quote from The Guardian on a column discussing the characteristics of Sanders and Trump populism.

"Like Sanders, he opposes the TPP (Trans-Pacific Partnership), a pending trade deal among the US, Japan and 10 other nations, negotiated by the Obama administration and supported by Republicans in Congress. (Under pressure from Sanders’s challenge, Clinton broke with the Obama administration and now opposes the trade deal, despite having supported it while in office.) "
 
That seems like some lame bullshit.

And Frank, my personal weakness is I am a perfectionst. Lol.

I can't give you a toaster for trying. Perhaps a slice of toast.

Your loss, wyatt.
Do you even have media sources that you trust or like?

Val, your bias here is Trump was not good on any policy. I'm guessing you might have been part of the group who criticized him for not having any positions or policies in 2016 then spent four years criticizing anything he tried to do.

This I find amusing. The only rump policies seemed to be tax breaks for billionaires and deregulation so those billionaires could do what they want.
Please feel free to articulate what you really think his policies were.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
Squee, sometimes we all have to make difficult choices. With that in mind - If you could fuck EITHER but not both of Kari Lake or Ron De Santis's wife, who would it be?

Why can't I have both, WHY DO I HAVE TO CHOOSE???????

If I can only have one let me go with Kari Lake. Hey, how about throwing in Melania since Kari is a little older?
 
Why can't I have both, WHY DO I HAVE TO CHOOSE???????

If I can only have one let me go with Kari Lake. Hey, how about throwing in Melania since Kari is a little older?
rPhwN2CF0nnN2a0t.jpg

Kari's still got what I need, Squeezer. I'm thinking a "milf sandwich" with Kari, Mrs De Santis and Mandrill in the middle!
 
  • Love
Reactions: squeezer
View attachment 186515

Kari's still got what I need, Squeezer. I'm thinking a "milf sandwich" with Kari, Mrs De Santis and Mandrill in the middle!
Kari would be a freak in bed. Melania would just lay on her back and let out a small wimper at climax.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
Exit polls. If you have better info, please post it.

View attachment 186291
I have a different take on this. Many more suburban white woman voted for Abrams in 2018. Suburban women might be the most independent voters in the country right now.

One of the problems was it looks like Abrams lost some of the Black male vote. When you start dividing the electorate into races and project voter allegiance based on that, then Stacey Abrams needed more share of the Black male vote to have a chance.

This isn't an original idea. I have heard commentators say that Black men don't vote for Black women to the degree they vote for Black men.
 
Kari would be a freak in bed. Melania would just lay on her back and let out a small whimper at climax.
This is a rare point upon which we have 100% agreement. How would you rate Mrs De Santis?
 
Taking aim at DeSantis, Trump goes further than he should have
Biden said this week that it’d be “fun” to watch Trump and DeSantis “take on each other.” It looks like the Democrat was right.

Nov. 11, 2022, 8:00 AM EST
By Steve Benen
The New York Times published an article that quickly made the rounds among political insiders, especially in the Republican Party. Its lede was straightforward:

For months, former President Donald J. Trump has been grumbling quietly to friends and visitors to his Palm Beach mansion about a rival Republican power center in another Florida mansion, some 400 miles to the north. Gov. Ron DeSantis, a man Mr. Trump believes he put on the map, has been acting far less like an acolyte and more like a future competitor, Mr. Trump complains. With his stock rising fast in the party, the governor has conspicuously refrained from saying he would stand aside if Mr. Trump runs for the Republican nomination for president in 2024.

The article coincided with an Axios report that said the former president “is trashing Ron DeSantis in private as an ingrate with a ‘dull personality.’”

These reports ran 10 months ago, when Trump’s simmering rage about the Florida governor could still be described as “quiet” grumbling and “private” complaints.

As both Republicans look ahead to the 2024 presidential campaign, and much of the right sees DeSantis as the big GOP winner of the midterm elections — and Trump as the cycle’s big GOP loser — the words “quiet” and “private” no longer apply.

The first sign of public trouble came over the weekend when the former president headlined a rally in Pennsylvania, where he mocked the Florida governor as “Ron DeSanctimonious.” A few days later, after DeSantis won a second term, Trump used his social media platform to note that he received more votes in 2020 than the governor did this year.

Late yesterday, the former president abandoned all subtlety, slamming DeSantis as an “average” governor with “great public relations.” Trump added a series of related missives, taking total credit for the DeSantis’ rise to political prominence.

Part of the online tantrum included this eye-opening claim: “[A]fter the Race, when votes were being stolen by the corrupt Election process in Broward County, and Ron was going down ten thousand votes a day, along with now-Senator Rick Scott, I sent in the FBI and the U.S. Attorneys, and the ballot theft immediately ended, just prior to them running out of the votes necessary to win. I stopped his Election from being stolen.”

It’s difficult to say with confidence what in the world he was talking about, and it’s likely that the former president was simply sharing a delusional story he concocted in his head. But if Trump actually dispatched FBI agents and federal prosecutors to interfere with Florida’s election tallies in 2018, that would be worthy of its own investigation.

Recommended

MADDOWBLOG
Judge sanctions Trump lawyers over frivolous anti-Clinton case
Stepping back, what we see is a former president, the week before launching another national campaign, struggling with blame after many of his candidates failed in this year’s midterms, having a meltdown.

A small man, driven by jealousy and insecurity, sees an understudy getting attention. Fearing his mini-me will interfere with his ambitions, Trump has made a decision to treat DeSantis as a threat.

At a post-election White House press conference this week, a reporter asked President Joe Biden about Trump and DeSantis. The Democrat responded that he expects it to be “fun watching them take on each other.”

As things stand, it looks like Biden was right.
 
Val, your bias here is Trump was not good on any policy. I'm guessing you might have been part of the group who criticized him for not having any positions or policies in 2016 then spent four years criticizing anything he tried to do.

You have to credit some of Trump's popularity with his skepticism for globalism. As I have said, my opinion is this skepticism accelerated under Trump. Remember the Trans-Pacific Partnership. Hillary switched her view and no one said boo. And yes, anti- globalism is a part of populism.

Be honest, you also have humped the race thing for the Trump phenomenon. Why would you want to dilute that?

Why on earth would anyone pretend Trump wasn't a vile racist, though?
What benefit would there be to lying to yourself about that?

Trump was not good on any policy, Wyatt.
He could be steered into shit that was less bad if he didn't care about it or if people sold it to him a certain way.

Skepticism about gloablism can count as populism, sure (although you have to define your terms, since "globalism" can mean all kinds of shit).
Hilary dropping support of the TPP was in response to Bernie more than Trump. (And was probably a bad decision in terms of long-term strategic interest, in the end.)
I don't see anyone adopting Trump's "all agreements should be private deals between leaders of countries" as the new norm, though.

Also, Trump adopting positions other people had isn't the kind of "no one would do this if it weren't for Trump" thing you were pitching.

I would say that is the exact definition of populism. I think you are conveniently ignoring Wall Street and many multinational CEOs wanted to go soft with China. That's probably not completely changed.

What is the exact definition of populism? Being "hard" on China?
I agree that the framing of "They are fucking you over" is populist and Trump used that.
I don't see how it is supposed to have influenced Biden's China position.

In regards to the Trans-Pacific Partnership, here's a quote from The Guardian on a column discussing the characteristics of Sanders and Trump populism.

"Like Sanders, he opposes the TPP (Trans-Pacific Partnership), a pending trade deal among the US, Japan and 10 other nations, negotiated by the Obama administration and supported by Republicans in Congress. (Under pressure from Sanders’s challenge, Clinton broke with the Obama administration and now opposes the trade deal, despite having supported it while in office.) "

Yes. As I said, Clinton dropping it was mostly due to Bernie's pressure.
Bernie also framed it as "the elites are trying to screw you on this deal".

But being "tough on China" isn't populist. It is the reason you are giving for being "tough on China". (Or the reason you are giving for being soft on China, which can also be a populist position.)
 
Also, Trump adopting positions other people had isn't the kind of "no one would do this if it weren't for Trump" thing you were pitching.

I feel like I hit that Trump nerve. I don't think I said "no one would do this if it weren't for Trump". Either was I giving him credit for originality. I don't think most Presidents independently originate policy anyway. They just bring them to the forefront through that communication thing you don't think is important as I do.

From previous discussions, you might recollect I said all Presidents leave a mark good and bad. I think Trump put more effort into certain policies than his predecessors. I don't agree it was all bad. If that leaves you in a place where you have to defend every Biden action or policy and attack every Trump policy, that's your prerogative. Biden certainly has gone in a different direction on many things.

As far as TPP, I didn't say Hillary opposed it because of Trump. However, Trump and Sanders brought it to the forefront and it's now considered mainstream policy. As a sidebar, I don't think all trade deals are necessarily good for the average American.

What is the exact definition of populism? Being "hard" on China?
I agree that the framing of "They are fucking you over" is populist and Trump used that.
I don't see how it is supposed to have influenced Biden's China position.

I think I actually said certain populist policies get absorbed into ongoing policy (actually mainstream thinking is my exact quote). Yeah, it's more innocuous a comment than your reaction. It wasn't necessarily a Trump specific commendation.

Would Biden have been tough on China irregardless of the Trump Administration, maybe. You can't really isolate policy relative to time. Particularly with foreign policy, every Administration tries to find a positive path forward with adversaries and allies that are also dynamic.

Look, you don't have to read my words and make arguments. You could simply Google "Trump populism" and you would get a host of perspectives that discuss China, TPP, America First along with common themes with Sanders. Of course, Sanders populism differs in key areas. If you think Trump populism was bad for race relations, fine. This discussion was really about Trump populism beyond racism. I guess you think not.
 
Last edited:
I feel like I hit that Trump nerve. I don't think I said "no one would do this if it weren't for Trump". Either was I giving him credit for originality. I don't think most Presidents independently originate policy anyway. They just bring them to the forefront through that communication thing you don't think is important as I do. From previous discussions, you might recollect I said all Presidents leave a mark good and bad.

If all you were saying is "Trump did some things that had an impact" well... sure.
It is basically impossible for a President not to.

I think Trump put more effort into certain policies than his predecessors. I don't agree it was all bad. If that leaves you in a place where you have to defend every Biden action or policy and attack every Trump policy, that's your prerogative. Biden certainly has gone in a different direction on many things.

Why would that put me in a position where I have to defend ever Biden policy or attack every Trump policy? (Speaking as an administration.)

As far as TPP, I didn't say Hillary opposed it because of Trump. However, Trump and Sanders brought it to the forefront and it's now considered mainstream policy. As a sidebar, I don't think all trade deals are necessarily good for the average American.

Neither do I. In fact, I think TPP had lots of problems and I opposed it. But dropping it unceremoniously and not engaging in any international trade structure afterward was ceding the playing field to China in particular, and I think that was probably a bad choice.

I think I actually said certain populist policies get absorbed into ongoing policy (actually mainstream thinking is my exact quote). Yeah, it's more innocuous a comment than your reaction. It wasn't necessarily a Trump specific commendation.

There aren't really any populist policies though.
There is just populist framing. And yes, it can get into mainstream thinking, sure.
But there's nothing special about populism there - that's just politics. Shit gets discussed and promoted and some of it becomes the conventional position.

Would Biden have been tough on China irregardless of the Trump Administration, maybe. You can't really isolate policy relative to time. Particularly with foreign policy, every Administration tries to find a positive path forward with adversaries and allies that are also dynamic.

I agree, which is why I thought you comparing him to Obama's position and implying that was due to Trump specifically so odd.

Look, you don't have to read my words and make arguments. You could simply Google "Trump populism" and you would get a host of perspectives that discuss China, TPP, America First along with common themes with Sanders. Of course, Sanders populism differs in key areas. If you think Trump populism was bad for race relations, fine. This discussion was really about Trump populism beyond racism. I guess you think not.

Trump's populism goes beyond racism, sure.
Bernie's populism goes beyond racism as well.
 
Neither do I. In fact, I think TPP had lots of problems and I opposed it. But dropping it unceremoniously and not engaging in any international trade structure afterward was ceding the playing field to China in particular, and I think that was probably a bad choice.

Okay, I think multilateral trade agreements are very unworkable. You lose some of you sovereignty in these arrangements for good and mostly bad. (You might realize I don't think Brexit will be bad for Britain in the long-run.)

As far as the China thing, I think that was scare tactics. I look at the list of TPP countries and I see countries that either want to replace China as the U.S.' primary supplier or countries that want to sell China commodities. No offense, but Canada, Australia and Chile are not going to sell their commodities at a discount to the United States and other TPP members simply because of the TPP.

I think Wall Street thinks they are going to open some doors with accessibility to the U.S, economy. First, that benefits the financial community at the expense of many others. Second, I believe financial services are very sticky and difficult to liberalize in many TPP countries.

Look at Mexico, the President of Mexico is not a big fan of free trade even though Mexico would appear to be a big beneficiary of the USMCA trade agreement.
 
Last edited:
I disagree with both of you! Melania would look at you and say, "that all you hev, I vanted Justeen and I end up wit mandril and Vyatt"
I'm reconsidering my rejection of Boebert. I'm seeing her over Kari Lake's knees with her jeans pulled down. (I doubt she wears panties). Boebert is screeching "No, Auntie Kari! No! I'm too old to spank!"

But Kari just says "And to think that my very own niece Boebert was caught selling blowjobs to those ghastly illegal immigrant men for $20 behind the Capitol! You'll be too sore to sit for a month, missy!"
 
  • Wow
Reactions: squeezer