Val, your bias here is Trump was not good on any policy. I'm guessing you might have been part of the group who criticized him for not having any positions or policies in 2016 then spent four years criticizing anything he tried to do.
You have to credit some of Trump's popularity with his skepticism for globalism. As I have said, my opinion is this skepticism accelerated under Trump. Remember the Trans-Pacific Partnership. Hillary switched her view and no one said boo. And yes, anti- globalism is a part of populism.
Be honest, you also have humped the race thing for the Trump phenomenon. Why would you want to dilute that?
Why on earth would anyone pretend Trump wasn't a vile racist, though?
What benefit would there be to lying to yourself about that?
Trump was
not good on any policy, Wyatt.
He could be steered into shit that was less bad if he didn't care about it or if people sold it to him a certain way.
Skepticism about gloablism can count as populism, sure (although you have to define your terms, since "globalism" can mean all kinds of shit).
Hilary dropping support of the TPP was in response to Bernie more than Trump. (And was probably a bad decision in terms of long-term strategic interest, in the end.)
I don't see anyone adopting Trump's "all agreements should be private deals between leaders of countries" as the new norm, though.
Also, Trump adopting positions other people had isn't the kind of "no one would do this if it weren't for Trump" thing you were pitching.
I would say that is the exact definition of populism. I think you are conveniently ignoring Wall Street and many multinational CEOs wanted to go soft with China. That's probably not completely changed.
What is the exact definition of populism? Being "hard" on China?
I agree that the framing of "They are fucking you over" is populist and Trump used that.
I don't see how it is supposed to have influenced Biden's China position.
In regards to the Trans-Pacific Partnership, here's a quote from The Guardian on a column discussing the characteristics of Sanders and Trump populism.
"Like Sanders, he opposes the TPP (Trans-Pacific Partnership), a pending trade deal among the US, Japan and 10 other nations, negotiated by the Obama administration and supported by Republicans in Congress. (Under pressure from Sanders’s challenge, Clinton broke with the Obama administration and now opposes the trade deal, despite having supported it while in office.) "
Yes. As I said, Clinton dropping it was mostly due to Bernie's pressure.
Bernie also framed it as "the elites are trying to screw you on this deal".
But being "tough on China" isn't populist. It is the reason you are giving for being "tough on China". (Or the reason you are giving for being soft on China, which can also be a populist position.)