Ukraine war - how we got here

Syria's problems started as a climate change/drought caused farmers protests that escalated into protests against Assad's authoritarianism.
The US, Turkey, Iran, Israel and Lebanon were all meddling and none of it helped.
You can't blame that one on the US.
You missed Russia on that list. You know, the guys with military bases there and who was hugely involved in airstrikes on Aleppo.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
I know we've been picking on nottiboy but this articulation of his position is perfectly clear.
"Every war requires at least one belligerent to conclude that it can create a more favorable future for itself though war "
Russia feels it can make a more favorable future by this war and so therefore is doing it.
It's basic Clausewitz of war as an extension of politics.

You can even argue the whole build up is just compellence that failed.
Putin ups his threats and escalates to compel Ukraine and NATO to submit to his demands.
It fails, so he decides he needs to escalate more.
 
I know we've been picking on nottiboy but this articulation of his position is perfectly clear.
"Every war requires at least one belligerent to conclude that it can create a more favorable future for itself though war "
Russia feels it can make a more favorable future by this war and so therefore is doing it.
It's basic Clausewitz of war as an extension of politics.

You can even argue the whole build up is just compellence that failed.
Putin ups his threats and escalates to compel Ukraine and NATO to submit to his demands.
It fails, so he decides he needs to escalate more.
I think the issue most westerners have is that the "more favourable future" is apparent only to the Russians and is nonsensical to everyone else. To perceive an advantage to invading Ukraine, you have to buy into the Russian belief system that all Slavs have to be subservient to Moscow and that any departure from this should be met with death and military conquest. This is extremely disturbing and more appropriate to Ivan the Terrible in the 1550's than anything in the modern world.

Add thereto the rhetoric that all political action that is not Moscow-directed Pan Slavism is "Nazism" and the assumption that all Ukrainians really desire to be subservient to Moscow and they are simply misled by corrupt Western politicians and one is in truly lunatic territory.

 
Last edited:
I think the issue most westerners have is that the "more favourable future" is apparent only to the Russians and is nonsensical to everyone else. To perceive an advantage to invading Ukraine, you have to buy into the Russian belief system that all Slavs have to be subservient to Moscow and that any departure from this should be met with death and military conquest. This is extremely disturbing and more appropriate to Ivan the Terrible in the 1550's than anything in the modern world.

Add thereto the rhetoric that all political action that is not Moscow-directed Pan Slavism is "Nazism" and the assumption that all Ukrainians really desire to be subservient to Moscow and they are simply misled by corrupt Western politicians and one is in truly lunatic territory.

It still seems to me to be more about Putin becoming a totally isolated dictator who was told how successful he was and how powerful his army was endlessly.
So he really thought he could take out Zelenskiy in Kyiv in one day and install a puppet government and be done with it.
Victory parade on Tuesday.

That the army had a plan B with 60km of convoy was Putin doing his due diligence since it would never be needed,
As soon as the attack at Kyiv's airport failed the war was lost.

Putin is stuck now, he can't admit he lost, keeps having to send away his generals, has killed the best of his fighting forces and equipment so is trying to make a show of 'capturing' the breakaway states that declared themselves independent and asked for his military before the war.

His only accomplishment is destroying Mariupol and possibly controlling the ruins.


 
Yup, Russia should be on that list.

Though it seems like only one country on that list is still bombing Syria.
Hey, your Israel obsession again.

And considering Canada considers Iran's Quds Force to be a terrorist entity who is openly devoted to Israel's destruction, I'm not going to cry rivers when Israel hits their bases.
 
I think the issue most westerners have is that the "more favourable future" is apparent only to the Russians and is nonsensical to everyone else. To perceive an advantage to invading Ukraine, you have to buy into the Russian belief system that all Slavs have to be subservient to Moscow and that any departure from this should be met with death and military conquest. This is extremely disturbing and more appropriate to Ivan the Terrible in the 1550's than anything in the modern world.

Add thereto the rhetoric that all political action that is not Moscow-directed Pan Slavism is "Nazism" and the assumption that all Ukrainians really desire to be subservient to Moscow and they are simply misled by corrupt Western politicians and one is in truly lunatic territory.

I don't think invading the Ukraine was on most Russians' bucket list. Strictly Putin's idea. I don't think his military advisors were strong arming him into invading. Nor the Russian populace. They already have the biggest land mass around with 11 time zones. World war 3 is being started by one cocksucker.
 
Last edited:
I think the issue most westerners have is that the "more favourable future" is apparent only to the Russians and is nonsensical to everyone else.

Sure.
But then the question is just "whose reality do you believe"?