Grey Cup Tickets

What about his other two points? You don't need the link to answer those points.

Or are you going to turtle on those?


Shack waiting for a new Darts post


 
A member made the following statement:
"100% of all coaches who have won the toss have deferred and taken the ball second."
Is it too much to ask for a link or something to support that 100%?

Yes, I understand the "logic" of giving the other team the ball first to see what they do with it but 100% is a big number.

If there are no links or other support for the 100%, so be it. I'm not going to lose any sleep over it.
 
A member made the following statement:
"100% of all coaches who have won the toss have deferred and taken the ball second."
Is it too much to ask for a link or something to support that 100%?
How many times have you seen the team that wins the toss, elect to receive the ball in the overtime. That's in the CFL of course. Have you seen a coach employ your strategy?

Not essential, but maybe you could also tell us where you were living at the time and provide a picture of a group of unattractive naked ladies, photoshopped or not. LOL.
 

This study was done in 2007. There was 328 football games under this overtime format. 324 times or 99% the team that won the toss deferred. Is that enough for you?

The study found overall there was a slight advantage overall of going with this deferral strategy.

Another study said it really does not make much of a difference.

Not surprisingly neither found deferring was a bad strategy.
 
Last edited:

This study was done in 2007. Is there a more recent study than 2007? There was 328 football games under this overtime format. 324 times or 99% the team that won the toss deferred. Is that enough for you?

The study found overall there was a slight advantage overall of going with this deferral strategy.

Another study said it really does not make much of a difference.

Not surprisingly neither found deferring was a bad strategy.
"The study found overall there was a slight advantage overall of going with this deferral strategy."
"Another study said it really does not make much of a difference."

I knew there were studies that indicate a very slight advantage or no difference in the results. What was missing in those articles was that coaches chose deferred 99% of the time even though statistically it didn't make any meaningful difference in the result.

In the Grey Cup game, the Bombers had a great offensive 4th quarter (15 points) albeit they had the wind. So, I thought it was a mistake to give them the ball first, and I was right.

P.S. Maybe the teams that won the coin toss should elect taking the ball more often than 1% of the time. Maybe, the result will be better than roughly 50-50? Or, maybe not?
 
Last edited:
3. 100% of all coaches who have won the toss have deferred and taken the ball second. This is not my opinion of what they should do. This is fact of what they have done. But yes Darts knows more then every college football and CFL coach in the last 10 years.

I could literally sit down with a 10 year old and explain why this strategy makes sense in less than 2 minutes.


and

This study was done in 2007. There was 328 football games under this overtime format. 324 times or 99% the team that won the toss deferred. Is that enough for you?

The study found overall there was a slight advantage overall of going with this deferral strategy.


Another study said it really does not make much of a difference.

Not surprisingly neither found deferring was a bad strategy.

Your own quoted studies above indicate that although deferral is the most common choice made by coaches, that overwhelming choice does not in fact seem to hold much value or make much sense at all based on outcomes observed. It's just all just a crap shoot. You should maybe defer sitting down with that 10 year old. No point looking foolish in front of a kid by stating categorically that deferring possession is ALWAYS the right choice.
 
Your own quoted studies above indicate that although deferral is the most common choice made by coaches, that overwhelming choice does not in fact seem to hold much value or make much sense at all based on outcomes observed. It's just all just a crap shoot. You should maybe defer sitting down with that 10 year old. No point looking foolish in front of a kid by stating categorically that deferring possession is ALWAYS the right choice.

Darts said it was wrong and essentially stupid for a team to give the other team the ball first and is the reason they lost.

neither study said deferring was the wrong strategy nor that it is a losing strategy.

Logically if a study says there is a slight advantage to doing something, it is not defending the person that says it’s a losing strategy.

At the end of the day I proved that is what coaches did and showed there was generally slight advantage to doing it. Darts claimed going second was a big mistake and claimed that it was not what all coaches did — you are going to give him the W? Sure thing. I’ll take the W here and move on to a few other threads at my convenience.

Which reminds me. The Ovechkin thread. The one where you made claim after claim that was incorrect and I countered over and over. I let you have the last word where you said “sorry not sorry” because it was getting frustrating to argue with someone who was wrong over and over again.

On the agenda over the next few weeks when I have time;
1) Taking down your last “sorry not sorry” Ovechkin post.
2) Discussing the Darts “Montreal System” posts
 
Can someone explain why Hamilton gave Winnipeg the ball in OT?
"Can someone explain why Hamilton gave Winnipeg the ball in OT?" Full stop.
The above quote is my original question. Actually, a very simple question.
 
Darts said it was wrong and essentially stupid for a team to give the other team the ball first and is the reason they lost.

neither study said deferring was the wrong strategy nor that it is a losing strategy.

Logically if a study says there is a slight advantage to doing something, it is not defending the person that says it’s a losing strategy.

At the end of the day I proved that is what coaches did and showed there was generally slight advantage to doing it. Darts claimed going second was a big mistake and claimed that it was not what all coaches did — you are going to give him the W? Sure thing. I’ll take the W here and move on to a few other threads at my convenience.

Which reminds me. The Ovechkin thread. The one where you made claim after claim that was incorrect and I countered over and over. I let you have the last word where you said “sorry not sorry” because it was getting frustrating to argue with someone who was wrong over and over again.

On the agenda over the next few weeks when I have time;
1) Taking down your last “sorry not sorry” Ovechkin post.
2) Discussing the Darts “Montreal System” posts

I never said Darts was right. I said YOU were wrong in some of your assertions. You'd have been fine if you'd stopped with saying pretty much all coaches have made the same situational decision - that part was pretty much correct.

But then you went and said 'But yes Darts knows more then every college football and CFL coach in the last 10 years.' There you pretty much face-planted. Based on the studies you quoted, seems Darts is no smarter or dumber than any college or CFL coach - he's just not a lemming, blindly going along doing what every other coach does, even when the results don't really provide any real value or advantage towards the outcome. On that point you have been, through your own words, proven wrong. Your attempt to be a smart guy and slap down Darts seems to have blown up in your face on that one.

Regarding the Ovechkin thread - you were wrong. Let it go. You're still obviously psychologically torturing yourself over it. No one but you really cares anyway, and have long since moved on. I'm certainly not interested in arguing with you, so if you have a date already pencilled in on the calendar to start up again - get a life.

In terms of the Darts "Montreal System" posts. Again - get a life. Some of you seem overwhelmingly and unnaturally obsessed with this discussion. And Darts keeps pulling the puppet strings just to make you react, which you do each and every time. Talk about gullible.

Most septuagenarians like you guys that I know are a little more mature and world-wise than to keep getting their chains yanked. Have you any idea how ridiculous you guys look 'demanding' answers and 'substantiating evidence' from a stranger shit-posting on the internet just for the fun of it? He jiggles his dick a tad and you guys hit the roof each and every time. Talk about looking like fools. :rolleyes:
 
Feel free to also discuss the "Toronto System" also known as the "Shanaplan".
One has nothing to do with the other.

Although, I know that you want to divert attention from the fact that there has never been a "Montreal system" that you seem to think has been in existence since the 50's. It is a fabrication of your mind. Scour the internet and there are zero references Why is that darts? Why is there nothing when you Google "Montreal system"? You've never answered that.

Not surprisingly when you Google Shanaplan there's tonnes of stuff. The Shanaplan is real. The Montreal System is a fantasy like the Loch Ness monster or the Abominable Snowman. That's why it's a more interesting topic.

the montreal system of building a hockey team - Google Search There's nothing that supports your position. It's interesting because it exposes your fraudulent claims.

shanaplan - Google Search 24,000 results. It's common knowledge and it's only been around a relatively short time.

So the discussion is not about the relative success of each franchise, it's about what is real and about what is your B.S. The proof of your B.S. is that you are the only person in history to talk about the Montreal system of team building.
 
Every NHL team has or should have a system whether it is posted on the internet or not. A team without a system is not a team, just a bunch of guys thrown together. Disorganized, chaos, etc.
 
Every NHL team has or should have a system whether it is posted on the internet or not. A team without a system is not a team, just a bunch of guys thrown together. Disorganized, chaos, etc.
You refer to a specific "Montreal system" that has made them the most successful franchise in hockey since the 40's or 50's. Why are there no references to it anywhere on the internet? You're the only person that seems to be aware of its' existence. Even you must find that unusual, don't you think?