Grey Cup Tickets

Can someone explain why Hamilton gave Winnipeg the ball in OT?

Beats the shit out of me. The theory is that Hamilton wanted to know what Winnipeg scored so they would know what they needed to do.

Why Hamilton gave up the last safety point to make the field goal tie possible is a whole other question. The guy had room to run the ball out of the end zone...
 
Even though I lived in Calgary for 3 years I am East born and raised but Winnipeg is a worthy winner. Still don't understand why Hamilton gave Winnipeg the ball in OT? I use to have a J5V football but it has since disappeared.
ba919p_1600x.jpg
 
Still don't understand why Hamilton gave Winnipeg the ball in OT? I use to have a J5V football but it has since disappeared.
View attachment 107551

J5V: Best football ever.

It was an advantage to Hamilton to let Winnipeg go first in overtime because then the Ticats know if they have to score a touchdown or if they can just kick a field goal - it greatly affects offensive strategy and play calling.
Exciting finish; great game in the end.
 
  • Like
Reactions: xmontrealer
Canadian football could use an extra down. One short run and one incomplete pass and it's punt or field goal attempt almost every time...
Because it's "Canadian football", it's a kicking game, opposing defences line up a yard from the scrimmage line, 12 yards wider than the NFL field , 10 yards longer field with 20 yard end zones.
 
Last edited:
Even though I lived in Calgary for 3 years I am East born and raised but Winnipeg is a worthy winner. Still don't understand why Hamilton gave Winnipeg the ball in OT? I use to have a J5V football but it has since disappeared.
View attachment 107551

I've had plenty of those Jake Gaudaur signature JFVs as a teenager, it was a fatter ball than the Pete Rozelle signature NFL ball.

Wilson now makes the CFL ball , it's same size as the NFL ball .
 
Even though I lived in Calgary for 3 years I am East born and raised but Winnipeg is a worthy winner. Still don't understand why Hamilton gave Winnipeg the ball in OT? I use to have a J5V football but it has since disappeared.
View attachment 107551

I
It’s the same procedure in OT as NCAA football has had for years. One team starts and the other team gets the chance to math . And 100% of the time the team that wins the toss gives the ball to the other team to start. It’s a big enough advantage.

The theory is fairly accurate simple to understand. The team with the ball second has the advantage as they know what to do.

The team with the ball first gets to third down and they have to typically kick a FG. They basically only have 2 plays to get 10 yards before kicking. If they get a TD, the second team basically has 3 downs to get 10 yards because the FG is out of the question.
 
Last edited:
It’s the same procedure in OT as NCAA football has had for years. One team starts and the other team gets the chance to math . And 100% of the time the team that wins the toss gives the ball to the other team to start.
i think the wind was also a factor in this game. It's obvious that the team that gets the ball first will try for the TD (and two point conversion?).

Anyway, the strategy backfired on the Ti-cats.
 
i think the wind was also a factor in this game. It's obvious that the team that gets the ball first will try for the TD (and two point conversion?).

Anyway, the strategy backfired on the Ti-cats.

Please explain to me in a logical way how thr strategy backfired for Hamilton. They “lost” is not a logical explanation.

1. I’m nearly 100% certain both teams go in the same direction in OT. So wind is not a factor.

2. You claim it is obvious that teams that go first will always try for the TD and will not take the FG. Have you ever watched an overtime game in your life under this format? In NCAA or CFL?

Example western semi final just over two weeks ago. Saskatchewan had the ball first and took the field goal when forced into third down. As has pretty much every team in the history of time that gets the ball first and is third and long.

3. 100% of all coaches who have won the toss have deferred and taken the ball second. This is not my opinion of what they should do. This is fact of what they have done. But yes Darts knows more then every college football and CFL coach in the last 10 years.

I could literally sit down with a 10 year old and explain why this strategy makes sense in less than 2 minutes.
 
Last edited:
"100% of all coaches who have won the toss have deferred and taken the ball second."
Link please.
 
"100% of all coaches who have won the toss have deferred and taken the ball second."
Link please.
What about his other two points? You don't need the link to answer those points.

Or are you going to turtle on those?
 
"100% of all coaches who have won the toss have deferred and taken the ball second."
Link please.
Let's make it easier. No research required.

How many CFL games have you watched that went into overtime and the team that won the toss decided to take the ball and go on offense first?
 
Please explain to me in a logical way how thr strategy backfired for Hamilton. They “lost” is not a logical explanation. Logical or not, it didn't work.

1. I’m nearly 100% certain both teams go in the same direction in OT. So wind is not a factor. Ok, if you say so.

2. You claim it is obvious that teams that go first will always try for the TD and will not take the FG. Have you ever watched an overtime game in your life under this format? In NCAA or CFL?

Example western semi final just over two weeks ago. Saskatchewan had the ball first and took the field goal when forced into third down. As has pretty much every team in the history of time that gets the ball first and is third and long.
I assume that their intent was to score a TD, but failed to do so in the first two downs so settled for a FG.

3. 100% of all coaches who have won the toss have deferred and taken the ball second. This is not my opinion of what they should do. I am not convinced that it is 100%. A link or confirmation from one or two credible member(s) would help.