Realtor & Housing Scams

poker

Everyone's hero's, tell everyone's lies.
Jun 1, 2006
7,699
6,016
113
Niagara
Curious what scams you guys have heard of...

My son was renting from a couple who decided to move back to Brampton. (It was in the boonies).

They offered him a shot at buying it first. He asked me to sit down their realtor as he had never had a major purchase before. He was single, and worked a sales job in a gym. He did not qualify for a mortgage, and I suspect he wanted me to jump in with him.

He house was about $400k. He did not have a downpayment, and my money is tied up. His income was also too low.

Without batting an eye last the realtor says we can add the the down payment to cost of house and the seller will provide it. Then she goes on to say if we provide them with $5000, they will have a friend provide my son with five $1000 chq's they can show as income from contract work.

Both of sceme's are illegal. And it was offered so flippantly, I have assume it's common practice in the industry.

Now... as the sale price of the house would have gone from $400k to $450k... does the next realtor selling in that neighborhood not use that price to justify the price he is about to recommend "based on the market"?

As I see it... the realtor industry are asking customers to take out massive loans that they take the first cut of, and do not give even the tiniest shit whether you lose the house down the road or not. They are happy breaking the law as they get paid massive commissions, and these scams help them inflate the market for bigger commission chq's all around.

Am I wrong?
 
So your one encounter with a bad apple, you extrapolate and lump the entire industry of realtors to be scammers too?

What you should do is to report the realtor to RECO and get him/her out of the industry.
 
So your one encounter with a bad apple, you extrapolate and lump the entire industry of realtors to be scammers too?

What you should do is to report the realtor to RECO and get him/her out of the industry.

Do I trust people... nope. Always thought most realtors and bankers were dirty. Always seen real estate as a very manipulated industry. This simply confirmed it.

I probably should have reported at the time... however, my word against hers. Nothing would have happened.

However... to be fair, I am asking if there are other scams people know of... you know, as in "there is another offer, but the rules prevent us from telling you what it is".
 
Curious what scams you guys have heard of...

My son was renting from a couple who decided to move back to Brampton. (It was in the boonies).

They offered him a shot at buying it first. He asked me to sit down their realtor as he had never had a major purchase before. He was single, and worked a sales job in a gym. He did not qualify for a mortgage, and I suspect he wanted me to jump in with him.

He house was about $400k. He did not have a downpayment, and my money is tied up. His income was also too low.

Without batting an eye last the realtor says we can add the the down payment to cost of house and the seller will provide it. Then she goes on to say if we provide them with $5000, they will have a friend provide my son with five $1000 chq's they can show as income from contract work.

Both of sceme's are illegal. And it was offered so flippantly, I have assume it's common practice in the industry.

Now... as the sale price of the house would have gone from $400k to $450k... does the next realtor selling in that neighborhood not use that price to justify the price he is about to recommend "based on the market"?

As I see it... the realtor industry are asking customers to take out massive loans that they take the first cut of, and do not give even the tiniest shit whether you lose the house down the road or not. They are happy breaking the law as they get paid massive commissions, and these scams help them inflate the market for bigger commission chq's all around.

Am I wrong?

I am sorry, but did you expect the sale person not to try to sell? Yes, he may have offered some grey schemes, but he did not try to cheat anyone of their money. If anyone needs to have a prove of income, just fill the tax return with any amount you want and pay the income tax. You can always hire yourself to do your own dishes. Or you could have hired your sun and give him 10 of $500 checks for making dinner(if you do not have to have $5000 on you - you could have give him $500, borrow $500 from him, and repeat 10 times). It is no crime to report more income then you have and pay taxes from it, it is a crime to report less and do not pay taxes.

Also, realtors do not care for how much they sell the house - they just want to sell it, and, if they represent sellers, they try to persuade their clients to sell for less so it will be a fast sale.
 
  • Like
Reactions: IloveMe2345
I am sorry, but did you expect the sale person not to try to sell? Yes, he may have offered some grey schemes, but he did not try to cheat anyone of their money. If anyone needs to have a prove of income, just fill the tax return with any amount you want and pay the income tax. You can always hire yourself to do your own dishes. Or you could have hired your sun and give him 10 of $500 checks for making dinner(if you do not have to have $5000 on you - you could have give him $500, borrow $500 from him, and repeat 10 times). It is no crime to report more income then you have and pay taxes from it, it is a crime to report less and do not pay taxes.

Also, realtors do not care for how much they sell the house - they just want to sell it, and, if they represent sellers, they try to persuade their clients to sell for less so it will be a fast sale.

Actually... realtors knowingly engaging to falsify income to get a mortgage approved is a crime. I am taking the course and will have my license in a few months.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SchlongConery
Actually... realtors knowingly engaging to falsify income to get a mortgage approved is a crime. I am taking the course and will have my license in a few months.

Well, it depends on what was offered. Let;s say "party A" pays "Party B:" $5,000 for a one-time grocery shopping and B pays A $5,000 for one-time car ride. Both parties report $5,000 as income and pay taxes on it. Where is the fraud here? In fact, you could have simply paid your sun $5,000 for helping you with choosing the best type of cheese and he may have give you $5,000 as a birthday gift. He would have had a legitimate taxable $5,000 income. In fact, you could have even signed a contract with him that every month he will give you a consultation on how to choose a specific type of apples in a supermarket and you will pay him $5,000 every month. It is a legitimate employment, and neither bank nor the government will have any issues with it. What he will do with his $5,000 a month (give it back to you because he loves you and spend on SPs) - up to him. Of course, he will have to pay taxes on it and you cannot deduct them (so, the money will be double-taxed) There is no falsification here. Maybe you can explain exactly what was the falsification in your case (e.g., backdated paychecks or forgery), but the way you describe it I cannot see any legal issues.
 
Well, it depends on what was offered. Let;s say "party A" pays "Party B:" $5,000 for a one-time grocery shopping and B pays A $5,000 for one-time car ride. Both parties report $5,000 as income and pay taxes on it. Where is the fraud here? In fact, you could have simply paid your sun $5,000 for helping you with choosing the best type of cheese and he may have give you $5,000 as a birthday gift. He would have had a legitimate taxable $5,000 income. In fact, you could have even signed a contract with him that every month he will give you a consultation on how to choose a specific type of apples in a supermarket and you will pay him $5,000 every month. It is a legitimate employment, and neither bank nor the government will have any issues with it. What he will do with his $5,000 a month (give it back to you because he loves you and spend on SPs) - up to him. Of course, he will have to pay taxes on it and you cannot deduct them (so, the money will be double-taxed) There is no falsification here. Maybe you can explain exactly what was the falsification in your case (e.g., backdated paychecks or forgery), but the way you describe it I cannot see any legal issues.

I don't play "let's say...." where you build a pretend construct for sole purpose of making you're arguement.

I play real life. And I'm asking if anyone know of "actual" real estate scams.
 
Maybe you can explain exactly what was the falsification in your case (e.g., backdated paychecks or forgery), but the way you describe it I cannot see any legal issues.

Did you not read what he wrote.

Then she goes on to say if we provide them with $5000, they will have a friend provide my son with five $1000 chq's they can show as income from contract work.

This is fraud. 😆
 
There is a lot of corruption and scamming going on in the real estate market. Its nothing new. But its probably worse than ever.

The number 1 scam is bribery. Good old fashioned bribery. You bribe the real estate agent to put your low ball offer through. Simple as that. Sellers need to know what houses are going for in their area and have an honest sense of what their house is worth.

Also, I used to date a woman who worked for the Law Society of Upper Canada in their Disciplinary group investigating fraudulent behaviour committed by lawyers. She told me that the number 1 fraud for the law society was by far real estate law. It boiled down to fraudulent mortgages. Properties being sold to front men at fraudulently high prices (and mortgaged for far more than the property was worth). The transaction was done, the mortgage entered into by the front man (along with the corrupt real estate agent) and then the front man would disappear. The bank was left with a property that was worth half of what they mortgaged it for.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jeff2
OMG no!.

The amount of blood, sweat, tears and moolah they expend to sell a $2million property in 2 days basically wipes out their $100,000 commission.
Agreed, when average houses were sold for $300,000 less than 20 years ago the listing agent commission was 1.75% or about $5,250
The broker got 0.75% or $2,250 and the same applied to the selling agent.
Total commission of $15,000 at 5%

Today that same average house if $1.4 million and the commission is now $70,000

Most people have actually seen a decrease in inflation adjusted income over the last 20 years. Agents are massively overcompensated for the work they do.
$24,500 to sell a single house is ridiculous.
 
For a fee of 1% of the mortgage, you can get income done on you quite easily through many agents with a connection at a bank.
 
Anything goes in Brampton.
Had to deal with it several times myself.
Lawyers and realtors there don’t care about Canadian laws.
 
For those of you not in the industry, you would not believe how much unscrupulous activity goes on in every stage of the real estate and mortgage process. What the OP described is small potatoes compared to other things. The amount of fake income and bank statements in the industry is huge.

 
  • Like
Reactions: poker
Don't be too hard on realtors. They have a lot of overhead to think about, namely their coke habit and monthly payments on their Range Rovers.

I agree that agents are overpaid. Granted it's a tiny number that are actually getting paid at all. There are 50k realtors in the GTA and most are broke. It's a saturated occupation with only a few rise to the top.
 
In theory, it's possible for the owner/seller to provide part of the downpayment. It's called a Vendor Take Back mortgage. But banks still require you to show that some of the downpayment comes from the buyer.
I'd be very wary of that scheme of trading $5000 to generate false proof of income. I don't know the effects of that, but it might backfire if the bank catches wind of it.
 
Don't be too hard on realtors. They have a lot of overhead to think about, namely their coke habit and monthly payments on their Range Rovers.

I agree that agents are overpaid. Granted it's a tiny number that are actually getting paid at all. There are 50k realtors in the GTA and most are broke. It's a saturated occupation with only a few rise to the top.
Most of the money in many shops comes from selling "newbies" on the prospect of good, part time income. They collect substantial fees for "support services" and like you said, the market is saturated and only a few ever recoup their "investment" Not really a scam, but certainly a racket...
 
For those of you not in the industry, you would not believe how much unscrupulous activity goes on in every stage of the real estate and mortgage process. What the OP described is small potatoes compared to other things. The amount of fake income and bank statements in the industry is huge.

I know someone on ODSP who was able to qualify for a mortgage!!!!!!! They make what? Less then $1500 a month. That doesn’t cover housing costs for owning a house.

Mortgage brokers will get you The financing. I don’t get how but pay enough and you will get a mortgage.

which I don’t get because then you are house rich and food poor. Makes no sense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: poker
Another scam is when you bid on a property and the agent comes back telling you that you’ve been out bid and you need to increase your offer. Meanwhile there is no other bidder and you’re bidding against yourself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: poker and roadhog