This team is a disaster, plain and simple.
Three minutes left in the 3rd and who's on the ice? Why it's 50yo castoff Jason Spezza! Are you kidding me!? That's who you put out there to close the gap and hopefully get an equalizer? While Matthews, Tavares, Marner, Kapanen, and Hyman are on the bench 'resting'? Resting my ass! Get the fuck out there and play the full last 3 mins if you have to. That's what you're paid for! Same with Reilly. Ride that fucker into the ground when the game and playoffs are on the line.
Talent-wise, this team is just not an NHL-caliber roster. Spezza, Gauthier, Marincin, Ceci, Barrie, Kerfoot, Engvall, Holl, Clifford and Muzzin all have to go. These are just not NHL-level players. End of life, career AHL or KHL, but not good enough to be a regular on any NHL franchise that says it wants to win a cup.
LIke it or not, trade Marner for a couple grit players (top six) who can support Tavares and Matthews, plus a couple role players with experience (bottom six). It'll hurt, but you gotta give up something to get something. He's really all you got as bait.
Time to end the Nylander experiment too. Totally afraid of the tough going, constantly going for a long skate in a wide circle after giving up the puck along the boards, missing a reaching stick check, or making a turnover with yet another bad/useless pass. Plays with zero passion and grit. Won't crash the net. Was a total non-factor in this series. Many times, the Leafs looked shorthanded with him on the ice, he was always so far out of the play. Yeah, he'll score goals in the regular season against mostly the bottom feeding teams, or when he can dipsy doodle around on the power play where there is no chance anyone will try to crunch him, but he won't win you many, if any, important games on his own like Tavares, Marner, or Matthews can/will/have. For his salary, the Leafs need to get more out of him, and he ain't got anything more to give. Even Marner manned up and blocked shot after shot at the point, even playing goalie on the empty net without wetting his pants. And he's built like a 13 year old girl! You'll NEVER EVER see slick Willie do that. EVER.
Keep: Matthews, Tavares, Reilly, Hyman, Kapanen, Mikheyev, Roberston, Johnsson, Dermott, Sandin, Rosen, Malgin, Liljegren and maybe Muzzin for one more season. They have propects like Agostino dying for a chance...why not give it to them.
They also need to bring in someone who can really challenge Andersen. Campbell ain't gonna do it. This team can't have its starter continue to give up soft goals at critical moments without consequences. He's a good goalie, but he hasn't stolen a series for them, or led them deep into the playoffs so far...nothing to suggest he will either. Someone else needs to be brought in to share the load like Jarry and Murray in PIT.
If this franchise is going anywhere, it better look dramatically different when the new 2020-21 season gets going. As bad as the Leafs are, CBJ are worse and they still stonewalled to a series win.
This season has been nothing short of an embarrassment. You already blamed and changed the coach, and the new GM still isn't getting it done. Maybe Dubas needs to take ride somewhere else too.