2020 HHOF Class

glamphotographer

Well-known member
Nov 5, 2011
19,645
20,230
113
Canada
Five players were named to this year’s class: Jarome Iginla, Marian Hossa, Kevin Lowe, Kim St-Pierre and Doug Wilson. They are joined by longtime NHL executive Ken Holland, in the builder category.
 
Iggy and Hossa are clear cut. Can't comment on KSP. Wilson was talented. Despite his Cups, I thought Lowe was a solid defender but very unspectacular. If he'd played for any team but a dynasty, I doubt he'd be going in to the HOF.
 
Iggy and Hossa are clear cut. Can't comment on KSP. Wilson was talented. Despite his Cups, I thought Lowe was a solid defender but very unspectacular. If he'd played for any team but a dynasty, I doubt he'd be going in to the HOF.
Lowe is the weakest of the class I think. Mogilny or Fleury would be better choices.
 
I have no issue with lowe he was a stay at home rear guard on the most offensive minded team in hockey for years. It's not like they had a lot of forwards coming back to help him out. He gave Paul Coffey licence to do his thing as well.

Fleury to me has to be in at some point in time as well. Couldn't have been easy being 5'6 in the NHL during those days and he took home a lot of hardware. It seemed to me every shift he took in the offensive zone he was making things happen.

Being a big Daniel Alfredsson of course I'm disappointed but his time will come. One of the best two way players in his generation and a success on the world stage.
 
Good player but would you rank him ahead of say Pierre Turgeon? Who hasn't got a sniff

2 Selke trophies,1484 games,452 goals,732 assists for 1184 points.So I say yes.Pierre has more points but played roughly 200 less games.So they both should be in.
 
2 Selke trophies,1484 games,452 goals,732 assists for 1184 points.So I say yes.Pierre has more points but played roughly 200 less games.So they both should be in.
I'm a big proponent of being in both ends and wasn't aware of Rod's 2 Selke wins. So yeah I see your point.
 
Fleury to me has to be in at some point in time as well. Couldn't have been easy being 5'6 in the NHL during those days and he took home a lot of hardware. It seemed to me every shift he took in the offensive zone he was making things happen.

I agree Fleury should be in the HOF, like you said, he was small guy and played his heart out.
He was a point a game player (1084 GP/1088 pts) with a Stanley Cup win, Lanny Mcdonald was not quite a point game player (1111 GP/ 1006 pts) with one Cup win and he is in the HOF.


During training camp in T.O. for the 1991 Canada Cup , I was eating pizza at the front window at a Pizza Pizza on yonge across from the Reference library when lo and behold Theoren Fleury walks by me. It was august, so he was wearing shorts. I couldn't believe how short he was, but what struck me the most was that his quads were the size of tree trunks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bazokajoe
During training camp in T.O. for the 1991 Canada Cup , I was eating pizza at the front window at a Pizza Pizza on yonge across from the Reference library when lo and behold Theoren Fleury walks by me. It was august, so he was wearing shorts. I couldn't believe how short he was, but what struck me the most was that his quads were the size of tree trunks.

knew a guy who played with Sidney Crosby and he said the same thing. Sid's legs are proportionally to big for the rest of him.
 
Carbonneau?......Darts we were talking about Brind'Amour
Yes, Guy Carbonneau. He is the perfect example why we shouldn't just measure the value of a player strictly on goals and assists. Ok, so Brind'Amour has more goals.
 
I would have voted in Fleury over Lowe or Wilson that's for sure. Fleury had a >1 ppg average in both his regular season and playoff career. Has a SC ring and was an all around player a regular on both PP and PK exhibiting tremendous grit and toughness.
 
knew a guy who played with Sidney Crosby and he said the same thing. Sid's legs are proportionally to big for the rest of him.
Sid also has a big bum. Hence, he is so good at protecting the puck. Low center of gravity.
 
As you can see, he inhabits some different universe where it is ok to discuss any Canadien regardless of the topic at hand.

Darts is making a legitimate point:
If most of us are choosing a defensive forward we'd probably take Rod Brind'Amour over Guy Carbonneau.
But Carbonneau is in the hall of fame and Brind'Amour isn't, despite better stats. Why? It goes to your point earlier; Carbonneau has a fistful of Stanley Cup rings, Brind'Amour doesn't.
Without Stanley Cup rings Kevin Lowe wouldn't even be looked at.

How did Kim St. Pierre gain the hall of fame as the first female goaltender while Manon Rheaume has been overlooked?
Rheaume was the first dominant female goalie in her generation, she's been the only female to ever see playing time in the NHL and has been a major innovator, designing female-specific skates.
Regardless of the circumstances, does being the only female to play in the NHL not deserve a HOF mention?
No - because Rheaume won world titles but only got a silver at the Olympics. St. Pierre has three Olympic gold. So St. Pierre is in, Rheaume isn't.

When Bazookajoe mentioned Brind'Amour being overlooked, Guy Carbonneau was the first person that I thought of as well.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Darts