Doug Ford was doing so well - until today

Dutch Oven

Well-known member
Feb 12, 2019
7,117
2,620
113
Ford held a press conference today which, contrary to what many were led to expect, failed to announce any business re-openings. Instead, all Ontarians got was a bland policy "framework" which made it clear that no businesses will be opened for at least 2-4 weeks. Against that backdrop, Quebec announced that it would be re-opening primary schools across the province.

Doctors are trained to be risk averse. They will always provide you with advice that reflects that. It's the reason that we have Medical Officers of Health, but they report to politicians, and not the other way around. Public policy can't simply be delegated to bureaucrats, no matter how scientific their advice or well educated they are, because political decisions need to take into account too many factors and usually need to be made in circumstances where information cannot be perfect or complete.

I think Ford is going to be hearing from a lot of business leaders who ordinarily support him, and taking a lot of flak for passing the buck on this file.
 
The government announced it will reopen the province's economy through a three-stage process in the coming weeks and months, though it offered no firm date and few details about when that effort will begin.

Health and safety "will continue to be a top priority as Ontario transitions to a 'new normal,'" a government document unveiled Monday afternoon said. A Framework for Reopening our Province emphasizes that public health officials will have input during each phase of the process.

According to the province, the stages are as follows:

  • Stage 1: Open select workplaces and allow some small gatherings.
  • Stage 2: Open more workplaces and outdoor spaces, and allow some larger gatherings.
  • Stage 3: Further relax restrictions on public gatherings and open all work places "responsibly."

Each stage will last at least two to four weeks, at which point Ontario chief medical officer of health will be able to tighten certain restrictions, extend the stage or advise that the province can move into the next phase.

While there are no specific dates included in the planning document, when and how Ontario begins reopening will depend on a number of factors, including:

  • A consistent two-to-four week drop in new daily COVID-19 cases.
  • A decrease in cases that can't be traced to a source.
  • A decrease in new hospitalizations.

Dr. David Williams, Ontario's chief medical officer health, said last week that the province would need to see fewer than 200 new cases daily for an extended stretch before relaxing COVID-19 emergency measures would be feasible.

With the province still falling somewhat short of its goal of processing 13,000 tests per day, whether the number of new cases being reported daily reflects the true number of new infections remains a question.

Coronavirus: What's happening in Canada and around the world Monday
 
Doctors are trained to be risk averse. They will always provide you will with advice that reflects that. It's the reason that we have Medical Officers of Health, but they report to politicians, and not the other way around. Public policy can't simply be delegated to bureaucrats, no matter how scientific their advice or well educated they are, because political decisions need to take into account too many factors and usually need to be made in circumstances where information cannot be perfect or incomplete..


I agree with you.

There has to be a balance. Where that balance is, is the big question.

I am beginning to feel that the long term effect on individuals and society as a whole may be worse than the pandemic itself.

Life is going to be different. We will all have to find our way as the world has changed forever. Maybe good, maybe. bad.
 
Ford is taking a very cautious though kind of optimistic approach to this whole Pandemic. In a way he is right, as we have to see the down slope confirmed in a real TRENDING data before any real decisions are firmly taken.

https://toronto.ctvnews.ca/ontario-...-what-the-new-normal-will-look-like-1.4913052

What's the point of modelling if you aren't going to rely on your models? Why would you both model AND wait for concrete confirmations of your projections? Anyone can be a Monday morning quarterback. Leaders can make decisions in the heat of battle.
 
I am beginning to feel that the long term effect on individuals and society as a whole may be worse than the pandemic itself.

Imagine how you'll feel in 2-4 weeks, which is the minimum time line for the opening of any businesses under this framework!

May 1 is a big day. It's the day that we'll see just how many Ontario businesses can no longer pay their commercial rent. The commercial rent relief program won't open up for applications until mid-May. What should businesses do? Pay? If they all pay, no landlord will apply to the program (because if they do, they have to sacrifice 25% of the rent just to help their tenants out)! Not pay? No protection from evictions in the commercial world at the moment. How will not paying affect their ability to negotiate lease renewals or re-negotiate with their landlords? I guarantee it won't help!

Business disaster is just around the corner in Ontario. Ford needed to show some guts at this specific moment.
 
What's the point of modelling if you aren't going to rely on your models? Why would you both model AND wait for concrete confirmations of your projections? Anyone can be a Monday morning quarterback. Leaders can make decisions in the heat of battle.

In this situation, erroring on the side of caution is a good approach.

Can you imagine rushing things back and then a 2nd flare up of cases? All we have done to date would have been for nothing. And then imagine the backlash on any politician who made that decision.
 
In this situation, erroring on the side of caution is a good approach.

Can you imagine rushing things back and then a 2nd flare up of cases? All we have done to date would have been for nothing. And then imagine the backlash on any politician who made that decision.

Erring on the side of caution is reasonable, as long as you are taking into account everything there is to be cautious about. The impact of Covid on the health of citizens (and, more accurately, the impact of ordinary life + Covid on the health of citizens vs. what would happen anyway) isn't the only threat to the public that's in play.

I'll predict right now that we'll run out of all this government money (which is really our own future earnings) before we ever get 100% assurance from public health experts that there is no risk in re-opening the economy.

It will take political courage to try to get the best result possible for people, but that's what I want from leaders.
 
1605 new cases and 147 new deaths today alone in Canada.
Too soon.
Much, much too soon.

We need those numbers to go down by an order of magnitude at least.
We need to drastically ramp up testing.
We need MASKS to be widely available for everyone. And hand sanitizer.

Then, we'll talk about re-opening things.
 
Ontario has 16,000 (0.12% of pop.) cases and 1,020 (0.007% of pop) deaths due to COVID19. I'll leave it at that.
 
Ontario has 16,000 (0.12% of pop.) cases and 1,020 (0.007% of pop) deaths due to COVID19. I'll leave it at that.

Where would the numbers be at if all the preventative measures were not taken when they were? ie social distancing, etc.

They are only as low as they are due to that effort. The health system has not been overloaded as a result, which means people who are seriously ill will not die due to lack of facilities, medical staff, etc.

A vaccine is a year away at best. The only coping strategy until then is what we are doing now.
 
1605 new cases and 147 new deaths today alone in Canada.
Too soon.
Much, much too soon.

We need those numbers to go down by an order of magnitude at least.
We need to drastically ramp up testing.
We need MASKS to be widely available for everyone. And hand sanitizer.

Then, we'll talk about re-opening things.

Ontario appears to have peaked.
https://www.blogto.com/city/2020/04/new-coronavirus-cases-continue-decrease-ontario/
Half of Canada's cases are now in Quebec and it looks like we may be at peak, though its hard to say for sure.
https://www.ctvnews.ca/health/coronavirus/tracking-every-case-of-covid-19-in-canada-1.4852102
 
Where would the numbers be at if all the preventative measures were not taken when they were? ie social distancing, etc.

They are only as low as they are due to that effort. The health system has not been overloaded as a result, which means people who are seriously ill will not die due to lack of facilities, medical staff, etc.

A vaccine is a year away at best. The only coping strategy until then is what we are doing now.

I don't think we'll ever know... The testing has been and will continue to be piss poor. The data is skewed and incomplete to make any truly accurate statements. How many people have been hiding out who were previously infected?
 
As I said, from the very beginning of the shutdown, the cure is worse than the disease. The virus has spread far and wide and it's nowhere as dangerous as predicted. Closing the economy and overstating the impact of the faulty and/or incomplete data forced our politicians into a corner from which they have no clue how to exit.
 
As I said, from the very beginning of the shutdown, the cure is worse than the disease. The virus has spread far and wide and it's nowhere as dangerous as predicted. Closing the economy and overstating the impact of the faulty and/or incomplete data forced our politicians into a corner from which they have no clue how to exit.

On the contrary, the hammer is nearly complete and has bee globally quite successful.
Soon the dance.
 
As I said, from the very beginning of the shutdown, the cure is worse than the disease. The virus has spread far and wide and it's nowhere as dangerous as predicted. Closing the economy and overstating the impact of the faulty and/or incomplete data forced our politicians into a corner from which they have no clue how to exit.

Heard that Conspiracy Theory on numerous occasions. Wonder why Trump fell for it and closed the Economy rather than taking the word of these Conspiracy Theorists as Gospel Truth!!
 
Heard that Conspiracy Theory on numerous occasions. Wonder why Trump fell for it and closed the Economy rather than taking the word of these Conspiracy Theorists as Gospel Truth!!

Because if he hadn't, you and your ilk would crucified him for it. So, he followed the advice of the "experts". Btw, not a conspiracy. Numbers don't lie.
 
Because if he hadn't, you and your ilk would crucified him for it. So, he followed the advice of the "experts". Btw, not a conspiracy. Numbers don't lie.

This is exactly what was predicted at the start, that if social distancing works than the science deniers would come out and claim that the virus wasn't dangerous after all and we didn't need to do it at all.
 
This virus is a crock of shit!

My business was open the whole time and every person and delivery guy I asked about knowing anyone affected by Covid and they all said NOBODY!!!!!

My neighbor who works in a hospital said there were 6 cases total.

A friend of mine had sever pain and called an ambulance to take him to the hospital and they refused unless he had covid symptoms.
He got a taxi to drive him and when he got to the hospital they were mad that he was there with no covid symptoms. He was later diagnosed with a kidney infection.

Going out of the hospital, he said there were signs saying NO PICS OR VIDEO!!!!

I took my gloves off today. Im done being fooled by our government! The rest of you can live in fear of nothing.