Bryan Trottier or Bobby Clarke

Bryan Trottier every time, perhaps the best two way centerman of his generation, very under-rated. He has six Stanley Cup rings. As for the Philadelphia cheeseboy, you already know how I feel about the the Broad Street Pussy Flaps.
 
Trottier.

Aside from his skills and leadership, he was surprisingly strong. He didn't look it, but was he ever tough to knock off the puck and easily separated the puck from opponents by outmuscling them. I always respected his honest, hard play as opposed to the dirty little weasel Clarke.

An example of Clarke's personality was when he was GM. He justified firing the ailing Roger Neilson bysaying something like: "Well, I didn't tell him to get cancer."

Trottier was all class all the time.
 
Trottier for sure. Trottier was a very solid 200lber, big boned type body. I remember him checking Bob Gainey into the end boards, tremendous "thud" , Gainey did not get up for several minutes.
 
Bryan Trottier has the same body type as Diego Maradona, they have a low center of gravity making them very difficult to knock of the puck/ball without flagrantly fouling them.

 
guess i,ll be the exception.... i,ll take clarke, anytime. chippy player, but he can play on my team anytime.
 
guess i,ll be the exception.... i,ll take clarke, anytime. chippy player, but he can play on my team anytime.

What about all the goons you'll need to protect him from his stickwork. Bryan Trottier could handle himself.

I have grudging respect for Dave Schultz, he avoided the cheap shots. His career was cut short by taking on Big Bird, Jethro (Clark Gillies) and The Greasy Jet (John Tonelli). Billy Smith won the Conn Smythe in 1983, Tonelli deserved it more.
 
I would take Trottier if Bossy comes with him, otherwise it's a toss-up in my eyes.
 
you already know how I feel about the the Broad Street Pussy Flaps.

The Flyers were resurgent this year. By the end of the season they were beating everyone in sight and playing very complete hockey; 9-1 in their final 10 games.

The real tragedy of this shortened season is that Insidious Von missed the opportunity to see them hoist the cup again.
It’s a pity. I was looking forward to that string of posts.
 
Trottier for sure. Trottier was a very solid 200lber, big boned type body. I remember him checking Bob Gainey into the end boards, tremendous "thud" , Gainey did not get up for several minutes.

I remember that hit. He got Gainey behind the net a ran at him leaving both feet. In today's game that's a misconduct all day long.
 
guess i,ll be the exception.... i,ll take clarke, anytime. chippy player, but he can play on my team anytime.

Forgotten on here is the fact that Clarke is a 3 time Hart trophy winner and one of the most formidable leaders in the history of the game.
 
An example of Clarke's personality was when he was GM. He justified firing the ailing Roger Neilson bysaying something like: "Well, I didn't tell him to get cancer."

The actually quote in question. ''"The Neilson situation - Roger got cancer - that wasn't out fault," Clarke said. "We didn't tell him to go get cancer. It's too bad that he did. We feel sorry for him, but then he went goofy on us."
 
As a life long Habs fan who really appreciated the fast skating and puck moving game of the mid to late 1970's glory years I disliked the style of game played by the majority of the Flyers - so although I recognize Bobby Clarke's grit, leadership skills and talent I would go with Bryan Trottier. He was a well rounded player - good offensively and defensively and was incredibly strong on his skates.
 
The actually quote in question. ''"The Neilson situation - Roger got cancer - that wasn't out fault," Clarke said. "We didn't tell him to go get cancer. It's too bad that he did. We feel sorry for him, but then he went goofy on us."

Beautiful. Fuckin' beautiful.
 
Trottier in a heartbeat.
Appreciated in his time, but historically one of the most underrated stars of the game.
You never hear his name mentioned, Number 1 centre and won 4 cups.
 
Lanny McDonald.