Refugees in Canada

There have been times in Canada's history, and I'm sure there will be such times again, when Canada needed a massive influx of population to keep pace with the job market (an influx that the birth rate could not satisfy).

I don't believe we are currently living in those times. We exist in a time of wage stagnation, reduction in our standard of living (as adjusted by inflation), and stagnant GDP. We live in a time of reduced full time employment and reduced labour participation rates. This indicates to me that there is reduced, not increased, job opportunity, particularly in middle class as well and lower class employment.

Add to this our spiralling debt, and the knowledge that this burden can only become more serious when our borrowing costs begin to creep up from what are currently historical lows, and you can see the risk we run by adding to ranks of the unemployed or underemployed.

Our immigration system can adjust to this reality. We could restrict entry to those with the capital to sustain themselves and to develop new enterprises in Canada. That would help to kick start GDP growth and address underemployment (as well as sagging tax revenues). However, refugee status is not based on any of these criteria. If refugees were truly the "helpless" trying to escape persecution/war then, logically, these people would not be the wealthy of their societies bringing their capital into Canada. If these refugees are the wealthy trying to taking their capital out of dysfunctional nations, then you have to wonder if they are really "refugees" at all, unless the right term for them are "economic refugees".

Canada has a great deal of untapped economic potential, and thus the ability to grow its population as well as its GDP. We are rich in natural resources. We have a world class education system. We have abundant energy resources (too much hydro, in fact). We have good infrastructure. Our chief disadvantages lie in higher production costs due to our climate, and higher transportation costs due to our geography. However, there are not many signs that we are on the verge of an economic breakthrough in some existing or new sector. Notable areas where we have been historically successful are currently in recession (oil and gas), or decline (tech sector (e.g. Blackberry), specific primary resource production sectors (e.g. pulp and paper)), or attack (softwood lumber, agricultural exports). If someone has found the next Canadian "gold rush" they are keeping it rather quiet. Until its obvious that the job market is under supplied, Canada should adopt an "investment" based immigration policy and should stop importing low or unskilled workers, whether via regular immigration or via refugee claims.
 
^Yea what this guy said

Assuming we let you in. As someone once said, we should only admit those "…that are immediately useful, and even then, only if they fill a void that locals cannot".

We've got lotsa clowns and clods of our own.

I'm not immigrating silly I'm a tourist and have contributed tens of thousands to your economy over the years screwing your women, and if your liberal government of cucks continues taxing and spending the shit out of you while inviting more dregs of the earth to leech off you, good for me lol
 
There have been times in Canada's history, and I'm sure there will be such times again, when Canada needed a massive influx of population to keep pace with the job market (an influx that the birth rate could not satisfy).

I don't believe we are currently living in those times. We exist in a time of wage stagnation, reduction in our standard of living (as adjusted by inflation), and stagnant GDP. We live in a time of reduced full time employment and reduced labour participation rates. This indicates to me that there is reduced, not increased, job opportunity, particularly in middle class as well and lower class employment.

Add to this our spiralling debt, and the knowledge that this burden can only become more serious when our borrowing costs begin to creep up from what are currently historical lows, and you can see the risk we run by adding to ranks of the unemployed or underemployed.

Our immigration system can adjust to this reality. We could restrict entry to those with the capital to sustain themselves and to develop new enterprises in Canada. That would help to kick start GDP growth and address underemployment (as well as sagging tax revenues). However, refugee status is not based on any of these criteria. If refugees were truly the "helpless" trying to escape persecution/war then, logically, these people would not be the wealthy of their societies bringing their capital into Canada. If these refugees are the wealthy trying to taking their capital out of dysfunctional nations, then you have to wonder if they are really "refugees" at all, unless the right term for them are "economic refugees".

Canada has a great deal of untapped economic potential, and thus the ability to grow its population as well as its GDP. We are rich in natural resources. We have a world class education system. We have abundant energy resources (too much hydro, in fact). We have good infrastructure. Our chief disadvantages lie in higher production costs due to our climate, and higher transportation costs due to our geography. However, there are not many signs that we are on the verge of an economic breakthrough in some existing or new sector. Notable areas where we have been historically successful are currently in recession (oil and gas), or decline (tech sector (e.g. Blackberry), specific primary resource production sectors (e.g. pulp and paper)), or attack (softwood lumber, agricultural exports). If someone has found the next Canadian "gold rush" they are keeping it rather quiet. Until its obvious that the job market is under supplied, Canada should adopt an "investment" based immigration policy and should stop importing low or unskilled workers, whether via regular immigration or via refugee claims.

Who cares, you are just a stupid rightwing racist. Don't try to confuse us with the reality of our situation . :).

But I disagree on the low skilled/labour workers. Canadians are not accepting those labour jobs and there is need for more workers. I prefer the blue collar immigrants who want to work over the snot nosed punks who have been told Canada needs them. If I hear another jagoff talk shit about my country I might just become the first Canadian terrorist.

What does a Canadian terrorist do? Just about the most horrible thing you can to another person. I will tell them they are just not being very nice.
 
There have been times in Canada's history, and I'm sure there will be such times again, when Canada needed a massive influx of population to keep pace with the job market (an influx that the birth rate could not satisfy).

I don't believe we are currently living in those times.

You believe a lot of nonsense. We face a declining population. Of course we need an influx of labor. Is been the subject of much public debate.

Most of your arguments are sophistry. You look for whatever idiotic, far fetched argument to defend the indefensible. You presumably think that's what lawyers are supposed to do, but you do it badly.

In this case you simply shoved your foot in your mouth.
 
i am in the USA and like i said to fuji earlier it's fine with me that your country goes to shit so your young girls will be driven to prostitution and i can fuck them

Your young girls are prostituting themselves as well. We have nothing as legal as the prostitutes in Vegas etc. Loved having sex there.
Trump is going to screw your country over, the rich will get richer while Trump creates a few stupid coal mining jobs that are toxic for humans. Well your ignorant voters welcomed this stupidity. Keep on being an isolationist nation. One day when your economy is in the dumps, people may start using whats in their heads again.
 
Buddy, are you serious with this post? We have a country that is swimming in debt on the Federal, Provincial and Civic levels, consumer debt is at historically high levels, and your answer is to bring in more mouths to feed? How about if we used the money we spend on social assistance for refugees and use that to help the people who are suffering in our own country. Charity begins at home.

And those mouths tend to quickly be contributing to the tax base and return the advantages they got.

And in addition to economics, allowing a person who's life is at risk in their home country a chance to survive here is moral as long as it doesn't have a major negative impact on us and the fact is it doesn't. Do you really think that the 5% of social assistance refugees receive would actually help get the other 95% of Canadian born recipients off welfare?
 
Sure there is a decline over the years, but you think it makes sense to bring people in who will spend 3 - 5 years on social assistance???? ....

Comparing a person born in Canada who stays on welfare vs a refugee who's life is saved and 3-5 years later will be a contributing member of society makes my moral choice simple.
 
... There is a massive welfare state. ...

If this is your concern then why aren't you complaining about the Canadians who make up 95% of welfare recipients?

And I'm sure you're the type that complains about universal health care too.
 
i am in the USA ...

Damn foreigners coming here and thinking they can freeload of Canadian bandwidth and enjoy or escort scene.

Instead of bitching about our system and worrying about our ability to afford escorts, how about you start bitching about the way that your country forces you away to get sex?
 
Comparing a person born in Canada who stays on welfare vs a refugee who's life is saved and 3-5 years later will be a contributing member of society makes my moral choice simple.

How many have you taken in over the years? How much of your own money have you invested in helping refugees?

I applaud your moral choice as long as you spend your own time and money. I do a great deal of charity with my own money and I have a long list of friends and relatives who have fallen on hard times but dont qualify or are too proud to ask for welfare.
People who have fallen on hard times after having worked and paid taxes for decades only to find out they dont qualify for assistance while hundreds of millions are being doled out to new immigrants.
 
Last edited:
Comparing a person born in Canada who stays on welfare vs a refugee who's life is saved and 3-5 years later will be a contributing member of society makes my moral choice simple.
What about Canadians who do not want their taxes spent on refugees, did they have a choice? Forced redistribution of wealth is fundamentally immoral.
If this is your concern then why aren't you complaining about the Canadians who make up 95% of welfare recipients?

And I'm sure you're the type that complains about universal health care too.
Youre right I'm against all welfare. Even to Americans and against foreign aid as well. I think taxes should be lowered to the bare minimum for public infrastructure, law enforcement and a protective non-interventionist military and anyone who can't survive on their own be left for dead.
 
Damn foreigners coming here and thinking they can freeload of Canadian bandwidth and enjoy or escort scene.

Instead of bitching about our system and worrying about our ability to afford escorts, how about you start bitching about the way that your country forces you away to get sex?
yea i AM fucking pissed that attractive white hookers here charge 500-800 USD/hr. guess our economy is too good smh
 
^Yea what this guy said



I'm not immigrating silly I'm a tourist and have contributed tens of thousands to your economy over the years screwing your women, and if your liberal government of cucks continues taxing and spending the shit out of you while inviting more dregs of the earth to leech off you, good for me lol
As a tourist you only get in if we let you. Which depends on how good a prospect you are for fleecing in the same way locals have been fleecing tourists since Marco Polo. As long as you leave your money behind and remove yourself when you've run out, that makes you a fit for the quote about "…usefulness". Enjoy.

But remember, every time you want us to let you in, you have to ask.
 
Hey metal-aug, if Canadian Border Service gives you a hassle, just tell them you are Muslim and protected by M-103. They'll wave you through.