Study: Campuses With Privileged, Wealthy Students More Likely to Censor

canada-man

Well-known member
Jun 16, 2007
33,856
3,779
113
Toronto, Ontario
canadianmale.wordpress.com
It has long been suspected that the students who rail against “privilege” and “oppression” are themselves typically the pampered sons and daughters of wealthy elites. Now, a study from the Brookings Institution appears to prove it.
Controversies over the censorship and disinvitation of conservative speakers has reached epidemic proportions on American campuses. Earlier this month, a violent mob of leftists at Middlebury College derailed a talk by American Interprise Institute scholar Charles Murray, co-author of The Bell Curve. Professor Allison Stanger, who was injured and sent to hospital by the rioters, called the incident the “saddest day of her life.”

Earlier this year, rioters at the University of California, Berkeley, set buildings on fire, attacked passers-by, and smashed storefronts in order to disrupt the appearance of Milo Yiannopoulos on campus.

In the wake of the Middlebury riot, the Brookings Institution conducted a study on the type of colleges where the suppression of conservative speakers was most likely to occur. They found a clear correlation between censorship and wealthier colleges — in other words, its the rich kids who throw tantrums and clamp down on free speech.

http://www.breitbart.com/tech/2017/03/15/rich-wealthy-campuses-hostile-free-speech/



the study

https://www.brookings.edu/opinions/illiberal-arts-colleges-pay-more-get-less-free-speech/
 
Sad but true.
 
First of all to call that "article" a "study" is a farce. Crunching some numbers is not a study. Doing research written in a set format and submitting it to a journal where it is peer reviewed.... that would be a legit study.



Secondly, the article talks about disinviting often conservative speakers as their measure of censorship it is not the same as flat out censorship. At the very least we should say that the right is being censored. But to me this is a no brainer if I am some sort of right wing guy looking to spread my message I would go where I am most likely to be heard. I would be smart enough to know that universities in general are not my best places to find supporters.

So when you word the finding more correctly it is to say that wealthy schools tend to have more liberal views..... in other news water is wet.
 
One could also argue that at less wealthy universities students are too busy working part time jobs to put themselves through school to take time to be politically active and have guest speakers banned.
 
One could also argue that at less wealthy universities students are too busy working part time jobs to put themselves through school to take time to be politically active and have guest speakers banned.


it's a rich kid's world
 
Daddies little precious can't have her/his world view challenged.....
 
Daddies little precious can't have her/his world view challenged.....

You may be right. It might be a case of spoil brats acting out.

But it could be a number of other things.

First we have to assume that the "study" is correct. Personally I am highly suspect of the meaningfulness of this "study" for example is this behavior unique to universities? Also, is an organization (university) that you must apply to and pay a large amount of money (tuition) which is also funded by many corporate sponsors really the best place to try and measure free speech? Has anyone taken a look at the code of conduct for students lately?

Even social media has its limits as to what you can say and what will get you banned.

It would be interesting to know how many people get disinvited from convention centers.

Moving on though if we accept the findings as true.....

I think being anti right wing to the point of barring them from speaking at your school could be a number of things
1) you are rich and therefore have time to worry about this..... as opposed to say BLM where I'm sure a wider demographic of blacks support this movement.
2) you are rebelling against your rich parents.... therefore you see it more at rich schools

But honestly..... what place does a guy like Milo have. If I went to a university that he was speaking at I would be upset that my tuition is paying for a hateful guest speaker like him.
 
You may be right. It might be a case of spoil brats acting out.

But it could be a number of other things.

First we have to assume that the "study" is correct. Personally I am highly suspect of the meaningfulness of this "study" for example is this behavior unique to universities? Also, is an organization (university) that you must apply to and pay a large amount of money (tuition) which is also funded by many corporate sponsors really the best place to try and measure free speech? Has anyone taken a look at the code of conduct for students lately?

Even social media has its limits as to what you can say and what will get you banned.

It would be interesting to know how many people get disinvited from convention centers.

Moving on though if we accept the findings as true.....

I think being anti right wing to the point of barring them from speaking at your school could be a number of things
1) you are rich and therefore have time to worry about this..... as opposed to say BLM where I'm sure a wider demographic of blacks support this movement.
2) you are rebelling against your rich parents.... therefore you see it more at rich schools

But honestly..... what place does a guy like Milo have. If I went to a university that he was speaking at I would be upset that my tuition is paying for a hateful guest speaker like him.

Murray/Middlebarry is the better example.

It's entitled condescending "adults" who can't yet feed themselves....
 
I agree, I have never heard of leftists shutting down conservative speakers with violence. They sit quietly and listen without any disruptive behavior.

think you are missing the point.

the data used and conclusion is highly suspect for reasons i pointed out earlier

Furthermore, by looking only at disinvited guest speakers also skews data as they should also consider speakers who were flat out declined in the first place.
 
Oh boo hoo, a bunch of bigots recieve negative attention instead of having their uninformed hate speech delivered with quiet respect. I'll be crying myself asleep at this news.
 
Oh boo hoo, a bunch of bigots recieve negative attention instead of having their uninformed hate speech delivered with quiet respect. I'll be crying myself asleep at this news.

give an example of bigotry they spread?
 
Murray wrote that black people are inherently less intelligent than white people. Do you agree?

pot meets kettle

https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?386465-Shooting-at-Eaton-Centre


https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?p=4065993#post4065993

Actually I don't agree. Even those members of the black community who are not engaging in crime appear to support the criminal ethos. In other words, they glamorize the thug lifestyle and that contributes to crime. Therefore the majority really ought to be penalized, until they shape up.
 
I don't believe black people are inherently criminal or inherently unintelligent, the way Murray does. I certainly think that too many grow up in a pro violent gang culture that perpetuates itself. We as a society can fix that, and we should.

You asked for what bigotry Murray spreads. He says blacks are inherently inferior to whites.

As Anon said, checkmate.