Question about NHL's Top 100 Players.

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
53,838
11,780
113
Toronto
I found it pretty interesting when they presented the 33 from the 1st 50 years on Sunday. At first I thought they were presented by rank but realized it was alphabetical.

What I don't understand is why did a group including Dave Keon and Frank Mahovlich not include Bobby Hull. I believe he started in the league the same year as Frank and started before Keon. Does not make sense to me. Is it because he defected to the WHA?

For that matter, Stan Mikita should have been in as well.
 
As good as Dave Keon was, I think he is overrated in these "greatest ever" polls.


He was never a 1st team all-star. Never won the Hart or the Art Ross. Other centres of his era like Jean Beliveau and Stan Mikita were far better.
 
I saw some of this and didn't realize it was alphabetical. I think that Hull was snubbed because of his leaving the NHL, as the first star player to do so at the time, unlike Howe, who made a comeback there. I thought that they relied to heavily on players from way back, players that time has forgotten, except for the most rabid and die hard, who know hockey's history. IMHO they should have stuck with the original six, 1942 to the present, rather than Joe Schmo from the Pickle Lake Raiders, who scored a GWG in an unknown era.
 
I saw some of this and didn't realize it was alphabetical. I think that Hull was snubbed because of his leaving the NHL, as the first star player to do so at the time, unlike Howe, who made a comeback there. I thought that they relied to heavily on players from way back, players that time has forgotten, except for the most rabid and die hard, who know hockey's history. IMHO they should have stuck with the original six, 1942 to the present, rather than Joe Schmo from the Pickle Lake Raiders, who scored a GWG in an unknown era.
Gotta strongly disagree.

I think they would have been remiss to ignore the accomplishments of the pioneers of the league. Personally, none of them were Joe Schmo to me. I'd read of many of their accomplishments when I was young and knew every single name. If anything, their accomplishments should be praised even more often so that others don't cast them aside so irreverently as you seem to have. Look at the way baseball does not let us forget those players from waaay back when. They praise them. They honour them. They do not let baseball forget.

Maybe these "Joe Schmos" should be removed from the Hall of Fame as well. Why clutter up the place with guys who you never heard of?

Sorry dirk, you are very wrong.
 
Maybe you misunderstood me shack. While those of our generation of Canadians may know of these guys, a league that wants to have growth needs to be more current with their fan base. They might have done two lists, one of pioneers, the league before the Original Six era began in '42 and then be more current with the Original Six and on. While history is a big part of the game and is important when talking about the game, it can be boring and a turn off for the casual fan who would scratch their head and see it as irrelevant at best, to be talking about teams that are no more, while looking at grainy photos of guys that most people have never heard of. The Original Six having started in '42 is a better starting point, as most can reference the '40's and the teams are still around, so very well known, even to the casual fan. Maybe that's what they were trying to do though, in celebrating a centennial, going for a more aged look. To me it just didn't do it.

I am also not saying they are to be ignored. Your reference to baseball is apropos, but let's not forget, baseball is the great American pastime, it is ingrained in their culture and has been since early on, with even the casual fan and non fan getting bombarded with the history of the game, whether they knew it or not. From the radio days in skits to movies and television, people were fed a healthy dose of Americana and baseball. So while your analogy is correct, it is a flawed connection. If you didn't receive the CBC near the border, most American's only saw a game if they went to it and so anything we saw on the CBC regarding hockey, was not as much as what the American's were fed with regards to baseball, so the names and teams are fully ingrained in the American psyche, as well as most Canadians too. Who hasn't heard of the Brooklyn Dodgers, Ty Cobb et al? It's a tough sell to sell the old, when there is only a fraction of even the most rabid fan who know anything about it. I realize that the CBC has tried to feed this to us for years and kudos to them, but from a business standpoint, in selling what you have, stick to a more current roster of the "greatest", while still saluting the past would have been a better option. A split on the history would have worked better from a television standpoint and from the NHL's offices, have a package to be broadcast during each game that feeds this to the fan a little at a time. Those old time names will never reach the status of household names like Ruth is to baseball, so why not try with names that might become more well known, as their names are better known to most.


Was this an NHL initiative or CBC's own doing?
 
Maybe you misunderstood me shack. While those of our generation of Canadians may know of these guys, a league that wants to have growth needs to be more current with their fan base. They might have done two lists, one of pioneers, the league before the Original Six era began in '42 and then be more current with the Original Six and on. ?
It is a commemoration of the 1st 100 years, and as you suggest, they broke it down into 2 lists, the first 50 years (which they just did) and next will be the second 50 years (seems like the most obvious way to split it, 50:50). And again, just as you suggest, they only chose 33 players from the 1st 50 and will be naming 67 from the 2nd 50, which is twice as much emphasis on the current era. Not sure how much more you want.

I am also not saying they are to be ignored. Your reference to baseball is apropos, but let's not forget, baseball is the great American pastime, it is ingrained in their culture?
I don't think there need to be any qualifiers. Baseball to American culture = hockey to Canadian culture. Stop. End of story. Who can deny that there is anything more Canadian than hockey. Everyone says we are a hockey nation, it is our game. Maybe we don't use the phrase "Canadian pastime", but that is what it is. Again, they say if you want to know what Canada is, it is hockey on a Saturday night. So yes, I believe it is 100% analogous.


Was this an NHL initiative or CBC's own doing?
NHL

Even though the league is interested in growing the game, the centennial is a time to remember the past. Growing the game is an evolving process and will continue on an ongoing basis, year by year. We only have one past, one centennial to commemorate and this was/is a perfect time to do it, ahead of thinking of the future.

Anyways, come the All-Star game it will be all modern era players.
 
If Bobby Hull snubbed the NHL when he went to the WHA, so did Keon.
Agree. And Hull was a much bigger star. If that is their line of thinking, it is very petty, especially after almost 50 years. Talk about holding a grudge.

Maybe they are thinking Keon gets a pass since he had to deal with Ballard. Nobody could blame him. LOL
 
Perhaps it is just me but it would have been proper to split the list based on pre and post expansion year 1967.
 
shack, thanks for taking the time to answer me. Was this the same list that Ron was presenting before the outdoor game? From the bit I saw, I didn't feel it was very well done, from a presentation point of view. A better perspective, to better educate your audience, from casual to the die hard, would have been those who played pre Original Six, Original Six to the expansion years, which is where they split the list anyways, through to today. It would have been a better history lesson, while highlighting your product and how it has grown over the years. I await the all-star game to see the rest of the list.

The problem with history is that it can be quite boring, unless presented properly. Hence the reason most people ignore history.

Hull may yet make the list, as it only takes in the first half century; https://www.nhl.com/fans/nhl-centennial/100-greatest-nhl-players?

I agree with you shack, that there are many greats on this list for the first half century, household names for sure.
 
shack, thanks for taking the time to answer me. Was this the same list that Ron was presenting before the outdoor game? From the bit I saw, I didn't feel it was very well done, from a presentation point of view. A better perspective, to better educate your audience, from casual to the die hard, would have been those who played pre Original Six, Original Six to the expansion years, which is where they split the list anyways, through to today. It would have been a better history lesson, while highlighting your product and how it has grown over the years. I await the all-star game to see the rest of the list.

The problem with history is that it can be quite boring, unless presented properly. Hence the reason most people ignore history.

Hull may yet make the list, as it only takes in the first half century; https://www.nhl.com/fans/nhl-centennial/100-greatest-nhl-players?

I agree with you shack, that there are many greats on this list for the first half century, household names for sure.
I guess some of this boils down to personal preference.

I was thinking that Hull could still make it, but with Howe, Mahovlich (he beat Hull for the Calder in their rookie years) and Keon in there I couldn't get a sense, since their careers overlapped so much with Hull's.
 
I guess some of this boils down to personal preference.

I was thinking that Hull could still make it, but with Howe, Mahovlich (he beat Hull for the Calder in their rookie years) and Keon in there I couldn't get a sense, since their careers overlapped so much with Hull's.

Absolutely it does.

Hull's NHL career ended in '71-'72, so he'll probably make the list. With over 1000 NHL games under his belt, over 600 goals and more than 1000 points, he's certain to make it. If he doesn't, then it shows a sad state of affairs.