What is cap and trade?

It's fucked up that we need incentives to consume and pollute less but we do. This is because investors and corporations have no reason to think long term and have zero interest in a healthy planet so a tax or regulations are necessary.
 
Question to those upset at liberals, did you vote conservative when Stephen Harper is the one who put Bill C36 in place? I couldn't vote for him because that negatively affected my job. I don't like these tax hikes either, but I was hoping for some kind of shift in regards to decriminalizing this industry again for all of us.

I agree with the point on decriminalizing the industry, however, for me, how much money I keep in my pocket is waaaayyyy more important than paying for sex. I hate the liberals for what they have done to this economy and the people of Ontario.
 
I will admit I voted Liberal. At the time, the PC Government, IMHO, had screwed things up with C36, C51 and few others while they had the federal Majority. I didn't like what they were doing at the time. 2 years ago, all you saw around here was the same lines but with PC in the sentence instead of Liberal.

What did that have to do with provincial politics ?
Be proud of the bankrupt mess Justin is making for all of us.
Be Proud Liberals & prepare to Pay through every pore of your body.
 
Last edited:
I have no faith in any of the 3 leading parties in Ontario.. I'm voting Green until the 3 of them get their shit together..
 
It's fucked up that we need incentives to consume and pollute less but we do. This is because investors and corporations have no reason to think long term and have zero interest in a healthy planet so a tax or regulations are necessary.

This new tax will do nothing measurable to reduce the level of green house gasses in the atmosphere. If taxes and manufacturing becomes too expensive in Ontario, the plants will simply move to some other part of the world.

If the government put a tax on fossil fuels, and directed 100% of the revenue to rebates on LED lighting and insulation materials for example, than it would have some justification. As it is now, this is just another new tax justified in a new way with a new name.
 
Is there no carbon tax on gasoline for those living in Thunder Bay, Kapuskasing, or Iroquois Falls?

I don't know. My comment was just that there are some ways to avoid the new tax, but the idea is useless to most people. I should have included a crying emoji with that comment. This new tax especially screws over people outside the city, who often vote conservative.
 
I don't know. My comment was just that there are some ways to avoid the new tax, but the idea is useless to most people. I should have included a crying emoji with that comment. This new tax especially screws over people outside the city, who often vote conservative.
Indeed what I was driving at.
 
What did that have to do with provincial politics ?
You can also be proud of the bankrupt mess Justin is making for all of us.
Be Proud Liberals & prepare to Pay through every pore of your body.

I am sorry you don't agree with my voting choice, however you can take your negativity and passive aggressiveness else where.

You asked if people would admit it, and 2 of us have now. I was polite in my reply to you. Explained some of my feelings on why and because you don't like it, you want to lecture me?? Did you think to ask if I still feel the same?? If I regret my voting choice, or if I still agree with what I did??

Next time just give the open ended lecture to all since as you said, they won the Majority again. At least then you can direct your negativity towards everyone who voted and not just single out the person who answered you with an answer you asked for but didn't and wouldn't have liked.
 
The part I don't get, is much of our pollution comes from the US. http://www.airqualityontario.com/science/transboundary.php ... it is estimated that more than 50 per cent of Ontario's ground-level ozone and fine particulate matter come from the U.S

Shouldn't we be 'taxing' the goods providers in China and countries like that, as they probably have low environmental standards. We should also take into account the environmental impact of shipping.

If Trump wants to bring jobs back to America, perhaps that is the way to do it.
 
Question to those upset at liberals, did you vote conservative when Stephen Harper is the one who put Bill C36 in place?

Obviously
The off chance I get caught in some random scare C36 sting is far less than I get all the funds removed from my bank to help out low class people who have no interest in working
Anyone who votes Liberal is a fucking idiot

I may disagree with someone voting NDP but at least the NDP stands for something
 
I am sorry you don't agree with my voting choice, however you can take your negativity and passive aggressiveness else where.

You asked if people would admit it, and 2 of us have now. I was polite in my reply to you. Explained some of my feelings on why and because you don't like it, you want to lecture me?? Did you think to ask if I still feel the same?? If I regret my voting choice, or if I still agree with what I did??

Next time just give the open ended lecture to all since as you said, they won the Majority again. At least then you can direct your negativity towards everyone who voted and not just single out the person who answered you with an answer you asked for but didn't and wouldn't have liked.

Very Sorry that you are so sensitive & that you perceive reality with being negative or a pessimist.
When I said 'you' I meant all those who voted Liberal.
Having reread it I can see your point & will edit that post.
 
For gasoline, you are paying a carbon tax and it is used as an incentive to pollute less, by using other alternative (cleaner) energies or public transit.

For natural gas, the gas companies like Enbridge are hit with cap and trade, they in turn pass on the cost to the consumer (us) and it again, is to push us to use cleaner energies to heat our homes.

There is no reward for polluting less.

Doesn't Enbridge have to buy the carbon capacity from somewhere else? Ie some other company or industry is lowering expenses somewhere, we just can't put a finger on where.

Or perhaps i don't get it.
 
Very Sorry that you are so sensitive & that you perceive reality with being negative or a pessimist.
When I said 'you' I meant all those who voted Liberal.
Having reread it I can see your point & will edit that post.

Sorry. You quoted me, I assume that meant you were addressing me. Thank you for clarifying and addressing that.

Also, please don't antiquate not accepting negativity with being overly sensitive. I am pretty thick chick and that includes skin. :wink:
 
Interesting article from Wikipedia so take it with a grain of salt: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emissions_trading

IMO, if it takes a lengthy article like this to explain cap and trade, then it likely won't work as it should especially when you couple it with government inefficiency. I would agree with dirk that a lot of consumer efforts like changing to energy efficient cars, lights, appliances, etc. basically amount to nothing.
 
I read up on it but still don't get it, anyone?

Remember how in the 70s and 80s there was fear of acid rain? Ever wonder why you don't hear about it anymore?

It was caused by SO2 emissions, but since that time the emissions have been cut by over 70%.

This was achieved through a cap and trade system. Basically the total level of allowed emissions was limited to a specific target and potential polluters bid on the rights to emit SO2.

This caused polluters to invest in emissions reduction technology and to change to less polluting processes. Those who really had to emit SO2 were able to do it by buying emissions credits from those who found ways to avoid it. They were able to do it in the end for only a fraction of the cost originally forecast.

This successful elimination of acid rain proved that cap and trade works, so now people want to apply the same concept to greenhouse gas emissions.
 
Cap and trade was first brought into Europe several years ago and it's been an abysmal failure.