or the team he built is winning now that he is gone, while the team that was successful before he got here is sinking!
I disagree with your statement as building a team requires years of planning and execution. Last year Cleveland showed positive signs that they were contenders as they had an excellent pitching staff. All they needed was more consistent hitting.
Even last year when the Jays were having an exceptional second half, the Indians played them tough and it was low scoring games - Cleveland took the first game against Price, the Jays won the second game in extra innings and then they took the third game with a solid performance by Dicky. Gm 1 4-2; Gm2 5-3; Gm 3 5-1.
I remember thinking that this would be a tough series and it was. Cleveland had a strong nucleus and required just a few parts to fill in the gaps.
To me, this was the result of what the management team had put in place over several years.
On the other hand, Toronto mortgaged their immediate future on winning it all now, with a good possibility of contending next (this) year. If they did not win it all in 2015 or 2016, then in hindsight it would be considered a roll of the dice and I believe at the time of the trades in late July/early August, it was referred to just that as Beeston was in his last year and they wanted to send him off as a winner.
Double AA made some extremely risky moves in 2015. Prior to that he was a mediocre GM and the team was playing at a mediocre level.
To his credit he made some steals in acquiring Tulo for an aging and depleted Reyes, completely robbed Oakland in the Donaldson trade, but the Dicky trade was not that great.
Shapiro, as with any President, has a game plan that is focused on building a team as well as focusing on the business needs of ownership. In hindsight their trade of Revere for Storen backfired big time, but at the time it made sense as we had a suspect bullpen and felt that filling that void was more important and moving Pillar into the lead-off role was a practical idea. He (and the GM) did however acquire Grilli and Benoit, whom have been welcome additions to the bullpen. Their decision to sign Happ was excellent and well thought out.
So to me, the current leadership has proven they can build a winning organization, especially under the financial constraints in Cleveland. With more money, I am hoping they can duplicate that vision here in Toronto. I do like that they have been bringing in proven baseball talent in the management and administration of the organization.