Scientific issue that has always bugged kme

There reason why the hole will get bigger is that in a hot object the molecules will be further apart. That's what causes the expansion.

Of course a donut is also expanding as it fries yet the hole gets smaller .....
 
I think that rail car axles are cooled with liquid nitrogen, contracting the steel and then inserted into the hole in the centre of the steel wheel.
 
And in a slight twist...

Say you had a block of steel.... 3' cube of strong steel...super strong....And in the centre of that steel you had an egg sized pocket of water...no bubbles.


Then you froze that steel at way below sub zero...way way down in temp.


Does the water freeze/expand? And in so doing, does the steel crack?

Or????

Would guess as the temperature drops you would get an ice ball rattling around in the steel cube.
 
So I guess,...the molecules will be further apart in only one direction,...who knew.

FAST

The molecules want to get farther appart and increase the volume in between other molecules. If the hole decreased the space between the molecules would decrease and it would be contrary to what happens when you heat up a substance. Thus the expansion follows path of least resistance.
 
And in a slight twist...

Say you had a block of steel.... 3' cube of strong steel...super strong....And in the centre of that steel you had an egg sized pocket of water...no bubbles.


Then you froze that steel at way below sub zero...way way down in temp.


Does the water freeze/expand? And in so doing, does the steel crack?

Or????

To do this you would need a specialized system. In laboratories they use a diamond anvil cell capable of creating massive amounts of pressure to transform ice into different kind of ice by applying pressure to counteract the pressure water exerts when transforming to ice. This diamond anvil can create pressures up to 210,000 MPa. Typically steel has an ultimate tensile strength of 400-550 MPa. Liquid metal alloy can go up to 1600 MPa. You also need to be mindful of temperatures becuase the lower you go the more brittle the metal can become. Ice will turn into ice II when pressure reaches 300 MPa. Human skin has ultimate at 20 MPa.

Therefore the amount of pressure a container would need to be able to survive to stop water turning into ice is 300 MPa, instead causing it to turn to Ice II. Apparently the different types of Ice go up to Ice XV. However be careful not to go too cold as you could make your metal brittle and cause it to fail under pressure. Therefore it is possible with your scenario since you have not defined the metal and the temperature :p http://www.todayifoundout.com/index...er-container-strong-water-couldnt-expand-ice/ However if you cool it down far enough, it could become brittle and fail.

Another site to give you an idea of how you could test and contain the force of water as it expands and turns to differentforms of ice...https://stab-iitb.org/newton-mirror/askasci/eng99/eng99532.htm

Hope this helps, let us know how your experiment goes and good luck. ;)
 
OK, suppose you have a one foot by one foot by one foot cube of solid steel, with a one inch hole drilled all the way through it.
Now, steel should expand when it is heated right?
So if you take that block of steel from 0 centigrade, to, say, 300 centigrade - will the hole in the middle get larger or smaller? On the one hand, shouldn't the steel expand equally in ALL directions, including in towards the hole, so that the hole will actually get smaller? Or will the whole damn block of steel just get bigger so that hole as well gets bigger?

If the block of metal can be heated evenly, the hole will get bigger.

Think of the block as a tube. Think of the tube as divided into thin rings. The innermost ring surrounds the hole, then the next ring surrounds the innermost ring, and so on to the outermost ring.
When the metal is heated, every one of those rings expands. Every ring increases its hoop length, and increases its diameter.
I hope that, visualized in that way, you cannot imagine the hole getting smaller.

However, the assumption, in that, is that the block of metal is heated evenly. But it is practically impossible to heat a block of the dimensions you say in any way that could remotely be described as "evenly".
Suppose you put the heater inside the central hole. Now, the wall of the hole gets hot, while the bulk of the block, away from the hole, is still cold.
Depending on the heat-conductivity of the metal, and its thermal-expansion, the non-expanding cold bulk of the surrounding metal will resist the expansion of the inner rings, i.e the rings near the central hole. With nowhere else to go, these inner rings, which cannot help expanding, may then be forced to expand inwards. So the hole gets smaller.

Back in the 1970s (remember Jackie Stewart?), there was a spate of brake discs failing on grand prix cars. They would pull into the pits with the discs glowing red. A minute later, there would be as many as four loud cracks, signalling that all four discs had snapped right through, and now looked like spring washers.
The explanation was as follows.
Under prolonged heavy braking, contact between the pad and the disc creates a (visible) momentary "ring of fire" at a particular radius. The metal (cast iron) in that ring melts and expands. But the metal behind the ring is relatively cold, and immediately quenches the molten metal -- which then cools and solidifies, and contracts. Now, the quenched metal of the ring is under induced tension, surrounded by cold metal under compression. Cast iron being weak in tension, the contracted metal gives way, i.e snaps.

These rings of fire last perhaps a second, and then another one instantly appears at another radius of the disc.
Over time, the surface of the disc would develop a series of radial (spoke-like) cracks -- which looked bad enough, and it could and did happen on the racing cars that the cracks would sometimes go right through, especially when the discs were cooling down after a period of heavy driving.
This same problem cracks appeared also on some ordinary cars, in which the discs were too small relative to the braking duty required by the power and weight of the vehicle, when driven hard. It was a problem with some Minis -- and some Rolls-Royces -- for exactly the same reason -- discs too small for the car, so overheating.

If you're still here, I just mention this to highlight that uneven heating of metals can cause all kinds of unpredictable expansion/contraction anomalies.
 
OK, suppose you have a one foot by one foot by one foot cube of solid steel, with a one inch hole drilled all the way through it.

Now, steel should expand when it is heated right?

So if you take that block of steel from 0 centigrade, to, say, 300 centigrade - will the hole in the middle get larger or smaller? On the one hand, shouldn't the steel expand equally in ALL directions, including in towards the hole, so that the hole will actually get smaller? Or will the whole damn block of steel just get bigger so that hole as well gets bigger?

The hole will get bigger
 
Sometimes it is useful to reason by analogy: Say you have a vagina with a passage 2.5 inches in diameter... now when a vagina is heated, it expands, right?? Does it only expand outwards or does it expand inwards as well?

Oh yes I like this analogy. This one is much easier for me to test.
 
OK, suppose you have a one foot by one foot by one foot cube of solid steel, with a one inch hole drilled all the way through it.

Now, steel should expand when it is heated right?

So if you take that block of steel from 0 centigrade, to, say, 300 centigrade - will the hole in the middle get larger or smaller? On the one hand, shouldn't the steel expand equally in ALL directions, including in towards the hole, so that the hole will actually get smaller? Or will the whole damn block of steel just get bigger so that hole as well gets bigger?

At 300 I doubt you would notice much difference at all in size
Steel has a much higher melt point so not much expansion would be happening
 
Imagine a thin layer of metal around the hole in the metal. If that layer expands, the hole will get a larger diameter.
 
As soon as you mentioned the hole in the block of steel, all I could think about was putting my dick in it.
 
My original issue was this - why won't there be SOME expansion TOWARDS the interior?
 
My original issue was this - why won't there be SOME expansion TOWARDS the interior?

Did you read any of the comments?

Think about it. If the hole or void gets smaller the space between the molecules will get smaller. This is opposite to what happens when you heat an object becuase molecules need more space. This is your answer in a nutshell.

Just imagine little molecules on the surface of that hole all fighting equally for MORE space. They can not go inside the hole because the space would decrease between molecules. All the molecules want more space all around, so does each end every other molecule around that hole. You cant have any movement towards the inside just on the simple fact that the molecules need more space.

Imagine you and 20 other people looking at each other just holding hands with arms down forming a circle. Now raise your arms to the side still holding hands and have them sticking out horizontally. Will the circle between you and your frineds get smaller or bigger. Same principle.

Applying heat causes molecules to vibrate faster and require more space between each other.

You are ignoring all the molecules around the circle and looking at it from only one molecule perspective. How about all the other molecules around that circle that also want more space. Why do you ignore them in your rationalization.

Do you want us to start psychoanalyzing your mind to understand why it cant understand this simple concept?
 
My original issue was this - why won't there be SOME expansion TOWARDS the interior?

The assumption is that the whole block of steel is heating up uniformly, so the whole block gets bigger uniformly whether there is a hole in the block or not.

However, If a heater was inserted into the hole, maybe could see the hole getting a bit smaller as the molecules making up the surface of the hole would want to expand, but would be blocked from expanding by the unheated cooler molecules in the block, so the heated molecules would expand into the hole making it smaller.
 
Interesting question

When I want to grease a pin on my truck I heat up the sleeve so the grease will go in

So the answer is the hole gets bigger but the pin is made of a different metal so it must not expand at the same rate, I assume

all I know is it is easier to grease once heated
 
The assumption is that the whole block of steel is heating up uniformly, so the whole block gets bigger uniformly whether there is a hole in the block or not.


However, If a heater was inserted into the hole, maybe could see the hole getting a bit smaller as the molecules making up the surface of the hole would want to expand, but would be blocked from expanding by the unheated cooler molecules in the block, so the heated molecules would expand into the hole making it smaller.

How would you see the hole get smaller if you put a heating device inside the hole. The molecules would want to expand on the surface, they would cancel out with each other the inward movement becuase of other molecules around the circle also want to do the same. They would push out on the colder molecules further inside the block spreading the temperature gradient and progressing the heat through the block. Steel is elastic up to a point so it would expand.

The only way a hole would get smaller is if you heat up block from the outside becuse the hotter molecules would be pushing on all directions and compressing inwards the room temperature molecules on the surface of the hole. This would be very small amount because the steel will have a tendancy to expand due to heat vs. push inwards so pressure would be there but can be conisdered negilable compared to the expansion of the block. i.e. Path of least resistance. However once the heat spreads through the block and it is equally distributed the hole would get bigger once it reaches to molecules on the surface of the circle. So it depends on the heat, where it is applied and the time.