Scientific issue that has always bugged kme

barnacler

Well-known member
May 13, 2013
1,781
1,304
113
OK, suppose you have a one foot by one foot by one foot cube of solid steel, with a one inch hole drilled all the way through it.

Now, steel should expand when it is heated right?

So if you take that block of steel from 0 centigrade, to, say, 300 centigrade - will the hole in the middle get larger or smaller? On the one hand, shouldn't the steel expand equally in ALL directions, including in towards the hole, so that the hole will actually get smaller? Or will the whole damn block of steel just get bigger so that hole as well gets bigger?
 
OK, suppose you have a one foot by one foot by one foot cube of solid steel, with a one inch hole drilled all the way through it.

Now, steel should expand when it is heated right?

So if you take that block of steel from 0 centigrade, to, say, 300 centigrade - will the hole in the middle get larger or smaller? On the one hand, shouldn't the steel expand equally in ALL directions, including in towards the hole, so that the hole will actually get smaller? Or will the whole damn block of steel just get bigger so that hole as well gets bigger?
Carry out a nonisothermal finite element analysis of the expansion over the temperature range and get back to us.
 
If there was no hole drilled in the block, would the block get bigger when heated? Would a 1" circle drawn on the middle of the block, or anywhere else also get bigger?
 
On the one hand, shouldn't the steel expand in ALL directions, including in towards the hole, so that the hole will actually get smaller

Have you ever checked your blood pressure? You put on a cuff around your arm, and it expands. It doesn't just expand outwards, but inwards as well. That's because the cuff is expanding.

The steel is expanding, the air in the hole isn't expanding (Well, it is, but the pressure from the hot steel > pressure from hot air), so practically we can ignore the expanding air.
 
Sometimes it is useful to reason by analogy: Say you have a vagina with a passage 2.5 inches in diameter... now when a vagina is heated, it expands, right?? Does it only expand outwards or does it expand inwards as well?
 
The hole gets larger. Instead of the block of steel, think of the cylinder of steel removed when the hole is drilled. Heat that up and it will expand. Therefore, the hole that it came from will also expand. Similar concept as the circle drawn on the block mentioned by KBear, above.
 
Is this one of those perverted F an object fantasies?
 
Doesn't it depend how uniformly the heat is applied to this block of steel?

Personally, I would say that the hole gets bigger.
 
OK, suppose you have a one foot by one foot by one foot cube of solid steel, with a one inch hole drilled all the way through it.

Now, steel should expand when it is heated right?

So if you take that block of steel from 0 centigrade, to, say, 300 centigrade - will the hole in the middle get larger or smaller? On the one hand, shouldn't the steel expand equally in ALL directions, including in towards the hole, so that the hole will actually get smaller? Or will the whole damn block of steel just get bigger so that hole as well gets bigger?

If that were the case then you would not be able to pull apart two metal objects that have been heated up. Like say a hammer with a brass tip.

Edit I am wrong I think cooling is better for that purposes.
 
molecules move quicker when they are heated hence a change in size of a .001 or .0001 of an inch. dont know the exact expansion but with the correct info about the steel composition you can work the math out.

just as if you cooled a piece of steel with liquid nitrogen it will technically shrink. when I worked in a machine shop a shaft would be cooled with liquid nitrogen so it would shrink a couple of thousands of an inch so it would have an interference fit on the bearing after it returned to room temp. the cooled shaft would eventually drop into the bearing with just the force of gravity to guide it.

so the entire block will expand and the 1" hole should technically bigger..
 
molecules move quicker when they are heated hence a change in size of a .001 or .0001 of an inch. dont know the exact expansion but with the correct info about the steel composition you can work the math out.

just as if you cooled a piece of steel with liquid nitrogen it will technically shrink. when I worked in a machine shop a shaft would be cooled with liquid nitrogen so it would shrink a couple of thousands of an inch so it would have an interference fit on the bearing after it returned to room temp. the cooled shaft would eventually drop into the bearing with just the force of gravity to guide it.

so the entire block will expand and the 1" hole should technically bigger..

Thank you sir!
 
We have a bunch of smarty panties in here...hehehe....answer is it gets bigger.

Here is the process to figure out the actual thermal expansion amount.

 
There are always impurities in steel which would affect how quickly, uniformly and in which direction it expands.
 
And in a slight twist...

Say you had a block of steel.... 3' cube of strong steel...super strong....And in the centre of that steel you had an egg sized pocket of water...no bubbles.


Then you froze that steel at way below sub zero...way way down in temp.


Does the water freeze/expand? And in so doing, does the steel crack?

Or????
 
There reason why the hole will get bigger is that in a hot object the molecules will be further apart. That's what causes the expansion.

Think about the molecules along the rim of the hole--they need to get further apart. If the hole got smaller, they would instead be crunched together, the opposite of what needs to happen. The only way the molecules along the edge of the hole get further from one another is if the hole gets bigger.
 
But at least on some small, barely measurable level, the hole should expand slightly less than the rest of the block because ambient temperature air is passing through it so shouldn't the rim of the hole (as well as the block's outer edges) cool down just a tiny bit faster than the thicker, more continuous areas of the block???
 
There reason why the hole will get bigger is that in a hot object the molecules will be further apart. That's what causes the expansion.

So I guess,...the molecules will be further apart in only one direction,...who knew.

FAST