Blue Jays: 2016 Edition

You mean the way Gibby was universally praised as a good manager last year for getting to the ALCS?

Really? My recollection was that he was roasted pretty good for needlessly bringing in Price when Dickey was cruising again Texas, and exposing Osuna to the Royals in a blowout in game 3.
 
You mean the way Gibby was universally praised as a good manager last year for getting to the ALCS?
By who?? I dont remember anyone praising Gibby

That team was so stacked he wouldve had to really work at it not get to ALCS
 
Really? My recollection was that he was roasted pretty good for needlessly bringing in Price when Dickey was cruising again Texas, and exposing Osuna to the Royals in a blowout in game 3.

By who?? I dont remember anyone praising Gibby
Exactly.

bbl mentioned that a manager gets too much credit when a team wins. All I see is Gibby get shit on. No two way street here.

I'm sure a manager makes hundreds of moves during a single game. But if one of them is wrong, the so-called experts are head hunting. It means when they won 90-something games last year he made 10's of thousands of correct moves. It means most of the managers made more mistakes than he did.
 
All I see is Gibby get shit on. No two way street here.

I'm sure a manager makes hundreds of moves during a single game. But if one of them is wrong, the so-called experts are head hunting. It means when they won 90-something games last year he made 10's of thousands of correct moves. It means most of the managers made more mistakes than he did
Having said that, do you think Gibby will lead Jays to glory, or do you think someone better should take over??

My opinion (for what its worth), when you're trying to build a world-class team, you need a world-class manager.
So far I havent seen that in Gibby.

I see a decent manager in him, but not world-class
 
I've noticed that Boom Bats is hitting for contact this year. He's out to prove that last year's low average was due to his shoulder injury. If he resigns with the Jays, and I sincerely hope he does, does this mean he'll make an appearance on Take5's other hit show Penny Dreadful? Eva Green in a Blue Jays jersey - and nothing else. yum!
 
Having said that, do you think Gibby will lead Jays to glory, or do you think someone better should take over??

My opinion (for what its worth), when you're trying to build a world-class team, you need a world-class manager.
So far I havent seen that in Gibby.

I see a decent manager in him, but not world-class
He knows the game (it's amazing how many ex-catchers are managers) and the players play hard for him. They respect him.

Don't think you need much more of a manager.

After that, you need some players to have career years and you must stay relatively healthy. If you don't have those, no manager, world class or not (by the way any player or manager in MLB is world class by default) will win.
 
I wonder if Marcus Stroman should be moved into the bullpen because Cecil and Stoeren are losing too many games with the way they've been playing.

In the age of the nuclear bullpen, I've got a feeling Kansas City would put him there and Keith Law has been saying since Stroman was drafted that his long term future in the game should be as a lights out reliever. He thinks Stroman is the re incarnation of Tom Flash Gordon who recorded 46 saves with the Red Sox in 1998.

Sanchez looks too much like a prototypical stud starting pitcher to pull out of the rotation.
Steve Rogers of the Expos went from 134.0 innings in his rookie season of 1973 up to 253.2 in his sophomore season of 1974; so, Sanchez should be able to do 200 innings. Rogers never had any serious injuries during his career judging from the looks of his pitching profile on baseball reference.
The Jays spend too much time coddling and babying the pitchers they draft so that they can't hit 200 innings until 3 years after they debut in MLB. It's ridiculous.

Steve Rogers:
http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/r/rogerst01.shtml
 
God, this pen is awful outside of Osuna. Cecil plain sucks. Storen is the new Kevin Gregg. Venditte ain't a big leaguer. And Floyd is Shapiro's boy.
 
Good to see Brett Lawrie again. He looks different. Did he lose weight and is he wearing glasses now?
 
Saunders is coming along nicely. Good ole Canadian boy


:ranger:
 
does anyone know why josh Donaldson puts his 3 fingers in the air when he crosses home plate after a homer? I once read it was to show marcus stroman love when he was pretty much out for the season last year, but stroman is back and he still does it so I was curious if anyone knows what it means.
 
our bullpen is a shitshow. killing us right now.
 
Finding some AAA bat to PH for Goins is secondary to finding a bullpen! We have the 2nd worst bullpen in MLB. They blow hold after hold. Back in the off season when Jays missed opportunities to sign guys like O' Day, I wondered if this was how it was going to turn out!

Osuna aside, none of the bullpen looks decent. Maybe they can use Hutch for middle / long relief!
 
In his post game perspective Zauno was right on both counts.

Gibby made a mistake by coddling Stroman. He should have been allowed to pitch his way through the sixth inning. If he wants to be the ace of the staff he has to pitch his way out of trouble. It's not entirely Cecil's fault, it was the third game in a row he was called in to relieve. And if Stroman wants to be the ace he can't behave, to quote Moe Berg, "like a cheese eating high school boy". He's an adult now.
 
*Cheesie eating high school boy

Stroman looked done. Gibby just needs more options in his pen.
 
Last edited:
*Cheesie eating high school boy

Stroman looked done. Gibby just needs more options in his pen.

I luv the Stro show but is spoiled, little brat antics on the bench last night has to calm down, Zaun ripped into him.
 
I think bringing in Cecil at the time was the right move. After getting hit by the batted ball off Navarro, Stroman looked bad walking the number 9 guy on 4 pitches and a lefty was coming up. Second, as much as me and everybody likes the guy, Stroman has not yet earned complete ace status and the chance of him burning out is real (remember Ricky Romero - the last appointed ace (Dickey earned it with a Cy Young and then lost it). Cecil will have to turn it around and he probably will based on past performances - just not last night. Playing the result is easy - but who would have predicted that Cecil would fail to get 3 straight guys?

If Mr. Gibbons is making an error is thinking that Venditte is a major league pitcher. Chavez should have been in to start the ninth and that would have prevented insurance run.

Also, does anyone know the Jays batting average versus starting pitchers versus relief pitchers. It looks like we are only scoring against starters.

Mr. Gibbons should have been royally p****** losing a game where the Sox start their number 5 for the moment against our number 1 for the moment...and tonight its Dickey v Sale...look out.

By the way, Kathleen is looking better than ever and still has the best legs in the GTA ;)