Smoking - time for the endgame?

If we've gotten down to 15% with the current practices I see no reason to change. I'll make a fair assumption that the largest group of smokers is older. They'll be out of the picture whether through attrition or deciding to quit. I'd be okay if smoking was at the same level as weed, something people do but not as publicly.


And the weed comparison is a poor one. Weed is an issue mostly because the intoxicating effects. Smoking is an issue because people feel the need to have a pack or two a day.

Can't even imagine a typical person sparking 20 Js a day.
 
All very well to legislate: 'Nicotine is banned', but you have to have penalties, and that's when you criminalize. The harder you make it to get the stuff the bigger the underground market gets, with all the evils of utterly unregulated commerce.

But I'll take your, "I think it is time for an outright ban." as over-enthusiasm and hyperbole along with your call to "Outlaw the sale …", and imagine something like the old British System for managing addicts off heroin by legal prescriptions. Not that it worked, but it was relatively peaceable. Until mass tourism, greed and TV made such quiet little national policies impossible to maintain.

Given people's right to live as unhealthily as they choose, I see no hope of achieving zero use, and don't see much to be gained tinkering with the present set-up. Although I'd generally favour anything the cleared the butts from around buildings and kept the shivering addicts better hidden in winter. But regulating building owners to provide ashstands, and maintain their frontage would do more than any amount of 'outlawing'. And no law will stop private smoking at home

Although soon there'll be a carbon tax …

Lots of things are illegal, and come with a fine, without being criminal. Criminal charges would ruin people's lives. What I'm talking about is more like a parking ticket.
 
Lots of things are illegal, and come with a fine, without being criminal. Criminal charges would ruin people's lives. What I'm talking about is more like a parking ticket.
So, roughly speaking, as legal and available as alcohol; a few truly serious infractions with stiff penalties, like f'rinstance smoking in a car with kids, but mostly simple regulations with minor penalties and those not rigorously enforced, like we have against drinking in parks. Is that sorta what you mean?

I can easily see that kind of regime, but calling it an outright ban seems a little exaggerated. Regulated use, education and most importantly, social pressure will get us closer to zero use with less pain than bans and prohibitions. But nothing is absolute and with humans there's no zero point, which is why it's so important not to flim-flam ourselves into thinking that's what we're committed to in this relatively trivial matter.

Smoking isn't smallpox.
 
But if you really think making drugs illegal keeps our roads safe, why isn't alcohol illegal? It's far and away the most abused drug, and the one involved in the most crimes on and off the road.

I don't want to hijack the thread (I agree that this is not the main topic), but to answer your question, not all consumption of alcohol is legal. You are only allowed to operate a motor vehicle if you consume less than the legal limit. There has been a lot of research over many years into the intoxication effects of alcohol that correspond with different blood alcohol levels, and reliable testing procedures have been developed. As a result, society can feel secure that driving a vehicle with alcohol consumption less than the legal limit does not pose a significant safety hazard, and can be reasonably sure that a decision by a driver to drive over the limit can be reliably proved and punished. All of this information, research and testing provides some measure of security to the public about the safety of driving, and a reasonable expectation of arrest and conviction on the part of those who might break the law.

The same cannot be said about marijuana. Although some roadside cannabinoid testing methods do currently exist (swab testing):

1. There is no consensus that existing testing methods are sufficiently reliable (just review a few labour arbitration decisions on this).
2. Current testing methods do not produce an immediate result, so they can't be used to immediately take a driver off the road (in the way that a failed breathalyzer can).
3. There is no consensus as to how to measure the precise degree of impairment arising from specific levels on THC in the bloodstream, or other metrics of use (especially important since THC can stay in your system for much longer than alcohol).
4. The product itself varies widely in potency, making it hard for users to know what safe usage levels are.

In short, the reason pot is still illegal (and the historical commentary is interesting, but I think irrelevant to why pot is illegal today) is that we lack the ability to police its use in the way that alcohol abuse can be policed. I agree that the two are morally equivalent (as examples of self abuse), and that we don't need to legislate against all forms of self abuse.

To bring this back to the original topic, the argument against tobacco is completely different. It's based on second hand impact on non-smokers as well as the cost to the public health system.
 
So, roughly speaking, as legal and available as alcohol; a few truly serious infractions with stiff penalties, like f'rinstance smoking in a car with kids, but mostly simple regulations with minor penalties and those not rigorously enforced, like we have against drinking in parks. Is that sorta what you mean?

I can easily see that kind of regime, but calling it an outright ban seems a little exaggerated. Regulated use, education and most importantly, social pressure will get us closer to zero use with less pain than bans and prohibitions. But nothing is absolute and with humans there's no zero point, which is why it's so important not to flim-flam ourselves into thinking that's what we're committed to in this relatively trivial matter.

Smoking isn't smallpox.

How about a specific proposal: The sale of products containing nicotine should be banned by the province, with a fine of $25,000 for violators. Smoking itself should be banned in all public places subject to a $1000 fine. The drug should be available on prescription so that doctors can work with addicts in a compassionate way.
 
How about sexaddiction? May be next?

Sex isn't fundamentally harmful. Even other things like caffeine, which is addictive, aren't as harmful as nicotine.

Smoking kills 37000 Canadians a year, and another 800 Canadians die each year from exposure to second hand smoke. We can debate where the line is for something to be so harmful that it should be banned: however you draw that line, smoking will be on the wrong side of it.

I'm not aware of tens of thousands of deaths a year from sex addiction.
 
So, it isn't really a choice
The first few times someone tries drugs its definitely a choice. But after the user becomes addicted its no longer a choice because the addict loses control at this point
 
Make up your mind
I just did. The first few times someone tries drugs they are making a conscious choice, because they are not addicted yet
 
I just did. The first few times someone tries drugs they are making a conscious choice, because they are not addicted yet

So for 99.999% of people who buy tobacco, namely smokers, it is not a choice. For example, a typical smoker consumes 10 cigarettes a day, over 30 years that is around 100,000 cigarettes. You are saying the first 0.001% of those were a choice.
 
So for 99.999% of people who buy tobacco, namely smokers, it is not a choice
The fact they're addicted to tobacco is because of their initial stupid choice.

If I'm at a party and someone offers me a cig or a dimebag of heroin I'm going to decline. So, I just made a choice
 
The fact they're addicted to tobacco is because of their initial stupid choice.

If I'm at a party and someone offers me a cig or a dimebag of heroin I'm going to decline. So, I just made a choice

So we can agree. 99.999% of the time people buy nicotine products, it isn't a choice.
 
So we can agree. 99.999% of the time people buy nicotine products, it isn't a choice
No we dont agree, because it was their initial stupid choice that got them into that predicament
 
No we dont agree, because it was their initial stupid choice that got them into that predicament

All you are saying is that their initial purchases were voluntary. You agreed that the overwhelming majority of their purchases after that were not voluntary.

These are your words: "after the user becomes addicted its no longer a choice "