NFL Playoffs

I got one score right. Denver 20, but otherwise...........

New England was too one dimensional. A patchwork line and the Broncos incredible rush did it. Was it 17 rushes and about the same knockdowns. Brady still almost pulled it out despite all the punishment. Got to admit he's one tough SOB at almost 40.

I don't see Carson Palmer surviving that Panthers D and I think Peyton will get killed by it.
 
On the gridiron, Tom Brady has had Payton Manning hexed for over a decade. The Broncos are going to need a strong running game if they are going to have a chance.
In AFC Championship games I think Manning is now ahead 4-1 or 3-1 vs. Brady. Brady's legacy should be "Couldn't beat Manning to get to the SB". Between this and regular season stats Manning had a greater career. (Doubt I will get any disagreement there.)
 
In AFC Championship games I think Manning is now ahead 4-1 or 3-1 vs. Brady. Brady's legacy should be "Couldn't beat Manning to get to the SB". Between this and regular season stats Manning had a greater career. (Doubt I will get any disagreement there.)

Brady was beat by the D. One look at Mannings stats the last two weeks shows how much he was propped up by his D.

When the Broncos face off against the Panthers the D won't be able to tee off on a quarterback with no running game.
 
Isn't Brady 3 or 4 Super Bowl to Mannings 1?
4-1. But mano a mano for the AFC champ it is no contest. They can't play vs each other in a SB so this is as important a game they can play.

Also, Brady has played with a better organisation and a better coach to win those SBs. As good as he is, it is not all him.
 
Brady was beat by the D. One look at Mannings stats the last two weeks shows how much he was propped up by his D.
In that case, you have to acknowledge that Manning had real crappy defenses giving him next to no propping all those years in Indy yet he still had great results.
 
In AFC Championship games I think Manning is now ahead 4-1 or 3-1 vs. Brady. Brady's legacy should be "Couldn't beat Manning to get to the SB". Between this and regular season stats Manning had a greater career. (Doubt I will get any disagreement there.)

You will get much disagreement

3-1 in head to head, is minimal in importance to 4-1 Superbowls, for many NFL Fans. Don't shoot the messanger, that is just what I have learned from observing the NFL over the years, Championships mean a whole bunch when evaluating QB's, and Peyton has shown an inability to win the big one.

Personally, I think Peyton gets a raw deal, and I have no problem with putting Peyton above Brady. Actually, I am not big enough NFL care to feel passionate about either side. But head to head will not trump the # of titles for a significant base of fans.
 
You will get much disagreement
I expected it. My comment was mostly tongue in cheek.

IMO, both QB's have had phenomenal careers and I don't see how anybody can objectively say that one was clearly better than the other. One can interpret the stats either way. Regular season stats, post season stats, super bowls, overall quality of teams, overall quality of organizations, head to head records and on and on. There is no formula or weighting system to determine the relative importance of any of those factors. The stats are objective but their interpretation is hugely subjective.

We have been blessed to have seen two of the greatest of all time playing concurrently for so long. I don't see the need to have to crown one over the other as we all know it is a debate that can't be won. My recent posts in this thread were mainly a commentary against the posts I see declaring Brady clearly the greater QB because of his team's success. I didn't completely agree with what I posted. I just wanted to show how one can interpret the stats any way they want in an attempt to uphold one's beliefs either way.

I will be pulling for Peyton in the Bowl.
 
Championships mean a whole bunch when evaluating QB's,
Sure championships are important but the question is "Of how much importance"?

Is Eli and his 2 SBs better than Peyton?
Is Eli better than Marino was?
Was Doug Williams better than Marino?
Was Trent Dilfer better than Marino?

Obviously Marino was better but he won nothing. It wasn't his fault his teams weren't good enough, just as it's not Peyton's fault that Brady had better support an and off the field.

One can't say "Peyton couldn't win the big one" because football is the ultimate team sport. Nobody wins or loses on their own. His teams couldn't win the big one is a more accurate statement.

There is no objective rating system.
 
Sure championships are important but the question is "Of how much importance"?

Is Eli and his 2 SBs better than Peyton?
Is Eli better than Marino was?
Was Doug Williams better than Marino?
Was Trent Dilfer better than Marino?

Obviously Marino was better but he won nothing. It wasn't his fault his teams weren't good enough, just as it's not Peyton's fault that Brady had better support an and off the field.

One can't say "Peyton couldn't win the big one" because football is the ultimate team sport. Nobody wins or loses on their own. His teams couldn't win the big one is a more accurate statement.

There is no objective rating system.

I always laugh when I see
Brady..vs..Manning
Montana..vs..Marino
Griese..vs..Tarkenton
Bradshaw..vs..Staubach
They NEVER squared off against eachother!!
 
If I had a choice, I would take Russell Wilson and Cam Newton over Brady and Manning because they can run.
 
If I had a choice, I would take Russell Wilson and Cam Newton over Brady and Manning because they can run.

1)Let's see how well they will run when they are 38 (especially after getting banged up doing all their running. Ever hear of Robert Griffin? Pocket passers have longer careers.)

2)Brady's and Manning's careers sucked because they couldn't run.

10-20 years from now Newton and Wilson will be afterthoughts compared to Brady/Manning.
 
I think that QB's who run intelligently can actually have long careers. They can avoid the rush and not get hit like a sitting duck in the pocket. They can run and avoid getting hit by simply falling down or run out of bounds.