Derek Jeter will not get 100%.
I, like some analysts and writers have written before, believe Jeter to be an overrated great players of all time (note that I still said he was a great of all time). The New York Media has created this fiction that he is amongst the Greatest of the Greatest Hall of Famers And some believe that is not the case.
I see him more in the class of a Robin Yount or Paul Molitor level hall of Famer -- he had a little more longevity to get more hits so he is a tad highers. A clear first ballot hall of famer but not one of the 10 greatest players of all time.
This feeling has been expressed by some BWAA members before - and all it takes is one not to friendly with New York to explain his vote publicly by saying something like this for exampe
"While I think Derek Jeter is a clear hall of famer, typically one I would deem a first ballot hall of famer, the potential for Jeter to be the highest voted Hall of Famer ever is problematic for me. Derek Jeter was never the best player in baseball in any given season, never the best fielder at his position. His status was elevated by the market he played in and his chance to play with other great players, He is not one of the handful of best players ever -- In good conscience, as a custodian to baseball history I could not go along with him being the highest voted hall of famer ever".
This type of "class" distinction happens all the time amongst voters -- guys who are all hall of famers but are not deemed first ballot guys. And of course there are petty agendas.