WW II - What Ifs?

I think if we had been having these discussions in mid-1942, we might not have been so confident that the Allies would prevail. And it could very well have happened that the Americans did indeed lose the Battle of Midway.

At 10.20am 4 june 1942, any one who looked at the state of the world, and said it was inevitable that the Axis powers would surrender unconditionally, would need his head examined. The Battle of Midway was unfolding just like all the others -- disastrously. Picture Roosevelt at that moment. Tell me he wasn't thinking: There is no light at the end of the tunnel. I'm gonna have to give the Japs the whole of East Asia, to make them stop. Probably Australia as well.

Japanese would not have taken Hawaii and that would have ended their expansion, regardless of Midway. Hawaii was heavily fortified and garrisoned. As long as the USA had a carrier fleet in existence, it could also have contended in the Pacific. While the decisive USN attack at Midway was dramatic, there was still no indication that the IJN was doing much damage to the US carriers. Up to that final attack, neither side had landed a heavy punch.
 
I read a statistic that the Japanese GDP never exceeded 18% of US gdp during the entire war. Not really possible to win in that situation, once the Germans were prevented from getting the Russian oil fields and US subs made sure Japanese tankers never made it to Japan, it was all over.
 
^ Even the intelligent and well informed were very concerned between December 1941 and mid June 1942. Remember that every single aircraft carrier the Pacific Fleet had was at Midway, while only a fraction of IJN Aircraft carriers were there.

After the battle of the Coral Sea in May 1942 for a while the U.S.N had but three aircraft carriers in the Pacific.
 
. . Remember that every single aircraft carrier the Pacific Fleet had was at Midway, while only a fraction of IJN Aircraft carriers were there.
After the battle of the Coral Sea in May 1942 for a while the U.S.N had but three aircraft carriers in the Pacific.

In fact the fraction of (heavy) JP carriers at Midway was two-thirds -- i.e four out of six. All four were sunk. (The other two (Shokaku and Zuikaka) were under repair in june 42.) All six had been at Pearl Harbour.

Two new heavy carriers (Junyo, Hiyo) entered service shortly after. At that time, the IJN also had two escort carriers and three light carriers.

From then until the end of the war, two more heavy carriers (Hiyo, Taiho) entered service. The huge carrier Shinano was completed in 1944 but was sunk in harbour. Also five more light carriers, and three more escort carriers.

Every one of the JP carriers, large and small, was sunk or destroyed.
 
Last edited:
What if the French and/or British and/or U.S. a) enforced the Treaty of Versailles and b) kicked Hitler out of the Rhineland in 1936. Hitler was posturing to see how far he could go and, according to his papers, had given orders to withdraw if there was any resistance. Humm.. Very similar to Putin today going into Abkhazia, South Ossetia, Crimea, then eastern Ukraine, the latter two in violation of the Budapest Memorandum, not to mention International Law generally. The British and U.S. should be ashamed.
 
Very similar to Putin today going into Abkhazia, South Ossetia, Crimea, then eastern Ukraine, the latter two in violation of the Budapest Memorandum, not to mention International Law generally. The British and U.S. should be ashamed.
It is Putin who should be ashamed. Back in the old days it was a duty and moral obligation to oppose evil, to-day it is a war crime.