The Evidence: MH 017

I agree with that. Follow the money or as the french say: "Cherchez la femme". Clearly the downing of the airplane was a massive problem for Putin, and very beneficial to Obama (staying in the media parlance).

I disagree that is a 'false flag' operation as you might be implying here.

I will agree with Oagre's analysis (although I might take exception that anti-aircraft bullets or from a fighter jet can't take down a passenger airliner - couldn't heavy caliber rounds cause an explosion to a giant fuel tank?).
 
That is one question but we also have to consider the other applicable question. Who did something dumb? Examining motivation assumes all people act rationally.

Dumb or not, the finger points away from the Russians. Which is ultimately, very important.
 
I'm not insulted, I'm not from Ukraine. I was just letting you know. No offence taken by me.

To ease your curiosity though, don't cheat and tineye or GIS this picture, and tell me if you think the aircraft was struck by bullets or a missile?

Kim_campbell_damage_a10.jpg



If that's a missing pylon and engine, I'll say missile, but those look like bullet holes, although there are many of them which seem too close together (ergo, shrapnel?)
 
I'm not insulted, I'm not from Ukraine. I was just letting you know. No offence taken by me.

To ease your curiosity though, don't cheat and tineye or GIS this picture, and tell me if you think the aircraft was struck by bullets or a missile?

Kim_campbell_damage_a10.jpg


I could not tell you. To my eye it could be both, although from your question I am pretty sure it is a missile.


The thing that struck me on the picture of piece under the cockpit of MH17, is that some of the holes "pointed" outwards, while others "pointed" inwards. On your picture they all "point" inwards, as you would expect from a missile hitting.
 
I could not tell you. To my eye it could be both, although from your question I am pretty sure it is a missile.


The thing that struck me on the picture of piece under the cockpit of MH17, is that some of the holes "pointed" outwards, while others "pointed" inwards. On your picture they all "point" inwards, as you would expect from a missile hitting.


Well, if pointing outwards, it could be rivets blowing out as suggested by Blue Laser?
 
MH17. A Boing 777 which first flew on 17/07/1997. 17 years to the day of its final flight on 17/07/2014.
 
Just a small note to the "bullet holes". SA rocket Buk-1M is loaded with shrapnel. It explodes ~50-30 meters (if I am not mistaken about the distance, I studied radar systems, Buk was taught to another group) and send cloud of shrapnel towards target. There are 2 different warheads: with shrapnel - metal balls, and shrapnel - metal rods. Again, I do not remember which exactly is used when, but the holes from the ball shrapnel would look like bullet holes.
 
Just a small note to the "bullet holes". SA rocket Buk-1M is loaded with shrapnel. It explodes ~50-30 meters (if I am not mistaken about the distance, I studied radar systems, Buk was taught to another group) and send cloud of shrapnel towards target. There are 2 different warheads: with shrapnel - metal balls, and shrapnel - metal rods. Again, I do not remember which exactly is used when, but the holes from the ball shrapnel would look like bullet holes.

I think we all understand that. The only thing midly puzzling is that some of the holes look like they were pointing outwards, not inwards.
 
I think we all understand that. The only thing midly puzzling is that some of the holes look like they were pointing outwards, not inwards.

That is what shrapnel is meant for - to pierce aircraft and cause not critical structural damage, but destroy inner equipment, power, fuel lines etc. And it does take much to pierce an aluminum foil in and out.
 
That is what shrapnel is meant for - to pierce aircraft and cause not critical structural damage, but destroy inner equipment, power, fuel lines etc. And it does take much to pierce an aluminum foil in and out.

Take a look at the pictures. Some of the "bullet holes" are from things penetrating the fuselage in an outward direction. I am no expert on shooting down airplanes with missiles, but I am somewhat puzzled by these holes. I guess there couild be two missiles, one from each side.

I also read from some expert on the BUK missile system, that those missiles are programmed to explode above the airplane. Again, I have no clue if that is correct.
 
Take a look at the pictures. Some of the "bullet holes" are from things penetrating the fuselage in an outward direction. I am no expert on shooting down airplanes with missiles, but I am somewhat puzzled by these holes. I guess there couild be two missiles, one from each side.

I also read from some expert on the BUK missile system, that those missiles are programmed to explode above the airplane. Again, I have no clue if that is correct.

The photos don't show things penetrating outwards, they show a hole and metal bent outwards. That may be evidence of something penetrating outwards, it could also be the result of heat and structural failures. Like you said, you're not an expert. Being puzzled isn't a big deal when looking at things we know absolutely nothing about. That doesn't provide proof of anything. It isn't even evidence of anything.

Reasons for different fracture patterns can be numerous. I mentioned rivets and liquified aluminium already. It's also worth noting a key element with shrapnel: exit wounds aren't always directly across from entry wounds. Bits of metal in hit bits of metal inside, bounce off each other, possibly cause things inside to explode, more stuff comes out. If you and I aren't experts, where are the ones who are? Are they joining in the conspiracy theory debates to give it credibility, or are they just ignoring it as if it's beneath them and not worth their time to even entertain such ridiculous claims? Not a single credible source has come forward to say they think it's bullet holes going in both directions. That speaks volumes as far as I'm concerned.
 
The photos don't show things penetrating outwards, they show a hole and metal bent outwards. That may be evidence of something penetrating outwards, it could also be the result of heat and structural failures. Like you said, you're not an expert. Being puzzled isn't a big deal when looking at things we know absolutely nothing about. That doesn't provide proof of anything. It isn't even evidence of anything.

Reasons for different fracture patterns can be numerous. I mentioned rivets and liquified aluminium already. It's also worth noting a key element with shrapnel: exit wounds aren't always directly across from entry wounds. Bits of metal in hit bits of metal inside, bounce off each other, possibly cause things inside to explode, more stuff comes out. If you and I aren't experts, where are the ones who are? Are they joining in the conspiracy theory debates to give it credibility, or are they just ignoring it as if it's beneath them and not worth their time to even entertain such ridiculous claims? Not a single credible source has come forward to say they think it's bullet holes going in both directions. That speaks volumes as far as I'm concerned.

I did not say it was a big deal. I used the term "mildly puzzled". And please do not pull the conspiracy theory card. I have given you no reason to be confrontational.
I was not trained in the military to follow orders and believe what I am told. I was trained as an engineer and to think independently about what I observe. I simply find it odd that there are a bunch of holes showing things penetrating from the inside. The photo you showed does not have a single hole like that. I am not at all convinced that these holes are bullet holes, I just thought that maybe you or somebody else could come up with an explanation.
 
...And please do not pull the conspiracy theory card.....

When people without a solid background in the field and with very incomplete evidence start coming up with conclusions to fit their preconcieved political opinions, it sure seems a possibility.

At least prehistoric and bluelaser seem to have a background in military aviation.
 
For a long time I had Blackrock following me everywhere on Terb and commenting on every post I made. Finally he left, and what happens? Now Basketcase follows me everywhere and comments on every post I make.

It must be more fun to stalk jennifer Lawrence or Scarlet johannson.
 
For a long time I had Blackrock following me everywhere on Terb and commenting on every post I made. Finally he left, and what happens? Now Basketcase follows me everywhere and comments on every post I make.

It must be more fun to stalk Jennifer Lawrence or Scarlet Johannson.

Well, if you stop posting, then he won't seem to be following you. Problem solved.
 
I'm not insulted, I'm not from Ukraine. I was just letting you know. No offence taken by me.

To ease your curiosity though, don't cheat and tineye or GIS this picture, and tell me if you think the aircraft was struck by bullets or a missile?

Kim_campbell_damage_a10.jpg

I'm going to take a guess at this. 20mm cannon hit on the stabilizer with debris spatter striking the rear fuselage. Or else cannon hit on the stabilizer and shrapnel from an explosive round, possibly missile to fuselage - i.e 2 different hits.
 
I disagree that is a 'false flag' operation as you might be implying here.

I will agree with Oagre's analysis (although I might take exception that anti-aircraft bullets or from a fighter jet can't take down a passenger airliner - couldn't heavy caliber rounds cause an explosion to a giant fuel tank?).

I am going to assume the fuel tanks in the airliner were wing mounted and adjacent to the engines. You would get a flame up or an explosion taking off the wing with lots of burn scarring.

And stalking the plane and killing it at close range with prolonged gunfire is a ridiculous procedure when you could stand of at a km with a modern guided missile, get your lock on and a 100% probability kill in a second or two.
 
That is what shrapnel is meant for - to pierce aircraft and cause not critical structural damage, but destroy inner equipment, power, fuel lines etc. And it does take much to pierce an aluminum foil in and out.

??? Uh, no. The purpose of "shrapnel" is to maximize the opportunities to destroy an enemy target by maximizing the number of projectiles hitting that target. Good grief.