When Genocide is Permissible

They are not citizens and they do not live in Israel, hence the term apartheid is not applicable.

All citizens of Israel are treated equally.

The term apartheid is applicable because they live under Israeli military rule.
And it will be applicable until they are:
a) given full human rights and citizenship
b) given their own autonomous state

Israel treats those they rule in the occupied territories to apartheid rule.
 
The term apartheid is applicable because they live under Israeli military rule.
And it will be applicable until they are:
a) given full human rights and citizenship
b) given their own autonomous state

Israel treats those they rule in the occupied territories to apartheid rule.
The term apartheid means legal segregation based on ethnicity. Since 20% of Israeli citizens are ethically identical to West Bank Palestinians yet have full rights, you are full of shit.

p.s. Where do you get off trying to impose a solution that the Palestinians are overwhelmingly opposed to.
 
So you are against apartheid?
Then you must back either giving Palestine a state immediately or giving them full human rights under Israeli rule.
Because right now Palestinians in the occupied territories live under apartheid Israeli rule.

All the Palestinians in Israel already have full rights. Calling Israel apartheid just reveals you to be a mindless antisemite hell bent on inciting hatred.
 
All the Palestinians in Israel already have full rights.

Bullshit straw man attack.
Deliberately trying to ignore that I very clearly was talking about Palestinians in the Occupied Territories.
Bullshit, last ditch defence by someone who has no other defence.
 
Bullshit straw man attack.

You might want to look up the meaning of the term 'straw man'.


Deliberately trying to ignore that I very clearly was talking about Palestinians in the Occupied Territories.
...
Who are the same ethnicity as 20% of Israel's population. Not about race at all.
 
Bullshit straw man attack.
Deliberately trying to ignore that I very clearly was talking about Palestinians in the Occupied Territories.
Bullshit, last ditch defence by someone who has no other defence.

The Palestinians in Gaza are not in Israel. Duh. That is what the phrase you just used means, "occupied territory" means it is not Israel.

No matter how much clown dancing you do Gaza and the West Bank still won't be Israeli territory.
 
The Palestinians in Gaza are not in Israel. Duh. That is what the phrase you just used means, "occupied territory" means it is not Israel.

No matter how much clown dancing you do Gaza and the West Bank still won't be Israeli territory.

They have lived under Israeli rule for about half a century.
The Likud party charter says they will never accept a Palestinian state, as does Netanyahu.

There is no Palestine, only the occupied lands run by Israel.
And they run the occupied territories as an apartheid system.
End of argument.
 
...
And they run the occupied territories as an apartheid system.
End of argument.
You are right. It is the end of argument because it can't be an apartheid system since 2 million or so Israelis share the same ethnicity.
 
As an occupied territory.

Correct, living under military apartheid rule for half a century under a party that refuses to recognize a Palestinian state, obey the Geneva Conventions or listen to the UN.
 
Correct, living under military apartheid rule for half a century under a party that refuses to recognize a Palestinian state, obey the Geneva Conventions or listen to the UN.

It is not "apartheid rule", that is antisemitic nonsense.

I note that you have lost the point about them being in Israel and have fallen back to spouting mindless jibber jabber devoid of any facts.
 
call it what you want it......... the bloodshed needs to stop...... both sides need to sit down and negotiate

The only way the bloodshed will stop is for Hamas to disarm. Then the Gaza port can be opened and the Palestinians can work on building their own state instead of firing rockets at someone else's.

My guess is that Hamas will refuse to disarm, after awhile it will resume firing rockets, and the whole thing will repeat in a few years. Note that there had never, ever been a month go by without at least a couple of rockets being fired at Israel.

But there is another way, Hamas could disarm, Fatah can take over Gaza and actually use UNRWA building materials for schools and hospitals instead of terrorist tunnels.
 
call it what you want it......... the bloodshed needs to stop...... both sides need to sit down and negotiate

There would have been no Palestinian casualties if Hamas had allowed Israelis to peacefully enter Gaza to destroy the tunnels. Instead Hamas started to shoot the Israelis and the Israelis shot back (which any rational person would do).
 
There would have been no Palestinian casualties if Hamas had allowed Israelis to peacefully enter Gaza to destroy the tunnels. Instead Hamas started to shoot the Israelis and the Israelis shot back (which any rational person would do).

right and a rational person would also know that going in to destroy tunnels withouth permission would be met with force
 
The only way the bloodshed will stop is for Hamas to disarm. Then the Gaza port can be opened and the Palestinians can work on building their own state instead of firing rockets at someone else's.

My guess is that Hamas will refuse to disarm, after awhile it will resume firing rockets, and the whole thing will repeat in a few years. Note that there had never, ever been a month go by without at least a couple of rockets being fired at Israel.

But there is another way, Hamas could disarm, Fatah can take over Gaza and actually use UNRWA building materials for schools and hospitals instead of terrorist tunnels.

sure that is one way but not the only....... I wont play the game of proposing things I am just pointing out that you seem to have a binary view on things if this is your only solutiion
 
You are right. Israel is mostly there. Last I saw, 2/3 of Israelis support a two state peace while just over half of Palestinians do. Unfortunately major Palestinian factions are dead set against accepting a peace that includes Israel existing in any form or even against Jews living in the region. The closest they have come is saying Jews that were there by the end of the Ottoman Empire could stay but not as full citizens.
And there are factions equally extreme on the Israeli side. There are always extremists even in Our Perfect Democracies, but unless we allow conditions of repression, hostility and violent aggression to become the norm, the extremists operate in numbers and levels police can, and mostly do deal with.

The difficulties with partition—two states—as any sort of solution are the same as in Ireland, Yugoslavia, South Africa, Ukraine, and any number of similarly disputed, jointly settled lands: Even if one side is happy with the division, unless the other side is equally so, it will fail. Because if both sides do not turn similar commitment to policing and calming their extremists as they did to prosecuting their war, then the hostilities—and HamasII or IrgunII—will arise anew. Unmtil everyone is happier talking together than fighting, those who always fight first have the edge.

What's needed is Reconciliation between people who must share a small and harsh land, not just dividing lines. But as you say, even that pro tem sort of progress is still distant
 
There would have been no Palestinian casualties if Hamas had allowed Israelis to peacefully enter Gaza to destroy the tunnels. Instead Hamas started to shoot the Israelis and the Israelis shot back (which any rational person would do).
But considering the tunnels were the only way the people of Gaza could avoid the blockade, that was always a fairytale possibility. Much like 'demanding' Hamas fight only from positions free of all civilians. The more effective the prison you make, the more effective and determined you make your prisoners at opposing you.

As we keep hearing in our own relatively tiny context: Some day those prisoners who have been given nothing, except long sentences to learn from each other how to be better criminals will have to be let out.
 
right and a rational person would also know that going in to destroy tunnels withouth permission would be met with force

Are you serious? Israelis need permission to destroy terrorists tunnels that run into their country? :frusty: Stick to massage reviews