How to lobby against C-36 without outing yourself

Allegra Escorts

Supporting Member
Feb 27, 2014
4,089
660
113
There's certainly been lots of talk about how clients can get involved, with plenty of legitimate concern from clients who don't want to disclose the fact that they hobby. Why not change the focus of the discussion - instead of trying to convince MPs that clients deserve the right to purchase sexual services, why not focus on all the other failings of this bill, and use those to lobby against it?

Here are a few examples I came up with, many of which have to do with a darling complaint of the right wing - waste of tax dollars! If you have a Conservative MP, try these arguments:

"It costs over a hundred thousand dollars a year to incarcerate someone - I don't want my tax dollars being spent to imprison anyone who had consensual sex, even if money happened to change hands!"

"Police have better things to do than chase down people purchasing sexual services, let's direct the resources towards more important things!"

"I can think of a lot better uses for that $20 million dollars than anti-sex-work task forces, that's our money you're spending and you could put it to better uses!"

"The Supreme Court already ruled that these laws were unconsitutional, why does the government insist on wasting millions of dollars in court costs? This is just a way to give money to their lawyers to fight a losing battle!"

If you have a Liberal or NDP MP, taking a harm-reduction or personal-freedoms stance might work a bit better:

"Sex workers are people too, and this law makes their lives less safe."

"All Canadians deserve the right to be safe from violence, and this bill does the opposite."

"I am a Canadian who respects the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and I don't respect the Conservative government's blatant disregard for our constitution."

"This law pushes a market underground that is in desperate need of health and safety standards, and is likely to make disease and violence more prevalent"

Last but certainly not least:

"I see no place for the state in the bedrooms of the nation!"

Use this thread to add other arguments that you can use to lobby your MP that don't out you as a client. Public opinion is strongly against this bill, and the right amount of advocacy, written in the right way, might be able to tilt things away from where they are now. Don't just throw up your hands and say you can't do anything about it, make your voices heard if you truly feel that this bill is a bad thing for Canadian society.

~Allegra
 
I suggest people read the "Articles on prostitution related laws, opinions, comments" and print out the article(s) that most resonate with how you feel. Send that article to your MP and just say that you do not support C-36 as per the concerns raised in the article attached.
 
I suggest people read the "Articles on prostitution related laws, opinions, comments" and print out the article(s) that most resonate with how you feel. Send that article to your MP and just say that you do not support C-36 as per the concerns raised in the article attached.

Next election cycle, donate like crazy to anyone who is running against Joy Smith.

Both good ideas!
 
Both Allegra and DigitallyYours make good points.

However, unless somehow I missed when Canada became a police state along the lines of Stalinist Russia or the Third Reich, unless you write "as a Hobbiest/John I object to this proposed legislation" we all have the right to comment in a neutral factual way upon proposed legislation. The government or individual MP's really have better things to do than making a checklist of everyone who has a differing political/legal opinion and presents themselves as a thoughtful commentator rather than a "crazy" who may act out.

For those who do not hold Canadian Nationality this can be a bit more difficult, but if you have Canadian ancestry, or own property in Canada mention those facts which cause you to have an interest in commenting besides being a hobbiest.
 
There's certainly been lots of talk about how clients can get involved, with plenty of legitimate concern from clients who don't want to disclose the fact that they hobby. Why not change the focus of the discussion - instead of trying to convince MPs that clients deserve the right to purchase sexual services, why not focus on all the other failings of this bill, and use those to lobby against it?
. . .
~Allegra

Concrete, practical suggestions. This thread deserves a :thumb:
 
Good stuff.

Nice to read something positive instead of the idiocy and nay-saying we've been treated to.
 
There is a big difference between confessing that you are a client, and leaving people guessing.

"I read that ten percent of men have paid for a sexual service. More if you include those who use strip clubs. I am opposed to any legislation that would criminalize such a large number."

Sure the recipient might wonder, but they can't exactly openly accuse you of being a client, and they aren't going to forward it to you family and friends anyway.
 
unless you write "as a Hobbiest/John I object to this proposed legislation" we all have the right to comment in a neutral factual way upon proposed legislation. The government or individual MP's really have better things to do than making a checklist of everyone who has a differing political/legal opinion and presents themselves as a thoughtful commentator rather than a "crazy" who may act out.

I highlighted the relevant part for ya. It makes all the difference in the world. You may have all the right in the world to comment, but if you simply bang on about how men should be allowed to pay to get their wick dipped, you are not being a "thoughtful commentator". No way, no how. But if you frame the discussion in terms of harms and costs, you may well get their attention.
 
if you simply bang on about how men should be allowed to pay to get their wick dipped, you are not being a "thoughtful commentator". But if you frame the discussion in terms of harms and costs, you may well get their attention.
Amen. (BTW, I think it was me who said the same thing to you... Lol)

How many times does it have to be reiterated? This is not about "johns' rights"; it's about a gov't attempting to legislate morality - whether the 'offensive' activity be prostitution, abortion, same-sex marriage, etc etc etc.
 
The Harper Government has been a persistent failure in the Supreme Court of Canada. Prevent more of the same. Just Say NO to Bill C-36.

Is a government that was opposed by over 60% of voters qualified to write legislation without meaningful consultation? Just Say NO to Bill C-36.