Solution to Bill C-36 Important to read

Advertising wasn't illegal under the previous laws and outcalls were legal. So how could they prohibit NOW from advertising as it didn't break any law .
the issue back then was whether advertisement = soliciting in public place. End result back then was that public space was defined as physical space, rather than internet or papers.
Obviously, all this will be very different under the new law.
 
Write all the letters you want. If the PCs get one, they will know you would not be the type that voted for them anyway. That is how they think. This is gonna be the law. For all of you that voted Conservative, thanks a fucking lot you moronic hypocrites.
 
Write all the letters you want. If the PCs get one, they will know you would not be the type that voted for them anyway. That is how they think. This is gonna be the law. For all of you that voted Conservative, thanks a fucking lot you moronic hypocrites.

What has proven effective in the firearms lobby has been to include the letter with a donation to the party, or even just a promise of a donation, outlining what you expect the party to do to get another donation.

Even enclosing a cheque for just $50 gets you a lot more attention. It will also result in the party contacting you to try and get out your vote, and to solicit more money, at which point you reiterate your demand.

Parties do voter math on the contacts they receive, they know that statistically for every one person who sends an email there may be two more voters who feel strongly who didn't, five for everyone who makes a phone call, ten for everyone who spent money or time on the issue, etc., a donation attaches a much higher multiplier to your letter in their voter models because it signals a deeper and more serious interest.

Of course the time to do this was six months ago, but all the conservatives here dismissed the idea at that time. Still, they may yet be persuaded still to art least water it down with a good effort.
 
Here is a letter I just sent off to my MP, including full name and contact info. That last bit is important. I plan to send a letter to all Calgary MP's then to some Liberal and NDP MP's. I'm considering a letter to the editor of the Calgary Herald but I don't know if I have the balls for that. I'm not naive or delusional enough to think that these letters will change the outcome, I doubt the MP's will even see them, but you never know.

Let me know if my argument doesn't make sense somewhere.

Does anyone have a link to any studies or surveys that can substantiate the claim I made in red below? Or a name/contact that could help? I'll see what I can find tomorrow.

*********************************
The ​Hon. Ted Menzies MP

​I am vehemently opposed to Bill C-36.

First, the bill is a slap in the face of the Supreme Court's Bedford ruling and will almost certainly be struck down by the SC. This has been discussed adequately in the media by sex workers, their representatives and by various media commentators.

More importantly in my view, is simply this: If an adult, being of sound mind, wishes to purchase sex, and another adult, also of sound mind, wishes to sell it to him or her, in a private place, free of coercion, and not harming anyone else or breaking any other laws, then what business is it of the government to intervene? And why are these mutually consenting adults suddenly perpetrators and victims as soon as a transactional element enters into the activity?

Mr. MacKay's bill, and the language used to sell it, is redolent with sanctimony and moral judgment. If all men who hire sex workers are perpetrators of a crime (perverts in Mackay's rhetoric), does it not follow that all women are then victims of a crime? Is it the view of the government that women are not capable of determining whether or not they are being exploited and victimized? This is empirically false, unless you also have the dangerous and contemptuous view that women are victims, even when they claim that they are not. This would essentially be saying that the government does not believe that women have full moral agency. Is this the Government's position? If on the other hand, not all sex workers are being exploited (and therefore victims) then the men who enter into a transaction with these women should not be branded perverts and criminals as they are doing no harm. It is my understanding that sex workers who do NOT feel exploited or victimized by their work are in a large majority in Canada.

Bill C-36 is a morass of logical and moral confusion which ultimately does nothing to increase the safety of sex workers and misguidedly creates victims where there is no exploitation or harm, and criminals where there is no crime.

I urge you to review the need to hurry this legislation through the House - Canadians deserve much better. I have voted Conservative for 20 years. If Bill C-36 is passed, it will be the last time.

Sincerely,
xxxxxxxxxxxxxx


I will write a letter to my MP based along these lines with my personal touch.

Thank you.
 
Write all the letters you want. If the PCs get one, they will know you would not be the type that voted for them anyway. That is how they think. This is gonna be the law. For all of you that voted Conservative, thanks a fucking lot you moronic hypocrites.

That's childish Conservative bashing. It assumes that the Liberals would've done differently if faced with that SCC directive. The hobby or johns (if not sex workers) are not important to mainstream masses. We are a minority segment of society.

It may also be misguided to be a single-issue advocate, however, even if the C's lose, would the Liberals amend the law? By your criticism here, you would say a definite yes, which seems unrealistic.
 
This is related and even a CONServative makes some points which I believe a lot of you would find interest in.

http://globalnews.ca/news/1157113/provinces-divided-on-how-to-handle-bedford-prostitution-ruling/

“Basically what the provinces are doing now, is they’re cherry-picking the Criminal Code. So Canadians need to tell their elected people, keep the laws in place,” said Tory MP Joy Smith, who urged prosecutors in British Columbia to continue prosecuting the crimes.
“That’s a very dangerous precedent to be set.”
 
Write all the letters you want. If the PCs get one, they will know you would not be the type that voted for them anyway. That is how they think. This is gonna be the law. For all of you that voted Conservative, thanks a fucking lot you moronic hypocrites.


I remember a late night commentator once said [think it was Bill Maher] , they claim they have conservative family values, but want the benefits of a liberal dick.

Cons' are the worst breed.
 
People here don't even have the balls to write a letter opposing the bill for fear of being suspected as a John. Never mind actually campaigning on behalf of an accused, let alone willing to be the test case to get the law overturned.

Every one of the internet tough guys here will desperately seek to plea to a lesser offense if ever arrested.

i will sign off with initials and Constituent.
 
This is the second time you have insulted me with this type of defamatory comment or insinuation. These posts by you should be deleted, and you should be banned for this. I will report this to the mods.

I am not insulting you, I am highlighting the consequences of continuing to hobby for all of us once this law goes through.

People seem not to be taking the consequences of a criminal conviction seriously, brushing it off with claims it will be overturned, I am highlighting what the experience will be like if you do get convicted. Even if the law is later overturned, your own conviction will stand unless you have the resources and the nerve to take it to the SCC.

Are you planning to stop hobbying? If not, then having a probation officer becomes a real possibility for any of us who continue.

This is no joke.
 
Last edited:
Even if the law is later overturned, your own conviction will stand unless you have the resources and the nerve to take it to the SCC.
This is what happened to Alan Turing (the inventer of the computer). His conviction was never overturned.
 
That's childish Conservative bashing. It assumes that the Liberals would've done differently if faced with that SCC directive. The hobby or johns (if not sex workers) are not important to mainstream masses. We are a minority segment of society.

It may also be misguided to be a single-issue advocate, however, even if the C's lose, would the Liberals amend the law? By your criticism here, you would say a definite yes, which seems unrealistic.

The Liberals may not change the law and legalize it, but I would be satisfied that Adolf Harper is no longer dictator of this country and we can have a "Canadian" Prime Minister again.
 

I just wanted to tell you what an appropriate name DOGPILE is for you .... that's all :D
Although to pile part is a pantywaist euphemism, and the dog part insults canines.

It's interesting that pile believes "…those three broads" should have just rolled over, accepted their unlawful jail terms and penalties under unconstitutional laws that shouldn't have been on the books in the first place (that is why the SCC voided them) just so he can continue to poon.

What did he offer to do for them?
 
Dogpile is most well known as a compilation of several search engines, but I like the 3rd definition from urban dictionary.

http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Dog+Pile

:thumb:

dogpile
A disagreement on an Internet message board wherein one person says something wrong or offensive, and a large number of people comment in response to tell the person how wrong and/or horrible they are, and continue to disparage the original commenter beyond any reasonable time limit.

People commenting at the same time, without realizing others are jumping on the person as well, do not make a dogpile. The requirement is to join in with an angry group to yell at an easy target, or to get popularity points for being seen to agree with the group. They see that everyone else is doing something, and they copy it.

The original commenter typically does not respond at all, because they are completely overwhelmed or scared off. Once a dogpile has been established, an apology from the original commenter is less likely to be effective.
A dogpile in action

A 10:00 AM: "That song is retarded."

B 10:01 AM: "Um, that's really offensive."

C 10:01 AM: "That's not an okay thing to say."

D 10:02 AM: "Fuck you."

E-Z over the next 12 hours: "FUCK YOU, ASSHOLE."

A: "Sorry, I didn't realize that word was offensive."

12 different people: "Stop trying to backtrack, you piece of shit!"
 
Does the "right to life" per the Charter imply that every person has a right to enjoy a basic human need in a reasonably, expedient way without infringing on anyone else's rights?

If a sex worker is not prohibited from personally soliciting the service to provide for that need, then why should a purchaser be denied?


I looked up Right To Life but that wouldn't apply as a potential argument.

However, the Right To Liberty includes this meaning (from Wiki article): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_Seven_of_the_Canadian_Charter_of_Rights_and_Freedoms#Liberty

However, the right has been extended to include the power to make important personal choices. The court described it as "[touching] the core of what it means to be an autonomous human being blessed with dignity and independence in matters that can be characterized as fundamentally or inherently personal." (R. v. Clay, 2003) That is, the concept extends beyond physical restraint by the government as it goes to the core of the human experience.

Does this right then convey a freedom to choose to engage with another consenting adult and without coercion, for money or other consideration in kind, the provision of sex?
 
I am not insulting you, I am highlighting the consequences of continuing to hobby for all of us once this law goes through.

People seem not to be taking the consequences of a criminal conviction seriously, brushing it off with claims it will be overturned, I am highlighting what the experience will be like if you do get convicted. Even if the law is later overturned, your own conviction will stand unless you have the resources and the nerve to take it to the SCC.

Are you planning to stop hobbying? If not, then having a probation officer becomes a real possibility for any of us who continue.

This is no joke.


Oh now you clarify your previous libelous insults with hyperbole. Very clever. If we weren't using handles, my lawyer would've already sent you a cease and desist letter to your place of residence.


(So other than those engaging with minors, are you saying that the sex offender registry would include a new category for johns labelled as 'perverts'? Is this accurate?)
 
It is not about a single issue but there are lots of issues with this government:

Their repressive undemocratic actions not limited to sex laws but also spying on demonstrations and early closure of debates and their cover ups and scandals and corrupt selfish idiotic politicians. They stole and killed democracy in this country something that millions are fighting to achieve in the rest of the world and thousands giving up their lives to achieve it. We had it already and these reform party ultra right wing dictators took over Canada and killed democracy. The betrayal of the worst kind.


What other issues? There may have been some police improprieties at that G10 (or whatever) Summit, but honestly, many were antagonizers, and I would've thrown them in jail too.

Anyways, I'm upset with this government too, but let's be realistic. We hobbyists are a minor segment of society. Perhaps, many men think like us, but can't express themselves freely. Still, I will write a letter to my local M.P. who happens to be Conservative.
 
It is time to attack bill C-36 for what it is. Part of the Conservative hidden agenda. We have a government that has passed a bill that they know is unconstitutional according to experts. So it will cost the taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars in court expenses over the next few years before it is struck down. Meanwhile many regular people will have a permanent record of conviction or at least an arrest record which stays on your computer file affecting travel. All for simply getting a massage.

The opposition has little hope of winning the next election if they stick to economic issues. But, if they can start telling the public that this is the start of the real hidden agenda coming out(which it is), they could start to have an effect of government popularity with an election coming up next year. How about we write letters to the opposition parties stating this so they can use this real opportunity to make a significant dent in the governments popularity and then perhaps we can get a significantly modified bill that goes after what it should go after....street prostitution. Bills frequently do change and this one can as well.

This is your last chance. Use the power of the people to make the government change its mind about certain aspects of this bill in order to try to preserve what they really want. Another majority. They have been very careful so far not to impose moral laws until now for good reason. It will cost them dearly if people start to believe that there really is a hidden agenda coming out now.

I suggest sending the letters straight to each opposition leader.

Here is a list of MP's addresses.

http://www.parl.gc.ca/Parliamentarians/en/members/addresses

Your fervor is admirable. Thanks ;)

Ok, onto the topic at hand: firstly - there seem to be a large enough handful of socially left-ish leaning politicians in this country to have made Gay marriage legal, something still considered illegal in most parts of the US etc.

Also, though I think Harper and McKay lean in the direction of anti-humanism, I do agree with cracking down on human trafficking, esp for those under 18. However, big however, wtf with the term "offensive?" Archaic and otherwise, there would be some serious hairs to split. Mind you, a bill was recently passed referring to online (sexual) exploitation as "intimate."

I don't think this Bill will ever pass - at least in its current form - if for no other reason than the courts being majorly flooded with so many newly deemed "criminals."