Solution to Bill C-36 Important to read

Czar

Well-known member
Nov 19, 2004
1,314
221
63
It is time to attack bill C-36 for what it is. Part of the Conservative hidden agenda. We have a government that has passed a bill that they know is unconstitutional according to experts. So it will cost the taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars in court expenses over the next few years before it is struck down. Meanwhile many regular people will have a permanent record of conviction or at least an arrest record which stays on your computer file affecting travel. All for simply getting a massage.

The opposition has little hope of winning the next election if they stick to economic issues. But, if they can start telling the public that this is the start of the real hidden agenda coming out(which it is), they could start to have an effect of government popularity with an election coming up next year. How about we write letters to the opposition parties stating this so they can use this real opportunity to make a significant dent in the governments popularity and then perhaps we can get a significantly modified bill that goes after what it should go after....street prostitution. Bills frequently do change and this one can as well.

This is your last chance. Use the power of the people to make the government change its mind about certain aspects of this bill in order to try to preserve what they really want. Another majority. They have been very careful so far not to impose moral laws until now for good reason. It will cost them dearly if people start to believe that there really is a hidden agenda coming out now.

I suggest sending the letters straight to each opposition leader.

Here is a list of MP's addresses.

http://www.parl.gc.ca/Parliamentarians/en/members/addresses
 
I would also strongly urge everyone in a Conservative riding to call their MP and say that you think the bill is too repressive. If enough people call enough ridings, they may water it down.
 
It is time to attack bill C-36 for what it is. Part of the Conservative hidden agenda. We have a government that has passed a bill that they know is unconstitutional according to experts. So it will cost the taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars in court expenses over the next few years before it is struck down. Meanwhile many regular people will have a permanent record of conviction or at least an arrest record which stays on your computer file affecting travel. All for simply getting a massage.

The opposition has little hope of winning the next election if they stick to economic issues. But, if they can start telling the public that this is the start of the real hidden agenda coming out(which it is), they could start to have an effect of government popularity with an election coming up next year. How about we write letters to the opposition parties stating this so they can use this real opportunity to make a significant dent in the governments popularity and then perhaps we can get a significantly modified bill that goes after what it should go after....street prostitution. Bills frequently do change and this one can as well.

This is your last chance. Use the power of the people to make the government change its mind about certain aspects of this bill in order to try to preserve what they really want. Another majority. They have been very careful so far not to impose moral laws until now for good reason. It will cost them dearly if people start to believe that there really is a hidden agenda coming out now.

I suggest sending the letters straight to each opposition leader.

Here is a list of MP's addresses.

http://www.parl.gc.ca/Parliamentarians/en/members/addresses

this is pointless. sorry to be a debbie downer, but the fact is: no "John" will want to criticize this in public.

Peter MacKay made it clear: He's out to stop 'perverts'

anyone who criticizes this bill will be painted with that brush.

It's like the "Patriot Act", the language has already been subverted. Feminist/Religious groups
already have the daggers out and the 'moral high ground'. The media will run stories
portraying everyone who see's hookers as a potential "Robert Pickton".

The worst thing to happen, was for those three broads to fucking 'challenge' the laws
and thus making things worse for everyone else. Their ignorance of how the world
works singlehandedly gave Harper exactly what he needed to appease his base.

Sometimes it's better to NOT ROCK THE BOAT.
 
It is time to attack bill C-36 for what it is. Part of the Conservative hidden agenda. We have a government that has passed a bill that they know is unconstitutional according to experts. So it will cost the taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars in court expenses over the next few years before it is struck down. Meanwhile many regular people will have a permanent record of conviction or at least an arrest record which stays on your computer file affecting travel. All for simply getting a massage.

The opposition has little hope of winning the next election if they stick to economic issues. But, if they can start telling the public that this is the start of the real hidden agenda coming out(which it is), they could start to have an effect of government popularity with an election coming up next year. How about we write letters to the opposition parties stating this so they can use this real opportunity to make a significant dent in the governments popularity and then perhaps we can get a significantly modified bill that goes after what it should go after....street prostitution. Bills frequently do change and this one can as well.

This is your last chance. Use the power of the people to make the government change its mind about certain aspects of this bill in order to try to preserve what they really want. Another majority. They have been very careful so far not to impose moral laws until now for good reason. It will cost them dearly if people start to believe that there really is a hidden agenda coming out now.

I suggest sending the letters straight to each opposition leader.

Here is a list of MP's addresses.

http://www.parl.gc.ca/Parliamentarians/en/members/addresses

and what is the hidden agenda, pray tell?


btw, I'll bet you a jelly donut there is no fucking way more than a handful of people will write their mps. Agency owners and other ppl whose livelihoods are directly affected by this couldn't be bothered to lobby their mps six months ago. I'm so sure that johns on an anonymous review board will now be stung into action.
 
It is time to attack bill C-36 for what it is. Part of the Conservative hidden agenda.

…

http://www.parl.gc.ca/Parliamentarians/en/members/addresses


This is delusional… Even if everyone here wrote it would achieve nothing, the numbers are too small.

Give your head a shake, its not a case of hidden agendas. It was the Bedford ruling that caused this.

Any party in power would have been forced to do the same thing. The truth is NONE of them would have jumped at he chance to make it less restrictive. Its like the abortion issue, gay marriage issue etc. there is no winning political stance with those ones. With prostitution I would say the majority of Canadians are against it on a personal level.

Why can't everyone get it through their heads that johns have no moral status and never have. Yeah, we're fucked and there is nothing we can do about it. The best we can hope for is years away with a challenge to the law in the SCC. That is not a for sure thing. Notice the legislation targets the user not the prostitute. Just about everything the prostitute does is legal. How can the SP challenge something in court that is legal for her to do? It would realistically be the john that would have to make the SCC challenge. How much public support do you think that wanker would get?

Many, myself included, only are on TERB because it is anonymous. If we had to use our real names I wouldn't be here either and TERB would probably not exist. For the same reason a protest by having to put your real name to a letter is also never going to happen.

Smoking weed has a better chance of being decriminalized than prostitution.
 
Maybe the NDP or Liberals would have done this differently. At the very least then, the timing of Bedford was terrible. It should have been done at a time when the government ideology would have been more supportive to relaxing rules.
 
I agree that it was Bedford ruling that caused this but I don't believe or agree that any party would have done the same. The liberals even wanted to decriminalize it back in 2005. I remember because one of the religious fanatics colleagues was very angry one day attacking liberals for that motion. And NDP for sure. None of the other parties would have brought such a repressive regressive laws for sure even if they were going the path of criminalization. Only these idiot perverts who pray in churches (and prey on innocent girls as well) would have brought such laws. Damn reform party members from damn Alberta and Manitoba. Idiots.

Fact is: No party did anything until the SCC ruled on the Bedford challenge. Had the Bedford Troika simply
did not go through with this lawsuit...then Harper would have been two steps behind where He is today. Chances
are Harper wouldn't have bothered period.

We would not be here today if the Bedford group simply kept their damned mouths shut. Now they are
whining about what MacKay did. What did they expect?! They brought a knife to a gunfight!

As for voting NDP/Grits solely on a 'wedge issue' like screwing whores is idiocy.

Harper is doing a good job so far taking care of the big picture, like defence/budgets/etc.
It's the social conservatives that needs to get their asses booted from the party. These bible-bangers
really should go where they belong, the NDP.
 
At the time of a (majority) most right wing government in the history of Canada what did they expect???. When I posted on SP-biased board cerb about bad timing in 2011, same sex workers (and their goody boys) who are posting now on cerb that "it is bad guys, really bad", at that time attacked me for speaking out and ganged up on me like gangsters (the gang of dozen) for telling the truth and pretended that they were offended by my posts (and the usual twisting of what I said by aggressive SPs who wanted everything only their way and shut up others) and eventually lobbied the cerb mod to ban me as I continued to post that a challenge at this time would lead to Nordic style laws in Canada (and that status quo not perfect but is the best we can have under this ultra conservative government) and that was exactly what happened.

That's usually the case. Sorry you had to go through such idiocy.

What Escorts really want is for the government to take over this industry and begin 'price setting'.
Look for prices to skyrocket to $700-1000 an hour, and for anyone who dares charge under that
to be promptly arrested. It's sorta like the taxi industry...completely monopolized.

As of today, the escort industry is the only business where prices have come down, selection has radically improved
and services which were incredibly rare/taboo only a few years ago (BBBJ) is now pretty much a norm.

If you get government involved in this, health practitioners, feminist/activists: Their idea of GFE would be
something akin to that "Show me your tits" scene in Midnight Express.

Make no mistake, we're on our own here guys.. Don't even think for a split second escorts will
help make life easier. Escorts only give a shit about making money, and from
the looks of it..these laws will make it incredibly easy for them to accuse a client of violating this new law.
 
People should write if they want, but the solution to C-36 is probably to get it in the hands of a judge.

The Conservatives have given the Supreme court and all other judges a signal about what they think of them. If I was a judge, I'd be looking for someone to come before me on charges resulting from this bill, and then use the situation to send a message back to the government. This got to the Supremes via lower courts, the law was thrown out in Ontario first, remember?

Though I'm not volunteering for the role....

But Now magazine, and of course the SUN newspaper chain - they're gonna be in there pretty quick, that will probably get the advertising aspect fixed. Then perhaps an Escort agency or two, some johns... every single one of them is going to be an opportunity to whack this thing back.
 
This is complete bullshit. It is 2014 and I'm being told that I can't have sex with a consenting adult for money because she "might" be human trafficked? What percentage of escorts are human trafficked? We already have laws against that. Why curtail the rights of the rest of the johns and escorts to pursue happiness and/or financial enterprise?
Unfortunately half the johns are married, and the other half don't want to stand up and tell the world that they sometimes pay for sex, so we will be restricted by this Victorian moral code just so Harper can play to his religious conservative base. Fuck 'em all! Harper must go.
 
This is complete bullshit. It is 2014 and I'm being told that I can't have sex with a consenting adult for money because she "might" be human trafficked? What percentage of escorts are human trafficked? We already have laws against that. Why curtail the rights of the rest of the johns and escorts to pursue happiness and/or financial enterprise?
Unfortunately half the johns are married, and the other half don't want to stand up and tell the world that they sometimes pay for sex, so we will be restricted by this Victorian moral code just so Harper can play to his religious conservative base. Fuck 'em all! Harper must go.

+1 well put!!!!
 
People should write if they want, but the solution to C-36 is probably to get it in the hands of a judge.

The Conservatives have given the Supreme court and all other judges a signal about what they think of them. If I was a judge, I'd be looking for someone to come before me on charges resulting from this bill, and then use the situation to send a message back to the government. This got to the Supremes via lower courts, the law was thrown out in Ontario first, remember?

Though I'm not volunteering for the role....

But Now magazine, and of course the SUN newspaper chain - they're gonna be in there pretty quick, that will probably get the advertising aspect fixed. Then perhaps an Escort agency or two, some johns... every single one of them is going to be an opportunity to whack this thing back.
NOT LIKELY..... 1) Newspapers will do like in the U.S. .... as Backpages does. Restrict the wording so not clearly selling sexual services. 2) Agencies, escorts ect will do like the past 20 years ....suck up their charges..... do their time & move on. It takes ALOT of money ..... ALOT to challenge to S.C.C. In 20 & it took 20 years for some lawyer to come along to do it. NOT SURE how much money Bedford put into the challenge???
 
how much money Bedford put into the challenge???

$0.00. Alan Young was desperate to make his "reasoned argument" and didn't charge anything. She (and we) definitely got her money's worth from him. Especially when he told the SCC that the government is free to make prostitution illegal.
 
$0.00. Alan Young was desperate to make his "reasoned argument" and didn't charge anything. She (and we) definitely got her money's worth from him. Especially when he told the SCC that the government is free to make prostitution illegal.

I believe there is a lot of misconceptions here. I personally have met and spoken to Alan Young and he is actually a very strong advocate of getting the government to stop legislating morality and focus on more evidenced based decision making. The problem is that currently, it is well within the power of the government to legislate morality to "protect society" as they say. The only reasonable and acceptable argument were the ones he made to the SCC regarding the harm to prostitutes. I believe he is right in saying, there is no constitutional right to sell your body for sex or the right to buy it - the government has the ability to legislate this.
 
It is time to attack bill C-36 for what it is. Part of the Conservative hidden agenda. We have a government that has passed a bill that they know is unconstitutional according to experts. So it will cost the taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars in court expenses over the next few years before it is struck down. Meanwhile many regular people will have a permanent record of conviction or at least an arrest record which stays on your computer file affecting travel. All for simply getting a massage.

The opposition has little hope of winning the next election if they stick to economic issues. But, if they can start telling the public that this is the start of the real hidden agenda coming out(which it is), they could start to have an effect of government popularity with an election coming up next year. How about we write letters to the opposition parties stating this so they can use this real opportunity to make a significant dent in the governments popularity and then perhaps we can get a significantly modified bill that goes after what it should go after....street prostitution. Bills frequently do change and this one can as well.

This is your last chance. Use the power of the people to make the government change its mind about certain aspects of this bill in order to try to preserve what they really want. Another majority. They have been very careful so far not to impose moral laws until now for good reason. It will cost them dearly if people start to believe that there really is a hidden agenda coming out now.

I suggest sending the letters straight to each opposition leader.

Here is a list of MP's addresses.

http://www.parl.gc.ca/Parliamentarians/en/members/addresses

THE BILL HAS NOT BEEN PASSED YET.

this is pointless. sorry to be a debbie downer, but the fact is: no "John" will want to criticize this in public.

Peter MacKay made it clear: He's out to stop 'perverts'

anyone who criticizes this bill will be painted with that brush.

It's like the "Patriot Act", the language has already been subverted. Feminist/Religious groups
already have the daggers out and the 'moral high ground'. The media will run stories
portraying everyone who see's hookers as a potential "Robert Pickton".

The worst thing to happen, was for those three broads to fucking 'challenge' the laws
and thus making things worse for everyone else. Their ignorance of how the world
works singlehandedly gave Harper exactly what he needed to appease his base.

Sometimes it's better to NOT ROCK THE BOAT.

Is it the fault of SP's that johns won't stand up for themselves or there is no constitution right to sex? These ladies, all working ladies, were suppose to keep up with laws that were against their constitutional right so that johns can keep quiet, sit on the sidelines and keep fucking SPs? Is that really what you are saying here?

and what is the hidden agenda, pray tell?


btw, I'll bet you a jelly donut there is no fucking way more than a handful of people will write their mps. Agency owners and other ppl whose livelihoods are directly affected by this couldn't be bothered to lobby their mps six months ago. I'm so sure that johns on an anonymous review board will now be stung into action.

How do you know who lobbied, who wrote letters, who didn't, etc? That is some ESP shit if you know that escorts and agencies owners couldn't be bothered 6 months ago. What is the next winning lotto numbers? I will split the take with you.... I promise

Maybe the NDP or Liberals would have done this differently. At the very least then, the timing of Bedford was terrible. It should have been done at a time when the government ideology would have been more supportive to relaxing rules.
There would still be BS like this regardless of which party was in. The only thing that the timing did was the ruling happening during a majority. We have no way of knowing if this would have still happened in a minority. They can all say they would have voted down the bill all they want now since it is safe to do so, but can you really believe anything that any party says now-a-days.

That's usually the case. Sorry you had to go through such idiocy.

What Escorts really want is for the government to take over this industry and begin 'price setting'.
Look for prices to skyrocket to $700-1000 an hour, and for anyone who dares charge under that
to be promptly arrested. It's sorta like the taxi industry...completely monopolized.

As of today, the escort industry is the only business where prices have come down, selection has radically improved
and services which were incredibly rare/taboo only a few years ago (BBBJ) is now pretty much a norm.

If you get government involved in this, health practitioners, feminist/activists: Their idea of GFE would be
something akin to that "Show me your tits" scene in Midnight Express.

Make no mistake, we're on our own here guys.. Don't even think for a split second escorts will
help make life easier. Escorts only give a shit about making money, and from
the looks of it..these laws will make it incredibly easy for them to accuse a client of violating this new law.

WOW - First, how you can speak on "behalf" of escorts like you know all is beyond me.

Second - the goal of this was never to set rates at such high amounts. If you really think that SPs want the gov't all up in their shit, you are wrong. They don't want that either. You have either spent WAY to much time in the states or you have screw loose somewhere. However, please explain to me why the fuck escorts shouldn't care about money. Everyone cares about money, everyone wants to be paid top dollar for their work, why should escorts be no different? It is because people like you still think that escorts are "beneath" main stream society folk. They are the seedy underbelly people that the world doesn't want to see but only wants to use.

Thankfully, most escorts are NOT the way you present them. Not those that I have met anyway, and most do not want this for their clients. Most will stand up for their clients and why? because most know what is it like to be targeted unfairly.


This is complete bullshit. It is 2014 and I'm being told that I can't have sex with a consenting adult for money because she "might" be human trafficked? What percentage of escorts are human trafficked? We already have laws against that. Why curtail the rights of the rest of the johns and escorts to pursue happiness and/or financial enterprise?
Unfortunately half the johns are married, and the other half don't want to stand up and tell the world that they sometimes pay for sex, so we will be restricted by this Victorian moral code just so Harper can play to his religious conservative base. Fuck 'em all! Harper must go.

I agree. If they would upload the laws they have now, the issue regarding human trafficking would be addressed. There is no need for this bill to be created to address that issue.

My personal thoughts:

I may challenge some people on their posting, but I and many others from the beginning to now have said and I will say again, we did not want Bedford challenging the SCC. We did not want Bedford being the face of the escort industry. Many of us had fought to try and stop this BEFORE it started. We knew they were opening a can of worms. We called all sorts of things for it. Especially being told that were guilty of trying to repress, exploit and further use women, pimp them out, etc. We were worse then others because we were women and we were not standing beside our fellow women. I would have to go back many moons to find the threads but I have posted here about it as well. I called Valerie Scott myself. She would not hear me. Then again she never agreed with anything I said about any other topic related to this industry so it didn't surprise me. Not even things related to their site, their BCL, nothing. The only thing I was ever able to help with regarding these so-called Sex Professionals was to get the names of the ladies who reported the BCL clients off their site. That was back in 2003 maybe.

So there are people in this industry who do not want to see this. Who do not agree nor want clients targeted. Who do not want to jack up rates or fuck anyone over. There are decent people in this industry on both sides of the coin. We tried to fight then, we spoke up all along, what we did, didn't matter and many many clients bashed us for it. Now clients want all of us on the inside of the hobby to stand up for them. AGAIN, and this time it is will be better because why? Because now we are fighting for you when you can't? Because your wife or job or whatever is important to you can't be lost? Now that clients see what we called before it happening. Now that is it not free-reign to get sucked and fucked like they all thought when they supported this?

Ok, I will fight for you, as soon as you are standing beside me in that fight!

Sorry but I am kind of getting sick and tired of the SP bashing like this is their fault. I am kind of getting sick of the woe-is-me-client attitude no that things didn't turn out the way they wanted and I am certainly sick of the lumping everyone into one category. Don't tell me that I didn't do anything. I tried. So did others. We got shit on for it. Sorry you all have to come and join us in this shit pile. Maybe next time think twice before you throw that shovel on shit onto someone else. You may just be burying the wrong person.
 
I called Valerie Scott myself. She would not hear me.

Of course she wouldn't. Her goal was to open a brothel and make $$$. She doesn't care about sex workers. She is no worse off today than she was before.
 
I believe there is a lot of misconceptions here. I personally have met and spoken to Alan Young and he is actually a very strong advocate of getting the government to stop legislating morality and focus on more evidenced based decision making. The problem is that currently, it is well within the power of the government to legislate morality to "protect society" as they say. The only reasonable and acceptable argument were the ones he made to the SCC regarding the harm to prostitutes. I believe he is right in saying, there is no constitutional right to sell your body for sex or the right to buy it - the government has the ability to legislate this.

There is no misconception. Alan Young was very clear in a recent article that: "My role is to make a reasoned argument and if making that argument culminates in more sex workers getting murdered, don't blame me." All Alan Young cares about is the sound of his own voice.
 
Of course she wouldn't. Her goal was to open a brothel and make $$$. She doesn't care about sex workers. She is no worse off today than she was before.

We said that years ago too. No one listened. We were bitchy jealous ugly cunts if I recall the terms correctly. Anyone woman who didn't support the SPOC was considered this and this was before the challenge when there were issues regarding their BCL.
 
Sorry but I am kind of getting sick and tired of the SP bashing like this is their fault. I am kind of getting sick of the woe-is-me-client attitude no that things didn't turn out the way they wanted and I am certainly sick of the lumping everyone into one category. Don't tell me that I didn't do anything. I tried. So did others. We got shit on for it. Sorry you all have to come and join us in this shit pile. Maybe next time think twice before you throw that shovel on shit onto someone else. You may just be burying the wrong person.

You sound like a reasonable person. Unfortunately, under our legal system, people who won't bear the consequences (ie. Alan Young, Valerie Scott, Bedford) can cause havoc for people who will. That's reality. Hopefully, Alan etc. will feel that they have caused enough damage already and leave the scene. However, if they decide to challenge the new law (and they have nothing to lose by doing so), then the next stop on the crazy train is making it illegal for everyone. Personally, I expect Alan Young to be named person of the year by every church group in the country.