Here is a letter I just sent off to my MP, including full name and contact info. That last bit is important. I plan to send a letter to all Calgary MP's then to some Liberal and NDP MP's. I'm considering a letter to the editor of the Calgary Herald but I don't know if I have the balls for that. I'm not naive or delusional enough to think that these letters will change the outcome, I doubt the MP's will even see them, but you never know.
Let me know if my argument doesn't make sense somewhere.
Does anyone have a link to any studies or surveys that can substantiate the claim I made in red below? Or a name/contact that could help? I'll see what I can find tomorrow.
*********************************
The Hon. Ted Menzies MP
I am vehemently opposed to Bill C-36.
First, the bill is a slap in the face of the Supreme Court's Bedford ruling and will almost certainly be struck down by the SC. This has been discussed adequately in the media by sex workers, their representatives and by various media commentators.
More importantly in my view, is simply this: If an adult, being of sound mind, wishes to purchase sex, and another adult, also of sound mind, wishes to sell it to him or her, in a private place, free of coercion, and not harming anyone else or breaking any other laws, then what business is it of the government to intervene? And why are these mutually consenting adults suddenly perpetrators and victims as soon as a transactional element enters into the activity?
Mr. MacKay's bill, and the language used to sell it, is redolent with sanctimony and moral judgment. If all men who hire sex workers are perpetrators of a crime (perverts in Mackay's rhetoric), does it not follow that all women are then victims of a crime? Is it the view of the government that women are not capable of determining whether or not they are being exploited and victimized? This is empirically false, unless you also have the dangerous and contemptuous view that women are victims, even when they claim that they are not. This would essentially be saying that the government does not believe that women have full moral agency. Is this the Government's position? If on the other hand, not all sex workers are being exploited (and therefore victims) then the men who enter into a transaction with these women should not be branded perverts and criminals as they are doing no harm. It is my understanding that sex workers who do NOT feel exploited or victimized by their work are in a large majority in Canada.
Bill C-36 is a morass of logical and moral confusion which ultimately does nothing to increase the safety of sex workers and misguidedly creates victims where there is no exploitation or harm, and criminals where there is no crime.
I urge you to review the need to hurry this legislation through the House - Canadians deserve much better. I have voted Conservative for 20 years. If Bill C-36 is passed, it will be the last time.
Sincerely,
xxxxxxxxxxxxxx