Solution to Bill C-36 Important to read

why are the escort agencies so quiet about this? It seems like it is business as usual for them. They don't seem too worried...

Get while the getting is good - don't panic the customers, when it changes and becomes law then worry about it?
 
but what I don't understand is seeing them crying with joy after the outcome of the trial. The trial has drastically made the situation worse for everyone and they will go down in history for it. Again, I'm not blaming their intentions, I'm just surprised by their positive reaction on video after the trail

You know what the road to hell is paved with right?

When the first batch of arrests begin (shortly)...where 'upstanding' citizens of this country will
suddenly be 'frog marched' out in public for all to see, their lives destroyed. Those accused will
have very few 'friends'.

Nobody here will have the balls to go public and support these newly accused.

We're all just going to let the government do whatever the fuck they want...because we all know
the consequences of going public is simply too much.

Am I wrong?

This is where the anonymity of the internet ends, and reality kicks in. You all can
whine/bitch online nonstop, but that will mean zip unless you are willing to put your face/name/info
on it.
 
You know what the road to hell is paved with right?

When the first batch of arrests begin (shortly)...where 'upstanding' citizens of this country will
suddenly be 'frog marched' out in public for all to see, their lives destroyed. Those accused will
have very few 'friends'.

Nobody here will have the balls to go public and support these newly accused.

We're all just going to let the government do whatever the fuck they want...because we all know
the consequences of going public is simply too much.

Am I wrong?

This is where the anonymity of the internet ends, and reality kicks in. You all can
whine/bitch online nonstop, but that will mean zip unless you are willing to put your face/name/info
on it.

People here don't even have the balls to write a letter opposing the bill for fear of being suspected as a John. Never mind actually campaigning on behalf of an accused, let alone willing to be the test case to get the law overturned.

Every one of the internet tough guys here will desperately seek to plea to a lesser offense if ever arrested.
 
You know what the road to hell is paved with right?

When the first batch of arrests begin (shortly)...where 'upstanding' citizens of this country will
suddenly be 'frog marched' out in public for all to see, their lives destroyed. Those accused will
have very few 'friends'.

Nobody here will have the balls to go public and support these newly accused.

We're all just going to let the government do whatever the fuck they want...because we all know
the consequences of going public is simply too much.

Am I wrong?

This is where the anonymity of the internet ends, and reality kicks in. You all can
whine/bitch online nonstop, but that will mean zip unless you are willing to put your face/name/info
on it.

You are 100% right. As much as the whole thing disgusts and enrages me, I personally would loose more than I would gain. For that reason it is hard to justify being a Martyr just to satisfy my sexual urge.
 
I'm sure they really thought that they had paved the way for decriminalization. Many predicted the opposite and were heavily criticized for it. With 20/20 hindsight they made it worse for all SPs and clients. I don't think that was their goal.
These ladies had no way of knowing the "Blue-eyed Taliban" would have majority control of the House of Commons when they first launched their court challenge.

Guys, it might be time to turn gay. Not speaking from experience, but I heard that an HJ, BBBJCIMSW and anal feels the same even if the partner is a male or trans. LE would never dare raid a bathhouse.
 
If all of this were a chess game, the feds would have called "Check".
There will be some more men taken down (with all the life ruining attachments) during the rest of the game. The game won't be over until "Check-mate" and that lies with the SCC rather far down the road.

What I don't like is how castrated I feel because I'm in no position (risking divorce, criminal records, job loss etc.) to make my voice louder about the matter.

By going after the clients they have turned so many of us into Meatloaf (apologies to Michael Lee Aday)…

"I'd do anything for love (but I won't do that)"
 
NOT LIKELY..... 1) Newspapers will do like in the U.S. .... as Backpages does. Restrict the wording so not clearly selling sexual services. 2) Agencies, escorts ect will do like the past 20 years ....suck up their charges..... do their time & move on. It takes ALOT of money ..... ALOT to challenge to S.C.C. In 20 & it took 20 years for some lawyer to come along to do it. NOT SURE how much money Bedford put into the challenge???

My understanding is that NOW magazine has fought similar battles in the past.

This is likely to be a fight for life for NOW and the Sun papers - they make a SHITLOAD of money through these adds, in a context of generally declining add revenue.

If they don't spend money on this, they won't have any money to spend on anything.
 
Thanks, that was informative. So GPIDEAL won't have to worry about updating his address in the sex offender registry when discussing the unfairness of the law with his future probation officer.

I find the Asian girl in your video clip oddly quite sexy.
 
I find the Asian girl in your video clip oddly quite sexy.

This bill, if it passes, will be challenged and challenged fairly quickly. It won't take years until it gets to the Supreme Court. All it will take is a district court judge to strike the new law down. Also, I don't think any judge would be willing to strike the law down and then give it an extension, not after the Cons snarling response to the SC ruling. If significant changes are not made, it will die fairly quickly.
 
This bill, if it passes, will be challenged and challenged fairly quickly. It won't take years until it gets to the Supreme Court. All it will take is a district court judge to strike the new law down. Also, I don't think any judge would be willing to strike the law down and then give it an extension, not after the Cons snarling response to the SC ruling. If significant changes are not made, it will die fairly quickly.

I guess it depends on what you call quickly. Bedford trial started in 2009 and I don't know how much earlier it was filled before that.
To me that is 5 years to take us to where we are today and it technically is not a law yet. The old laws are still in place until the new one passes. Technically we can still be charged under the old law today (not likely LE would bother).

5 years is not what I call speedy.
 
This bill, if it passes, will be challenged and challenged fairly quickly. It won't take years until it gets to the Supreme Court. All it will take is a district court judge to strike the new law down. Also, I don't think any judge would be willing to strike the law down and then give it an extension, not after the Cons snarling response to the SC ruling. If significant changes are not made, it will die fairly quickly.

If the law is struck down in the courts, the Harperites can say blame prostitution on the courts.

If the law is not struck down, maybe the Harperites can throw you a bone and allow you to choose castration instead of spending 5 years of your life in jail.
 
My understanding is that NOW magazine has fought similar battles in the past.
It did. Summer 1990 - police visited several SPs with warnings, and attempted to prohibit NOW from printing further ads.
As you can see, that did not work.
 
Here is a letter I just sent off to my MP, including full name and contact info. That last bit is important. I plan to send a letter to all Calgary MP's then to some Liberal and NDP MP's. I'm considering a letter to the editor of the Calgary Herald but I don't know if I have the balls for that. I'm not naive or delusional enough to think that these letters will change the outcome, I doubt the MP's will even see them, but you never know.

Let me know if my argument doesn't make sense somewhere.

Does anyone have a link to any studies or surveys that can substantiate the claim I made in red below? Or a name/contact that could help? I'll see what I can find tomorrow.

*********************************
The ​Hon. Ted Menzies MP

​I am vehemently opposed to Bill C-36.

First, the bill is a slap in the face of the Supreme Court's Bedford ruling and will almost certainly be struck down by the SC. This has been discussed adequately in the media by sex workers, their representatives and by various media commentators.

More importantly in my view, is simply this: If an adult, being of sound mind, wishes to purchase sex, and another adult, also of sound mind, wishes to sell it to him or her, in a private place, free of coercion, and not harming anyone else or breaking any other laws, then what business is it of the government to intervene? And why are these mutually consenting adults suddenly perpetrators and victims as soon as a transactional element enters into the activity?

Mr. MacKay's bill, and the language used to sell it, is redolent with sanctimony and moral judgment. If all men who hire sex workers are perpetrators of a crime (perverts in Mackay's rhetoric), does it not follow that all women are then victims of a crime? Is it the view of the government that women are not capable of determining whether or not they are being exploited and victimized? This is empirically false, unless you also have the dangerous and contemptuous view that women are victims, even when they claim that they are not. This would essentially be saying that the government does not believe that women have full moral agency. Is this the Government's position? If on the other hand, not all sex workers are being exploited (and therefore victims) then the men who enter into a transaction with these women should not be branded perverts and criminals as they are doing no harm. It is my understanding that sex workers who do NOT feel exploited or victimized by their work are in a large majority in Canada.

Bill C-36 is a morass of logical and moral confusion which ultimately does nothing to increase the safety of sex workers and misguidedly creates victims where there is no exploitation or harm, and criminals where there is no crime.

I urge you to review the need to hurry this legislation through the House - Canadians deserve much better. I have voted Conservative for 20 years. If Bill C-36 is passed, it will be the last time.

Sincerely,
xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
 
Here is a letter I just sent off to my MP, including full name and contact info. That last bit is important. I plan to send a letter to all Calgary MP's then to some Liberal and NDP MP's. I'm considering a letter to the editor of the Calgary Herald but I don't know if I have the balls for that. I'm not naive or delusional enough to think that these letters will change the outcome, I doubt the MP's will even see them, but you never know.

Let me know if my argument doesn't make sense somewhere.

Does anyone have a link to any studies or surveys that can substantiate the claim I made in red below? Or a name/contact that could help? I'll see what I can find tomorrow.

*********************************
The ​Hon. Ted Menzies MP

​I am vehemently opposed to Bill C-36.

First, the bill is a slap in the face of the Supreme Court's Bedford ruling and will almost certainly be struck down by the SC. This has been discussed adequately in the media by sex workers, their representatives and by various media commentators.

More importantly in my view, is simply this: If an adult, being of sound mind, wishes to purchase sex, and another adult, also of sound mind, wishes to sell it to him or her, in a private place, free of coercion, and not harming anyone else or breaking any other laws, then what business is it of the government to intervene? And why are these mutually consenting adults suddenly perpetrators and victims as soon as a transactional element enters into the activity?

Mr. MacKay's bill, and the language used to sell it, is redolent with sanctimony and moral judgment. If all men who hire sex workers are perpetrators of a crime (perverts in Mackay's rhetoric), does it not follow that all women are then victims of a crime? Is it the view of the government that women are not capable of determining whether or not they are being exploited and victimized? This is empirically false, unless you also have the dangerous and contemptuous view that women are victims, even when they claim that they are not. This would essentially be saying that the government does not believe that women have full moral agency. Is this the Government's position? If on the other hand, not all sex workers are being exploited (and therefore victims) then the men who enter into a transaction with these women should not be branded perverts and criminals as they are doing no harm. It is my understanding that sex workers who do NOT feel exploited or victimized by their work are in a large majority in Canada.

Bill C-36 is a morass of logical and moral confusion which ultimately does nothing to increase the safety of sex workers and misguidedly creates victims where there is no exploitation or harm, and criminals where there is no crime.

I urge you to review the need to hurry this legislation through the House - Canadians deserve much better. I have voted Conservative for 20 years. If Bill C-36 is passed, it will be the last time.

Sincerely,
xxxxxxxxxxxxxx


Good for you.
 
I guess it depends on what you call quickly. Bedford trial started in 2009 and I don't know how much earlier it was filled before that.
To me that is 5 years to take us to where we are today and it technically is not a law yet. The old laws are still in place until the new one passes. Technically we can still be charged under the old law today (not likely LE would bother).

5 years is not what I call speedy.

You can wait 5 years for the bill to be dropped to start pooning again or wait 5 years in prison to start pooning again. Choose lesser of the 2 evils. However, junior can't stay in my pants to long, just a wiff of pussy..... :frusty:
 
I guess it depends on what you call quickly. Bedford trial started in 2009 and I don't know how much earlier it was filled before that. 5 years is not what I call speedy.

Actually 19 or 20 years if you count the one-year stay by SCC.
1994: Arrested for operating a bawdy house.
1999: Convicted
2010: Ontario Superior Court reversed. Justice Susan Himel with a long, very well researched opinion after one year of consideration struck down Canada's prostitution law.

Appealed March 2012 won in Court of Appeals
Appealed Dec 2013 won in SCC
 
Actually 19 or 20 years if you count the one-year stay by SCC.
1994: Arrested for operating a bawdy house.
1999: Convicted
2010: Ontario Superior Court reversed. Justice Susan Himel with a long, very well researched opinion after one year of consideration struck down Canada's prostitution law.

Appealed March 2012 won in Court of Appeals
Appealed Dec 2013 won in SCC

You count funny. Her original conviction stood, and its appeal failed. The 1994 conviction was not the one overturned.

Also, for the OP, appeals to the SCC do not cost hundreds of millions of dollars. Especially for the government.