Bill C-36 How Long Do We Have?

They call it the "Protection of Communities and Exploited Persons Act". What about these sex workers giving up their trade to work at McDonalds or Starbucks for minimum wage to enter the world of corporate slavery, just another form of exploitation IMHO.

Very well said.

There are women in this world that can tolerate being in the profession, and they are compensated well for it and certain risks, yet the state feels that they should not have that right. This must be challenged. Not every escort is exploited.
 
1- What the hell are sexual services? Intercourse only or intercourse and oral only or intercourse oral, kissing only or intercourse oral kissing touching........

It is undefined. The court will have to define this, since the legislators don't seem to be doing this.

2- Okay first part clear but when it says communicating in any place, does that extend to private media like text messages and email? Are they a place?

Technically, 286.1 would make it an offence, for a client to communicate in "any place" for the purposes of obtaining sexual services. So yes, if you are texting in your home, that would count. Unless a court interprets otherwise.

3 - a summary versus indictment - what the hell are they in differences (the latter by grand jury) and Who choses who should get a summary conviction (18 months) or indictment (5 years)

The Crown decides how they wish to proceed. It is their option.
http://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/rp-pr/cj-jp/victim/guide/sech.html
 
Any criminal code conviction is going to be on your record. Whats worse is that in Canada, merely being charged with an offence also goes onto your record. If you were found to be not guilty, or the charges dropped the charge would still show up on your record and potentially affect employment opportunities, travel ,etc.

Bobcat40, I read elsewhere about old offences or charges that were quashed, etc. but that they might still remain to haunt you even if you're acquitted. This is a privacy right issue and should be addressed as well (sorry, can't recall where I saw that but perhaps you can appeal to the Privacy Commissioner).
 
It is undefined. The court will have to define this, since the legislators don't seem to be doing this.



Technically, 286.1 would make it an offence, for a client to communicate in "any place" for the purposes of obtaining sexual services. So yes, if you are texting in your home, that would count. Unless a court interprets otherwise.



The Crown decides how they wish to proceed. It is their option.
http://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/rp-pr/cj-jp/victim/guide/sech.html



My post is not a debate but asking questions about things I don't understand. Now I know why lawyers have to spent years to get a degree!!!
[/QUOTE]


@ Capital Hunter, we don't have Grand Juries in Canada AFAIK. I believe DY answered your question.
 
For me, the issue isn't them finding out, it's the fact that this legislation would brand me a criminal.

Same here... I would be unable to work in my profession with a criminal record, so continuing on with the hobby would be too much of a risk.
 
Well I hope you are right but my understanding is that there will be two parts, the fine part ($500) and the imprisonment part up to 18 months or 5 years (don't know the difference between summary conviction and indictment). I could very well be wrong I know nothing about these mumbo jumbo. Anyhow as I said I think that even the minimum $500 will have a criminal record added for individual which for most of us is the loss of Annual salary for many years (hundreds of thousands of dollars fine) as most of us with criminal records will be fired. Again I do NOT know may be I am wrong. I hope I am. No criminal record for first offence???. Is that what you are saying???



I checked Wikipedia to see what a summary offense is, certainly the impression I get is a first offense will get the lowest fine. Prison time makes sense if they keep catching you, but the first time you're gonna get the minimum, unless there is something really messed up about what they catch you at. If you are caught discretely trying to get paid laid, I think the minimum is what you'll get. If you're propositioning women walking around in the Eaton center, there might be reason to go harsher in the first instance by adding prison time. Maybe.

If I got caught, I'd hang my head, learn my lesson, give up the hobby. But I really doubt I'd ever get caught - I make my arrangements via email which they can't look at without court order (unless I'm acting like a terrorist) and the crime will take place in my home, where they won't have any way of proving it. They're gonna go after the guys who are making a public nuisance of themselves. Or they'll hire hundreds of new LE to chase us all down, because they don't have any other crimes as important as this one to pursue, and there are unlimited funds for Government morality projects like this one.
 
Ok well then we have all summer to poon. Enjoy stress free pooning until the fall or winter.

Well, I'm not sure... James T. Kirk said it would be law before Parliament breaks for the summer, hence my question.
 
It's possible they might offer a diversionary program called "John"s school" like they did with the old "communicating for the purpose" street busts under the old laws for first time offenders. Just speculating though. A criminal record can certainly screw up your life in a various ways.
 
Same here... I would be unable to work in my profession with a criminal record, so continuing on with the hobby would be too much of a risk.

I totally understand these concerns, they just don't apply to me. Sorry, I'm just being a bit of an ass...

When not being an ass, I am totally sympathetic with those who would be royally screwed by a charge. My life is a simple life, and I plan to keep it that way. Others have complicated lives, I understand. I'll go do something else now...
 
It's possible they might offer a diversionary program called "John"s school" like they did with the old "communicating for the purpose" street busts under the old laws for first time offenders. Just speculating though. A criminal record can certainly screw up your life in a various ways.

Oh GOD... John school! That does put the fear in me, I know I'd fail John school. They'd bring in some bitter old hag who fucked up her life and had to hook on the subway, and then got a gig rubbing John's noses in her soiled panties... And I'd have trouble keeping from laughing at her face. I'd fail, and they'd surely put me away for life...
 
Technically, 286.1 would make it an offence, for a client to communicate in "any place" for the purposes of obtaining sexual services. So yes, if you are texting in your home, that would count. Unless a court interprets otherwise.



The Crown decides how they wish to proceed. It is their option.
http://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/rp-pr/cj-jp/victim/guide/sech.html

Under what circumstances can LE get at emails, texts, phone calls? My sense is that they have to have a really good reason, like they suspect terrorist activity... otherwise they need something from a judge. Is it likely a judge would grant this over this kind of "crime?"

Personally, I think chasing after private communications over purchase of sex services would only be a problem in a truly fascist state.
 
The vital question is whether with first offence (of $500) we receive also a record? A criminal record? and from what I understand the answer is yes. For me that is equivalent to a fine of hundreds of thousands of dollars as I will lose my job.

I think you would, but you can ask for a pardon after 5 years... which probably wouldn't help in your case. So yeah, it's rough. You have my sympathy.
 
The vital question is whether with first offence (of $500) we receive also a record? A criminal record? and from what I understand the answer is yes. For me that is equivalent to a fine of hundreds of thousands of dollars as I will lose my job.

If you are convicted, then yes, it goes on your criminal record. It won't be on your criminal record if you are discharged, although the charge will still be there.

In reality, for a first time offender and for a crime like this, you will probably get diversion, which means you get some education and/or do some community service and then the charge is withdrawn. No criminal record.

It's not dissimilar to, for example, if you are charged with a DUI, show remorse and no one else was injured, there's a good chance you would get diverted to get alcohol counseling and then after completing it, the charges would be dropped. If you did it again though, the Crown won't be so nice to you the second time.
 
If you are convicted, then yes, it goes on your criminal record. It won't be on your criminal record if you are discharged, although the charge will still be there.

In reality, for a first time offender and for a crime like this, you will probably get diversion, which means you get some education and/or do some community service and then the charge is withdrawn.

It's not dissimilar to, for example, if you are charged with a DUI, show remorse and no one else was injured, there's a good chance you would get diverted to get alcohol counseling and then after completing it, the charges would be dropped. If you did it again though, then you'd have a problem.

I think that's the way it would go too.
 
Under what circumstances can LE get at emails, texts, phone calls? My sense is that they have to have a really good reason, like they suspect terrorist activity... otherwise they need something from a judge. Is it likely a judge would grant this over this kind of "crime?"

Personally, I think chasing after private communications over purchase of sex services would only be a problem in a truly fascist state.

A judge won't waste his/her time. Nor will the police. In a small town of 1,000 people where judges and cops have nothing to do, maybe, but I don't see it happening in a busy city like Toronto.
 
Under what circumstances can LE get at emails, texts, phone calls? My sense is that they have to have a really good reason, like they suspect terrorist activity... otherwise they need something from a judge. Is it likely a judge would grant this over this kind of "crime?"

Personally, I think chasing after private communications over purchase of sex services would only be a problem in a truly fascist state.

Not sure about the police they probably require a warrant. But crossing the border into Canada the border guards have the right to go through your laptop, phone (you must provide the password) and go through all your emails and messages if they want to….
 
Oh GOD... John school! That does put the fear in me, I know I'd fail John school. They'd bring in some bitter old hag who fucked up her life and had to hook on the subway, and then got a gig rubbing John's noses in her soiled panties... And I'd have trouble keeping from laughing at her face. I'd fail, and they'd surely put me away for life...

I'd fail on purpose just to make a point.

I'd argue with them as to the fallacy of their ways.