Could independent quebec survive

We shouldn't allow "passport Canadians". Either you are one or you are not. Decide and get on with it!
I hear you. I have several friends who are "dual citizens" so I asked my Iranian friend if he is Canadian or Iranian and I asked my French friend if he is Canadian or French?

Question: Can someone also be "dual religious"? For example, can someone be both Jewish and Muslim?
 
No, he couldn't. Canadian criminal law is territorially-based.

"The phrase may also refer to a country's laws extending beyond its boundaries in the sense that they may authorise the courts of that country to enforce their jurisdiction against parties appearing before them in respect of things that they did outside that country. This does not depend on the co-operation of other countries, since the affected people are within the relevant country (or their case is being heard by a court of that country). For example, many countries have laws which give their criminal courts jurisdiction to try prosecutions for piracy or terrorism committed outside their national boundaries. Sometimes such laws only apply to nationals of that country, and sometimes they may apply to anyone."

I seem to vaguely remember Canada prosecuted a Canadian for a crime he committed in Serbia (or thereabouts).
 
I think Quebec is gone. Do not underestimate nationalism.

The most important things for me is two fold. One I should get a tax cut.

Two, work permits, there must be work permits so those unemployed government workers won't flood the job market in Ontario.

If the separtist win the referendum, then the negotiations start for the break up of the county, if the negotiations should bog down, cut them off. Like, who holds all the cards?
 
Quebec can do very well on their own.
 
In a separatist Quebec, are the Montreal Canadians still the Montreal Canadians???


Why haven't they changed that Team name already? She has criticized if not fined Italian restaurants for calling pasta 'pasta'. This is despicable discrimination! (They should put a contract out on her lol).
 
Why haven't they changed that Team name already? She has criticized if not fined Italian restaurants for calling pasta 'pasta'. This is despicable discrimination! (They should put a contract out on her lol).

They have, by stealth. His code name is PKP. The star candidate is causing real trouble in the ranks.
 
Actually, you are thinking of "Equalization Payments", not Transfer Payments.

Equalization payments are essentially Federal Government of Canada Welfare cheques (which by the way, Ontario is now a recipient of, so who are we to talk)

Most Franco Quebecers have no idea that Quebec receives Welfare from the Feds to the tune of 9.5 billion a year, plus another 7 or 8 billion in nonrelated funding. In total, Quebec receives about 17 billion more from Canada than it pays in to the Federal Government. But again, 95% of Franco Quebecers do not know this, nor is it even published in the French media. They truly believe that they are net payers and that they would be better off by separting.

I refer to equalization as a subset of the transfer payments and one of the major transfer payments, next to health and welfare. Quebec would not get any of the transfer payments, including equalization.......they're on their own.

Still hard to fathom that Ontario is now a have not province and Newfoundland is a have province......

The lifestyle in Quebec will change drastically if they separate, taxes up, services down, and a lot of civil unrest.
 
I refer to equalization as a subset of the transfer payments and one of the major transfer payments, next to health and welfare. Quebec would not get any of the transfer payments, including equalization.......they're on their own.

Still hard to fathom that Ontario is now a have not province and Newfoundland is a have province......

The lifestyle in Quebec will change drastically if they separate, taxes up, services down, and a lot of civil unrest.

Exactly.

The lifestyle of everyone except the Politcos.

The Quebec economy would be HAMMERED. There would be incredible political unrest. Partition of Quebec is a very likely outcome (whether the Separatists want to talk about it or not). The only part of Quebec that generates wealth is Montreal, and Montreal would be either decimated by brain drain as skilled professionals flee in unheard of numbers to Toronto leaving the city dead in the water for decades, or would vote for remaining in Canada (along with the Ottawa River Valley and the vast northland) causing huge political turmoil and still resulting in brain drain. Major corporations currently headquartered in Montreal (Canadian National Railways, Bell Canada, Bombardier, Royal Bank of Canada) would all pack up and leave.

The resulting devastation to the Quebec tax payer base would be catastrophic.

Add to that the loss of about 20 billion dollars that the Feds currently shower on Quebec and it would be impossible for Quebec to continue as it currently exists.

There would need to be massive cuts to government spending because the Quebec government simply will not have the cash, nor will they be able to borrow any either unless they want to pay loan shark interest rates.

But through it all, I can just imagine that what little money was available would still flow to the likes of Pauline Marois and her merry band of bigots and egg heads. You can count on that.
 
Actually the economy of Quebec has already been hammered. The businesses that were going to leave because of secession already did, after the last close call.

Quebec benefits from free trade within Canada, from equalization, from sharing costs like defense, and from being part of a confederation that promotes its interests across the country and internationally.

Relations between Ontario and Quebec at a personal and business level must have improved as a result of official bilingualism, even people who never did master French must have a more positive view of French culture for having studied it. Less xenophobia at the very least.

So I think Quebec gains a lot by being part of Canada, but they would do OK on their own. Just not as well as together with the rest of us.
 
Would quebec leave with all its current territory or would large chunks remain in Canada especially if the aboriginal population does not want to leave Canada.
If the province still wants to use canadian dollar as its currency, would Canada agree to that.

I dont understand why the politicians keep the issue of separation alive because if it happens separation would be so messy for both sides.
 
Thanks for today's laugh. Had a good chuckle...

Agreed, Quebec is a have not province, a heavily subsidized basketcase of a place on steroids from Ottawa. Do a reality check and confront issues such as massive aboriginal land claims, the St Lawrence Seaway which is partly American owned, the Federal Highways and railway system just to name a few. The IMF would not likely even finance the imminent bail out of a sovereign Quebec. Marois is a clown and a dangerous and opportunistic one one, bringing more uncertainty and delusions of grandeur at a very difficult time for many international economies.
 
I don't think the PQ truly want to leave Canada , l as a political entity is really all they have , if they were to get independence, the people of Quebec would tire of them soon enough and another party will come to power.

As for them not allowing us to use their airspace, well Canada could do the same to them.