Could independent quebec survive

alex52

New member
Jul 6, 2007
1,166
0
0
The perennial quebec independence referendum is looming once again. I hope they decide to leave so Canada can move on.
But my feeling is that this issue will never be resolved, and canada will limp along with this dysfunctional provence.
 
Quebec will become a third world country unless they get financial support from another country, either France or US. France is broke and has their own ugly issues, the US is broke on paper but really not, but I don't think they'll do it as the kettle doesn't want to call the pot black. Russia will milk that for all its worth if the US does.

Those from Quebec must not be too smart since they don't realize that Quebec has been a have not province as long as I can remember and the have provinces have been supporting their lifestyle for decades. Transfer payments always favoured Quebec, they are fools if they think they can survive economically on their own.
 
The perennial quebec independence referendum is looming once again. I hope they decide to leave so Canada can move on.
But my feeling is that this issue will never be resolved, and canada will limp along with this dysfunctional provence.

It will never be resolved if canadians don't grow up and enter into a positive and helpful dialog with Quebec about soverignty. Clearly, everybody agrees that Quebecers are a separate peoples from the english speaking canadians, and as all other peoples deserve to have their own country. The rest of Canada would gain greatness if it helped the quebecers achieve their dream.
 
It will never be resolved if canadians don't grow up and enter into a positive and helpful dialog with Quebec about soverignty. Clearly, everybody agrees that Quebecers are a separate peoples from the english speaking canadians, and as all other peoples deserve to have their own country. The rest of Canada would gain greatness if it helped the quebecers achieve their dream.

Ok but pay back any federal debt, compensate for federal assets or facilities including the military, and no more transfer payments.

Seriously though, why do they have to separate? Canadians already recognize a distinctness in their society. Is it so that they can discriminate in favour of their 'culture'? Maybe Quebec has to grow up?
 
It will never be resolved if canadians don't grow up and enter into a positive and helpful dialog with Quebec about soverignty. Clearly, everybody agrees that Quebecers are a separate peoples from the english speaking canadians, and as all other peoples deserve to have their own country. The rest of Canada would gain greatness if it helped the quebecers achieve their dream.

Hmmm, you're a Canadian. Do you count yourself among those who need to grow up? Everyone doesn't consider Quebecers any more unique than Newfies, Prairie folks, or Natives. At least Newfs know when they have good thing going.
 
It will never be resolved if canadians don't grow up and enter into a positive and helpful dialog with Quebec about soverignty. Clearly, everybody agrees that Quebecers are a separate peoples from the english speaking canadians, and as all other peoples deserve to have their own country. The rest of Canada would gain greatness if it helped the quebecers achieve their dream.

I agree.

I think if Madam Marois holds another referendum, on that same day, we should have a referendum in "the Rest of Canada" as they say on whether or not to kick out Quebec from Confederation.

I think you might be amazed, but the RoC would tell Quebec to leave already and go it alone.

Pretty much everyone I know is sick and tired of Quebec's belly-aching on this already.

It's a win win situation right.
 
Quebec will become a third world country unless they get financial support from another country, either France or US. France is broke and has their own ugly issues, the US is broke on paper but really not, but I don't think they'll do it as the kettle doesn't want to call the pot black. Russia will milk that for all its worth if the US does.

Those from Quebec must not be too smart since they don't realize that Quebec has been a have not province as long as I can remember and the have provinces have been supporting their lifestyle for decades. Transfer payments always favoured Quebec, they are fools if they think they can survive economically on their own.

Actually, you are thinking of "Equalization Payments", not Transfer Payments.

Equalization payments are essentially Federal Government of Canada Welfare cheques (which by the way, Ontario is now a recipient of, so who are we to talk)

Most Franco Quebecers have no idea that Quebec receives Welfare from the Feds to the tune of 9.5 billion a year, plus another 7 or 8 billion in nonrelated funding. In total, Quebec receives about 17 billion more from Canada than it pays in to the Federal Government. But again, 95% of Franco Quebecers do not know this, nor is it even published in the French media. They truly believe that they are net payers and that they would be better off by separting.
 
It's a French thing to be unhappy with the oppressive government that puts bread on your table. We're just lucky they are not acting up like in Corsica or Brittany.

I do not wish to see an independent Quebec as I believe it will undermine our Canadian values and show the world that despite all our efforts we were not able to find a compromise amongst ourselves. What's next… Independent BC, Ontario, Alberta?

To the OP's question, I think they'll survive. I don't think they can thrive.
 
I am sure it could survive. The real question is what it would look like. Chance are not very good. at some point it would be seeking some kind of economic union with the US which would be far worse then what they have today as a part of Canada.
 
The only way they could win an independence vote would be if the definition of independence were diluted to the point of meaninglessness. Their concept of nationhood defined by language and ethnic homogeneity is a throwback to the nineteenth century. If French Canadians have fewer babies over the long-term and non-French immigration into the province makes the French a minority in their own province, then eventually there is no "French Canada". This will happen. A referendum can't stop it.
 
I agree.

I think if Madam Marois holds another referendum, on that same day, we should have a referendum in "the Rest of Canada" as they say on whether or not to kick out Quebec from Confederation.

I think you might be amazed, but the RoC would tell Quebec to leave already and go it alone.

Pretty much everyone I know is sick and tired of Quebec's belly-aching on this already.

It's a win win situation right.


Ok but we will deduct the value of any Federal assets in Quebec from pending equalization/transfer payments should separation occur. Do they owe the Feds anything? What about their share of the Federal debt? Fuck them if they don't pay, we blockade their ports.
 
It can be done...but then Quebecers will just start migrating to Canada, get their citizenship..sponsor families. Then Canada will just re-acquire that lump of land beside Ottawa and name it Province of Quebec...where Quebecers came from....
 
It can be done...but then Quebecers will just start migrating to Canada, get their citizenship..sponsor families. Then Canada will just re-acquire that lump of land beside Ottawa and name it Province of Quebec...where Quebecers came from....

Quebec will lose its best and brightest to Canada and elsewhere.
 
.... They truly believe that they are net payers and that they would be better off by separting.

This statement is sad and very true. The PQ'ist and the french media propaganda machine does an excellent job of snowing the average Quebecer. Many, many Quebecer's believe they are net contributors to Canada and are tired of supporting "Les Anglais".

Quebec law requires its citizens to file a seperate tax return and Quebec business's to issue the Releve 1 (Quebec's version of the T4) to its employees. You would be utterly shocked if you knew how many of the average Quebecer's believe if they seperate, they would no longer have to pay federal income tax, the Quebec rate would stay about the same, and they personally would have all this extra money in their pockets. Of course this isn't anywhere near true, but the it is what is believed by many of them.

To get back to OP's question, they are already hinting they would prefer to use the Canadian dollar as currcency, not have border patrol with Ontario / New Brunswick, and continue close economic ties with the rest of Canada. So lots to work-out before they would even have a small chance.

The other point that needs to be addressed, is if they do win a referendum, and attempt to negotiate sovereignty, what part of the province does this include or do the seperatists represent? If Canada is divisible, surely Quebec is.

Do we go back to the 1867 borders when Canada became a country? They get back Lower Canada that became the province Quebec.

What about the island of Montreal? The Gazette has already floated the idea of Monteal being a city-province inside Canada.

Watch how quickly the city of Gatineau asks to become part of Ottawa.

And we haven't even begone to discuss how the Indians are going to react...
 
When it comes too carving up Quebec, Indigenous people will take over a third of the province. Thats what shut them up in the last refferndum!
51% of the English speaking want too leave. McGill Degrees will become invalid outside of the province. They want Canadian currency, Quebec Hydro.

Plains of Abraham, English won, French were allowed to stay, or leave. They are babbling idiots stuck with a dieing language.