Global Warming. Fact or grossly exaggerated??

Whats your opinion on global warming?

  • Its too late! We're all gonne bake, frie and die in a few years

    Votes: 44 30.1%
  • Its not as bad as scientists say. We got at least 100 to 200 years before shit hits the fan

    Votes: 33 22.6%
  • Its not real at all. Its a carbon credit money making scam

    Votes: 45 30.8%
  • Its all a big conspiracy MAN!!!

    Votes: 9 6.2%
  • Its way too cold in Canada, I wish it were real. Start up the SUV's

    Votes: 15 10.3%

  • Total voters
    146
  • Poll closed .
At least you're starting to realize that you're not that smart.
Now if you could make the next, and very tricky, step in the logic and realize that you'e not smart enough to judge whose research is real and whose is just lobbying
And apparently you were not smart enough to catch sarcasm.

Now are you gonna explain to us what precisely that footnote means so I can double-check it with IPCC. And no, we dont want it some time in the future, we want it today
 
I was making the guess, not accusing you.

Sorry about that. I misunderstood.

And no, we dont want it some time in the future, we want it today

That's not fair. Groggy won't be able to give you the phony excuses -- oop, I mean the technical explanations -- until Dana Nuccitelli or someone else at Skeptical Science has written them for him.

And if history is any guide, the "adjustments" to the predictions will only be made sometime after the results are known.
 
And apparently you were not smart enough to catch sarcasm.

Now are you gonna explain to us what precisely that footnote means so I can double-check it with IPCC. And no, we dont want it some time in the future, we want it today


If you like, I can point you to some courses and sites where you can learn enough of the basic science to understand that footnote, but no, I won't do that work for you.
Its an excellent reminder that you still think you're smart enough to judge the science yet clearly can't understand it.

I just read a new study that makes the footnote very relevant. The bet is on and I've won, though we'll have to wait until the due date to confirm.
 
If you like, I can point you to some courses and sites where you can learn enough of the basic science to understand that footnote, but no, I won't do that work for you.
Its an excellent reminder that you still think you're smart enough to judge the science yet clearly can't understand it.

I just read a new study that makes the footnote very relevant. The bet is on and I've won, though we'll have to wait until the due date to confirm
No groggy. No courses, no copy/pastas, no bullshit!

Explain to us exactly in your own words what the footnote means, and how it relates to the 0.2 degree increase in temperature the IPCC has predicted. If you can't do it in your next post we're gonna assume you're completely full of shit and we'll move on
 
Sorry about that. I misunderstood.



That's not fair. Groggy won't be able to give you the phony excuses -- oop, I mean the technical explanations -- until Dana Nuccitelli or someone else at Skeptical Science has written them for him.

And if history is any guide, the "adjustments" to the predictions will only be made sometime after the results are known.

No 'adjustments' are necessary. The prediction is quite good, considering that 2013 was the 4th warmest year according some measurements, and the relevance of a study just out with the details in the footnote.


By the way, was just reading a bit more about the Heartland Institute. They worked very hard for the tobacco industry, trying to lobby that tobacco was good for you, until that fell apart in large court cases against the tobacco industry. They've received about $15 million from Exxon and its ilk to continue spouting bullshit, including giving $90k to bullshitter Wattsupwiththat.

Skeptical Science is meanwhile trying to figure out who was funding the hacks on them. Same thing and same modus as the hacks on Mann et al. Sounds like the tobacco lobbyists that Exxon has hired, and who you like to quote, are also quite likely supporting hackers.

The people you keep quoting are really very dodgy, its just too bad you'e not smart enough to understand that.
 
Now, you're claiming you can see into the future?

No, I just need to look at the IPCC projections, read some new studies and refer to the footnote.
I can give you the same links to the same material, but what's the use, you won't understand it.
 
No groggy. No courses, no copy/pastas, no bullshit!

Explain to us exactly in your own words what the footnote means, and how it relates to the 0.2 degree increase in temperature the IPCC has predicted. If you can't do it in your next post we're gonna assume you're completely full of shit and we'll move on


Look, I'm really sorry that you aren't smart enough to understand the footnote or the science, but face it.
You are not smart enough to win this argument.

I have no need to explain to you why you're losing the bet until the bet is due, unless you're willing to concede it now and buy the book of my choice.
I'll repeat my offer, I'll explain the footnote to you if you concede you aren't smart enough to understand it and that you've lost the bet.

Fair?
 
I'll repeat my offer, I'll explain the footnote to you if you concede you aren't smart enough to understand it and that you've lost the bet.

The terms of the bet were set by me. I hope you're smart enough to realize that any changes to terms or meaning of the bet have to be approved by me.
 
There's no evidence that Mann and company's emails were "hacked."

Sure there is:
The Climatic Research Unit email controversy (also known as "Climategate")[2][3] began in November 2009 with the hacking of a server at the Climatic Research Unit (CRU) at the University of East Anglia (UEA) by an external attacker.[4][5] Several weeks before the Copenhagen Summit on climate change, an unknown individual or group breached CRU's server and copied thousands of emails and computer files to various locations on the Internet.
...
Norfolk Police later added that the offenders used methods that are common in unlawful internet activity, designed to obstruct later enquiries
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climatic_Research_Unit_email_controversy


You are supporting hackers, tobacco lobbyists and Exxon.
And you don't understand the science.
 
Sure there is:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climatic_Research_Unit_email_controversy


You are supporting hackers, tobacco lobbyists and Exxon.
And you don't understand the science.

I stand corrected. I have withdrawn my comments about the hacking.

In the same vein, you should withdraw your comments about Michael Mann being a "scientist."

By the way, you can drop the Big Oil allegations. I'm already on record -- including comments posted in this thread -- as saying that I have no objections to reducing our use of oil through other means such as gas and nuclear. Provided that the alternatives make sense, I'm fine with exploring alternatives.

My focus is solely on good science. I don't believe it's legitimate to promote dubious theories, regardless of the motives.

Indeed, it's worth asking -- why do the IPCC reports include a "Summary for Policy Makers"?

Science isn't about informing "policy", it's about uncovering the truths about our world -- regardless of how that affects policy. Indeed, the Summary for Policy Makers means the IPCC's reports can't be viewed as scientific findings.
 
Look, I'm really sorry that you aren't smart enough to understand the footnote or the science, but face it.
You are not smart enough to win this argument.

I have no need to explain to you why you're losing the bet until the bet is due, unless you're willing to concede it now and buy the book of my choice.
I'll repeat my offer, I'll explain the footnote to you if you concede you aren't smart enough to understand it and that you've lost the bet.

Fair?
Thats what I thought, you're full of shit!!

Whats even worse groggy is that you're lying to yourself when you *claim* to understand that footnote.

If you're gonna lie to yourself about that, and about making a simple little bet online, what else are you lying to yourself about??!!
 
drop the Big Oil allegations.

The "science" claiming to debunk global warming is clearly funded by Big Oil, and you have clearly taken many of your talking points from Big Oil propaganda groups.

Meanwhile it is quite balmy in the arctic this winter.
 
I think you'd have to be an idiot to deny global warming. Ocean temperatures are the biggest indicators we have and they're skyrocketing. The big question is did we cause it or is it part of a cycle. That's where the debates come in.

However, no matter how you slice it, I think we can all agree that pollution is bad, and whether we're causing the accelerated arrival of the next ice age or not, we should probably cut back.
 
The "science" claiming to debunk global warming is clearly funded by Big Oil, and you have clearly taken many of your talking points from Big Oil propaganda groups.

I never said the theory had been debunked. I said the reality is that we don't know what is happening and whether man-made carbon dioxide emissions affect the climate. There have been many skeptics over the years (Michael Crichton and George Carlin were two obvious examples) who weren't influenced by Big Oil.

In fact, I have cited a number of sources, including primary-source documents from the IPCC.

The champions of the theory have made a number of predictions that have been spectacularly wrong. You don't have to be influenced by Big Oil to realize there is a problem with the computer-model predictions.

If the predictions had been right, that would be a different matter. But they weren't.
 
The big question is did we cause it or is it part of a cycle. That's where the debates come in.

True.

When people talk about global warming, they really mean anthropogenic global warming (the theory that man-made carbon dioxide emissions are causing the planet to get warmer). No one disputes that the climate changes and will continue to change.
 
I think you'd have to be an idiot to deny global warming. Ocean temperatures are the biggest indicators we have and they're skyrocketing. The big question is did we cause it or is it part of a cycle. That's where the debates come in.

However, no matter how you slice it, I think we can all agree that pollution is bad, and whether we're causing the accelerated arrival of the next ice age or not, we should probably cut back
I agree on all accounts, except where I dont agree on is how fast earth is warming. Thats why I voted #2.

And yup, pollution is bad and we gotta get off oil anyways because its gonna run out one of these days
 
My focus is solely on good science. I don't believe it's legitimate to promote dubious theories, regardless of the motives.

Indeed, it's worth asking -- why do the IPCC reports include a "Summary for Policy Makers"?

Science isn't about informing "policy", it's about uncovering the truths about our world -- regardless of how that affects policy. Indeed, the Summary for Policy Makers means the IPCC's reports can't be viewed as scientific findings.

The summary's are of the science and not policy itself. They just put the most important points in place so that policy makers can decide how to proceed.
But if you're really interested in supporting good science (which you've already shown yourself unable to judge), why do you discard the findings of 97% of the scientists who work in the field in favour of people who have no counter theory that holds water?