Global Warming. Fact or grossly exaggerated??

Whats your opinion on global warming?

  • Its too late! We're all gonne bake, frie and die in a few years

    Votes: 44 30.1%
  • Its not as bad as scientists say. We got at least 100 to 200 years before shit hits the fan

    Votes: 33 22.6%
  • Its not real at all. Its a carbon credit money making scam

    Votes: 45 30.8%
  • Its all a big conspiracy MAN!!!

    Votes: 9 6.2%
  • Its way too cold in Canada, I wish it were real. Start up the SUV's

    Votes: 15 10.3%

  • Total voters
    146
  • Poll closed .
The basic science, CO2 and other gases cause the greenhouse effect, has been known for a century....

"Known for a century"? You gotta wonder why Mann had to use tree-ring data to get pre-1961 results if that's the case. :biggrin1:

From my viewpoint he knows a lot about this topic, so isn't as stupid as you claim and about the scientific method which clearly others don't.

For a guy who claims to know a lot about "the science" and says he has read the IPCC reports in detail, he sure spends a lot of time citing propaganda websites.

Let's review how he has responded to the "pause" and the huge problems with the IPCC's predictions:

1) He argues a "decade" is 20 years.

2) He says he has found something in "footnotes" that will presumably say something Earth shattering about the IPCC's predictions, but repeatedly refuses to tell us what that is. Nah-nah-na-nah-nah.

3) He argues that bogus claims of a "consensus" are more important than real evidence. Apparently, any person who ever preferred real evidence, such as Albert Einstein, must have been "stupid" and anti-science.

4) He says that AK-47, MF-2 and anyone else who disagrees with him are poo-poo heads.

Not exactly the most technical argument in the world, but there it is.

top10_pause_explanations.jpg
 
"Known for a century"? You gotta wonder why Mann had to use tree-ring data to get pre-1961 results if that's the case. :biggrin1:

You could read Mann to find out, he's quite clear on the matter.
Of course it might be too hard for you.



Let's review how he has responded to the "pause" and the huge problems with the IPCC's predictions:

1) He argues a "decade" is 20 years.

False, you said you were interested in betting on a 20 year prediction, based on the decade average and half way through the period of their prediction.
Different thing entirely, but you may not be able to understand the difference.

2) He says he has found something in "footnotes" that will presumably say something Earth shattering about the IPCC's predictions, but repeatedly refuses to tell us what that is. Nah-nah-na-nah-nah.
And I posted it right here so you could read it twice. It was right there.
Sorry you're too stupid to understand it.
But it does show that you aren't smart enough to follow the real arguments.

3) He argues that bogus claims of a "consensus" are more important than real evidence. Apparently, any person who ever preferred real evidence, such as Albert Einstein, must have been "stupid" and anti-science.
False, never said such a thing at all.
In fact I said consensus was important in climatology in order to make sense of the vast array of different sets of evidence. All of it real.

4) He says that AK-47, MF-2 and anyone else who disagrees with him are poo-poo heads.
No, I just think you're stupid.
Not exactly the most technical argument in the world, but there it is.
Exactly, you aren't smart enough to follow the technical arguments, all you can do is parrot lobbyist talking points.
 
I'm sure it was all spelled out in the acceptance speech for his fake Nobel Peace Prize.

http://www.skepticink.com/prussian/2014/02/28/mann-overboard/

You have focused on Mann as if he is the only scientist doing research on GW. News, he's not. He's only one of a couple of thousands. Shall we compare him with one of the more famous skeptics and vocal critics Bjørn Lomborg. who from the standpoint of lies, misrepresentations, and errors, make Mann slips look like kids play, yet people live on his every word.
 
You have focused on Mann as if he is the only scientist doing research on GW. News, he's not.

He's not the only one, but he's one of the leading researchers and one of the most prominent ones (op-eds in the New York Times, fawning coverage elsewhere, etc.). And the small handful of other top guys in the field (the ones who ultimately call many of the shots on IPCC recommendations, etc.) are mostly all friends of his.

Well, maybe all but one. In spite of the unsubstantiated claims that the Climategate emails were "hacked" and "stolen", what's more likely is that they were leaked by someone who didn't like what was going on.

In any event, Mann's hockey stick graph was central to the IPCC's third assessment report in 2001 (Mann was the lead author on one of the key chapters) and his graph has been at the heart of the IPCC's assertions that there is allegedly something unprecedented about recent warming patterns.

Mann is also a co-founder of RealClimate.org, one of the websites that is regularly cited by the believers.

Most importantly, Mann is a great example of what is wrong with so much of the climate research. He has compromised any attempt at scientific objectivity by being militantly political (as have others, such as James Hansen). Even worse, he has refused to make his methodology and data available -- a contradiction of everything that good science should be about.

It's fine for people on TERB to disown him. But why aren't more climate researchers doing it?
 
He's not the only one, but he's one of the leading researchers and one of the most prominent ones (op-eds in the New York Times, fawning coverage elsewhere, etc.). And the small handful of other top guys in the field (the ones who ultimately call many of the shots on IPCC recommendations, etc.) are all friends of his.

Well, maybe all but one. In spite of the unsubstantiated claims that the Climategate emails were "hacked" and "stolen", what's more likely is that they were leaked by someone who didn't like what was going on.

In any event, Mann's hockey stick graph was central to the IPCC's third assessment report in 2001 and has been at the heart of the IPCC's assertions that there is allegedly something unprecedented about recent warming patterns.

Mann is also a great example of what is wrong with so much of the climate research. He has compromised any attempt at objectivity by being militantly political (as have others, such as James Hansen). Even worse, he has refused to make his methodology and data available -- a contradiction of everything that good science should be about.

It's fine for people on TERB to disown him. But why aren't more climate researchers doing it?

Talk about guessing based on no facts.

The hockey stick graph is one factor/aspect in pages of research and reports based on facts going back pretty much hundreds, if not thousands of years. Then again some on here are basing a good chunk of their argument on a 15/16 year anomaly and a 1922 report on a singular event. As for the scientists not condemning Mann, maybe they know more than you do, just a guess.

Let me know when you want to talk about the famous Skeptical Environmentalist, Bjørn Lomborg, one of the prominent, leading and loudest deniers..
 
As for the scientists not condemning Mann, maybe they know more than you do, just a guess.

I'm not guessing. Mann was the lead author of the Observed Climate Variability and Change chapter in the IPCC's 2001 report, and his hockey stick graph was central to the findings in the Summary for Policy Makers.

Regarding your suggestion that climate researchers are prepared to defend Mann ... well, that may be so. They do it at their own peril, as Mann's work has been thoroughly discredited (and we already know what happened to the IPCC predictions that were based on Mann's work. I'm sure you recall the discussion about the IPCC's predictions being "spectacularly wrong").

As for Lomborg, I'm not all that familiar with the debates about him. But I don't need Lomborg to defend my views. The real-world evidence speaks clearly (and loudly) for itself.
 
Still waiting for groggy to explain that footnote to all us less intelligent lower lifeforms :happy:
 
I'm not guessing. Mann was the lead author of the Observed Climate Variability and Change chapter in the IPCC's 2001 report, and his hockey stick graph was central to the findings in the Summary for Policy Makers.

Regarding your suggestion that climate researchers are prepared to defend Mann ... well, that may be so. They do it at their own peril, as Mann's work has been thoroughly discredited (and we already know what happened to the IPCC predictions that were based on Mann's work. I'm sure you recall the discussion about the IPCC's predictions being "spectacularly wrong").

As for Lomborg, I'm not all that familiar with the debates about him. But I don't need Lomborg to defend my views. The real-world evidence speaks clearly (and loudly) for itself.

I was making the guess, no accusing you.

As for Lomberg, you might want to look into him before you accuse others of being phoneys. I'll give you a start;

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bjorn_Lomborg

AR4 is old news, 2007, almost ancient in scientific circles. AR5 is due later this year, authored by over 800 climate scientists, most if not all of whom you would not be familiar with, but who have more credibility than you and other armchair generals like AK AND Lomberg, using updated data from projects like the Coupled Model Inter-comparison Project (CMIP) and the Common Metadata for Climate Modelling Digital Repositories (METAFOR) which is and extension of CLIVAR and the Joint Scientific Committee for the World Climate Research Program. Man is not the only player in the game, nor the latest.
 
The idea is complete nonsense. Climate variation is as old as the world, and at many points in history the carbon dioxide content of the atmosphere has been significantly higher than it is now. ("Global warming" is, however, a huge industry in its own right). Want a quick rundown of media-sponsored crises that I can remember off the top of my head? Here goes: oil shortages, an ice age (that's right, a new ice age was predicted not so long ago), global famine, an AIDS pandemic, killer flu, SARS, overpopulation. "Global warming", conveniently renamed "climate change" when the warming didn't show up is only the latest unproven idea.



You forgot the Y2K Bug, and the killer bees.


One wonders how we put to rest the last ice age without global warming.

And don't forget that the idiot who invented global warming also professed to have invented the internet.
 
Tiz better to say nothing and be thought a moron than to express your incompetence and remove all doubt.

You forgot the Y2K Bug, and the killer bees.


One wonders how we put to rest the last ice age without global warming.

And don't forget that the idiot who invented global warming also professed to have invented the internet.

Say what?


Killer bees still pose a threat in the southern states, as mentioned earlier in this thread, the last ice age is still around, and Gore did not say he invented the Internet. Three for three, well done.
 
I'm not guessing. Mann was the lead author of the Observed Climate Variability and Change chapter in the IPCC's 2001 report, and his hockey stick graph was central to the findings in the Summary for Policy Makers.

Regarding your suggestion that climate researchers are prepared to defend Mann ... well, that may be so. They do it at their own peril, as Mann's work has been thoroughly discredited (and we already know what happened to the IPCC predictions that were based on Mann's work. I'm sure you recall the discussion about the IPCC's predictions being "spectacularly wrong").

As for Lomborg, I'm not all that familiar with the debates about him. But I don't need Lomborg to defend my views. The real-world evidence speaks clearly (and loudly) for itself.

No, you are wrong. Mann's work is still respected and he's still working away. The climategate hackers fake scandal was investigated by a couple of organizations and found to bullshit and Mann was absolved of all wrongdoing. Now Mann is actually suing those who've been slandering him and is now threatening to take out the National Review for shoddy lobbying masking as reporting.

Meanwhile, Lomborg has a site dedicated to his hard work.
http://www.lomborg-errors.dk/
 
Still waiting for groggy to explain that footnote to all us less intelligent lower lifeforms :happy:

At least you're starting to realize that you're not that smart.
Now if you could make the next, and very tricky, step in the logic and realize that you'e not smart enough to judge whose research is real and whose is just lobbying.
 
Tiz better to say nothing and be thought a moron than to express your incompetence and remove all doubt.

Then why are you posting here?
Are you smarter then AK an moviefan, think you can read and understand the footnote of death?
 

Wow, an article from 2010, a commentary from Steven McIntyre who is tied to CGX energy and a video from Judith Curry, hired to forecast the weather for another oil company and who's work is known to be shoddy.


I still need to ask, why do you think you're smart enough to be able to judge the science when you're not smart enough to read a single footnote of the IPCC reports nor to be able to distinguish between lobbyists like McIntyre and scientists like Mann?

How many times do you need to be embarrassed before you'll realize you don't know what you're talking about?
 
...and scientists like Mann?

"Scientists" like Mann? That may be the funniest thing you ever posted.

Let's look at a current example that tells us everything we need to know about the fake "Nobel laureate".

In response to the George Will column the other day that spoke about Albert Einstein's rejection of the Nazis' "consensus"-like reporting, Mann posted the following on Facebook:

"Paging Jeff Bezos: George Will Compares Climate Scientists To Nazis" via @ClimateProgress #GeorgeWill #ClimateChange

https://www.facebook.com/MichaelMannScientist

Say what? Will did no such thing. The point was about the claims of a "consensus" and the fact that Einstein understood that it only takes one scientist who is right to disprove a theory.

Unless Mann is a complete idiot, we have to assume that he understood Will's point and he knows the comment he posted on Facebook is false.

Much like the false comments he posted on Twitter the other day about a journalist that he had to retract.

Or his claims in a legal filing that he was a "recipient" of the Nobel Peace Prize (http://legaltimes.typepad.com/files/michael-mann-complaint.pdf).

Or his current legal papers citing alleged quotes about his "exoneration" that actually come from reports that had nothing to do with him (http://www.skepticink.com/prussian/2014/02/28/mann-overboard/).

Groggy can post all the ad hominem attacks that he likes. I stand by my earlier point. If the climate researchers continue to stick with Mann, they do so at their own peril.
 
Last edited: